Welcome! Log In Create A New Profile

Advanced

CD revival (redux)

CD revival (redux)
September 08, 2026 05:03AM
Grab your Discmans out of storage. CDs are back, baby.
Washington Post: Collectors and K-pop enthusiasts are driving a growth in sales that is outpacing vinyl’s.

As someone who bought a CD just this weekend, I think this article captures some of the relevant items that make CDs still attractive, but one of the most basic is playing a record straight through and experiencing it as an album and not just a collection of songs that can be taken and decontextualized. Yes, vinyl does that too, but the inconvenience and lack of portability make LPs almost more of a fetish object rather than an easy source of music at this point.

Good point about audio quality but fear lots of people listen to music over Bluetooth speakers and headphones, which negate any improvement in sound over a CD versus streaming or MP3s.

And my car still has a CD player, although I fear it's the last car I own that will. (I truly believe people would buy a modern car infotainment system with Apple CarPlay and mapping that also had a CD player and cassette deck, if someone sold it.)
Re: CD revival (redux)
September 08, 2026 06:46PM
Top-quality portable CD players are definitely tough to find - how I wish my trusty blue Panasonic SL-CT470 was still working! - but it's also misleading for that Washington Post article to claim that no major retailer is selling CD players anymore.

I'm not sure if Blu-ray discs are considered a niche product the way LaserDiscs were (compared to mass market products like VHS tapes and DVD's in their heyday) but I never see CD revival articles mentioning Blu-ray players, and if you have a Blu-ray player, you essentially have a universal disc player that can also play DVD's and CD's. This is exactly what I've been using for the past 16 years, and before that I was using a DVD player because they all played CD's too. Sony and Panasonic still make good Blu-ray players, so these aren't boutique products, any major electronics store should have one.

Similarly, when video game consoles requiring discs took off, many of them played other kinds of discs and it wasn't unusual for me to see friends use them as their all-in-one player. However thumb drives on these consoles may have replaced discs by now, either that or downloadable apps or subscription services - the goal now for so many companies is to eliminate physical media so that nobody owns a copy of anything and everyone has to keep paying for something they use - but that makes inexpensive items like CD's all the more appealing.

Just to add one warning that gives me pause because I don't want to cause an unwarranted panic, collectors are now noticing disc rot as a major issue. Some have misinterpreted this as meaning all CD's and DVD's are going bad - that's not true at all - but once in a blue moon you'll have a pressing plant that starts manufacturing discs improperly and unfortunately given how many discs they press and how long it may be before they correct things, it ends up being thousands or tens of thousands of discs of any given title.

Overseas in the UK/EU, there was only one major instance I can think of that "fortunately" happened during CD's peak, so when the problem was caught, people were able to get free replacements because that particular plant was still operating (and no longer pressing faulty discs) and it was the plant's obligation to replace their faulty goods. Here in the U.S., there was a problem with Discovery Systems which made THE worst CD's I've ever seen - I think these were mainly Warner Bros. CD's, and I noticed this because I bought THREE copies of New Order's Technique, all original issues made at Discovery, and they all skipped like crazy despite having no marks on them. (I ended up buying an original UK pressing made at a UK plant, and it plays with no problems.) I noticed the same problem with Rhino's CD release of Phil Spector's Christmas album, also made at Discovery. The album has since been claimed by ABKCO and then Sony, and both companies used a different plant. To be clear, all of these probably played fine for quite a long time after they were made, but I was buying them in the 2000s or 2010s, and while that is a long time later, I don't think people are generally okay with an album becoming completely unplayable less than 20 years later.

The big problem now is Warner's long-defunct Olyphant plant. There was a lot of press coverage about Warner and Rhino DVD releases starting to fail, and they all came from that specific plant. Some of these were music DVD's like a Paul McCartney/Wings set, some of the DVD's Neil Young was packaging with his Archives releases, the much-hyped Led Zeppelin DVD set (which they really need to upgrade to Blu-ray anyway), but people are starting to notice problems with CD's pressed at that plant too, most likely made around the 2000s. The first people to sound the alarm were Grateful Dead collectors - I'm not one of them (though I do like the Dead enough to own three albums and a generous compilation) and I'm sorry to say if you've been collecting all their official live releases, you may find that a lot of them have become unplayable. Again, this is one single plant that worked specifically with Warner Bros., but Warner released a TON of titles to put it mildly.



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 09/08/2026 06:53PM by belfast.
Reply Quote
Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.

Click here to login