Re: new Porcupine Tree album

In nearly every interview, Steven Wilson is asked whether or not Porcupine Tree will ever get back together. And his answer is usually the same: not likely, but never say never. So I was genuinely surprised to see news of a new PT album next year.

Details.

I know, I know - it's a tale as old as time. Band says they're probably never getting back together, then do. But considering how well Wilson's solo career has been going, there was no need to do it to shore up the retirement account or anything. Of course, the music on this record was begun right after what we thought was their final album back in 2009, so it's not exactly new. But they're gonna tour it and everything, so even if this doesn't last beyond this one album (and the title, Closure/Continuation, hints it might not), they're putting everything into it, so they're not treating this music as mere scraps. The new single certainly isn't.

I received an email about this the other day. Very exciting news! Any clue who's paying bass? Colin Edwin is not in the picture and there's no mention in the article.

My guess would be Nick Beggs from Wilson’s solo band (and Kajagoogoo, of course). Or maybe Gavin Harrison will talk his King Crimson bandmate Tony Levin into doing it. Or it could be someone new.

I don’t know why Edwin isn’t participating. I did read an interview recently where he talks about his children - maybe he didn’t want to commit to a tour. I’m sure the answers will come out at some point.

You're talking about the tour. I would expect he's out on that. But I'm wondering if played on the album?

If this is music developed right after The Incident, I would assume so. We shall see.

My guess would be Nick Beggs from Wilson’s solo band (and Kajagoogoo, of course). Or maybe Gavin Harrison will talk his King Crimson bandmate Tony Levin into doing it. Or it could be someone new.

I don’t know why Edwin isn’t participating. I did read an interview recently where he talks about his children - maybe he didn’t want to commit to a tour. I’m sure the answers will come out at some point.