Welcome! Log In Create A New Profile

Advanced

The Death Of Disco Was An Inside Job

The Death Of Disco Was An Inside Job
August 16, 2026 07:05PM
I've revived my blog for the purpose of posting original articles detailing some of my more uncommon musical observations.. Starting off with a controversial topic, but I very carefully considered the points I raised . Lots of revisions! Still, I kinda put off actually publishing this for a bit. You know how those "internet people" are...
[musicformaniacs.blogspot.com]
Reply Quote
Re: The Death Of Disco Was An Inside Job
August 17, 2026 03:22PM
Great post, Fab.

One of the things I wasn't really prepared for about growing old was watching the official history of things I lived through being written, and seeing how often that the history didn't quite jibe with reality as I experienced it. "Disco was killed by racism and homophobia" is one of the historical "facts" that has driven me the most nuts, as it's been stated so often with 100% assurance by people who are generally too young to speak with the rock-solid authority they seem to believe they have on the subject. It's a viewpoint that allows the holders of that viewpoint to feel superior to the benighted, backwards scum of the 70s.

The thing this historical point of view is completely lacking is any understanding whatsoever of what living in the monoculture was like. They have no clue how completely omnipresent disco was from roughly 1974-1980. There was pretty much no aspect of culture not touched by disco. The same people who insist that disco was definitely done in by homophobic racists do not hesitate to declare themselves to have "superhero fatigue," apparently having no clue that superhero movies have been a hell of a lot easier to avoid than disco was in its heyday. "People just get sick of things when they've been popular for too long" is a perfectly acceptable explanation for most things falling out of fashion, but "disco was killed by racist homophobes" confers a feeling of superiority on people who hold that point of view, so it's very appealing to hold it.

Plus, it completely ignores the fact that people in general had no huge beef with disco when it was closer to its underground roots in Gay and Black subcultures. The masses didn't rebel against it until it was co-opred by rich white asshats who took obscene pleasure in manning the velvet rope to keep anyone too average looking from getting inside to snort coke alongside Andy, Liza and Jerry Hall while the sweet sounds of "I Was Made For Loving You" wafted through the sea of glitterati. That's what people hated about disco. It wasn't Harold Melvin and the Blue Notes.

Anyway, it's been weird watching history being written, especially when it seems to be written incorrectly.
Reply Quote
Re: The Death Of Disco Was An Inside Job
August 17, 2026 07:20PM
Ah, breno you reminded me that I meant to write something about how grating the rich snob aspect was to normal people in Kansas who hadn't a chance in hell of getting into Studio 54. That elitist message of "Hey, losers! Look at all the fun THESE people are having. Sucks to be you!" was all over the radio, and in every magazine they picked up. Gee, why would there have been a backlash..?

It is indeed fascinating to see history re-written before our very eyes. Certainly makes one question the accuracy of the "history" we've all been taught..
Re: The Death Of Disco Was An Inside Job
August 20, 2026 04:41PM
FWIW, the funk episode of Rock & Roll (U.S. title) / Dancing in the Street: a Rock and Roll History (U.K. title) covers the disco craze, and they make the negative aspects clear, from the way it was taking over the culture ("Ethel Merman [had] a disco record") to Clinton's take on how reductive it could be ("they narrowed it down to one beat...to try to corner the market on a particular music...and when you do that with rhythm, you talking about something that would get on your nerve? Try to make love with one stroke...boy, they'll tell you to fax it in.")

All in the first few minutes of this clip:

[www.youtube.com]
Re: The Death Of Disco Was An Inside Job
August 17, 2026 07:45PM
Yeah, that exclusionary image of disco, as I saw it on shows like American Bandstand and The Midnight Special, really bothered me more than the music itself did. I liked some of the songs I heard, and I did like to dance, but I associated the style with the so-called cool kids, not with "rich elitists." (As a teenager in the '70s, I wouldn't have recognized a rich elitist if he'd run over me in his Bentley.) I'd see all the attractive young people dancing on TV — all of them well-groomed, with stylish clothes and clear complexions — and just took it for granted that this was a party I wouldn't be welcome to join. It wasn't until I actually went to a dance club for the first time that I realized this didn't have to be the case. I could dance well, and I was reasonably well-dressed for the occasion; that was all it took.

As for racism and homophobia, well, it seems to me that if those had been serious factors, then disco wouldn't have gotten nearly as popular or pervasive as it became. An inside job? I'm siding more with the explanation that Reno endorsed: disco had its rise, its peak and its fall, just like any musical fad. I can't say I missed it very much when it was gone; dance clubs remained open, and opportunities to go out dancing remained available.
Re: The Death Of Disco Was An Inside Job
August 17, 2026 09:14PM
I was born in 1972, so my firsthand memories of disco date from childhood. There's definitely a degree of presentism to the current discourse about disco. But when I read about people who hated it back then, culminating in "Disco Demolition Night," there's a degree of anger that doesn't seem justified by the music, even if you dislike it. They were pissed off by it as a cultural phenomenon, but those perceptions shift quickly when it's no longer part of the mainstream. Monoculture is much easier to avoid now. Ella Langley's "Choosin' Texas" has been #1 for the last 4 & 1/2 months, but how many Americans have never knowingly heard it?

Vince Aletti's book THE DISCO FILES, which compiles weekly columns written between 1973-8, tells a story where DJs started out seeking Afrobeat and Latin imports and playing danceable deep cuts from Seals & Crofts to one where the market was overflowing with bandwagon-jumping disco records by late 1976.



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 08/17/2026 09:18PM by steevee.
Reply Quote
Re: The Death Of Disco Was An Inside Job
August 18, 2026 03:01AM
A little over a month after Disco Demolition Night, "My Sharona" hit #1 on the U.S. charts. It stayed there for six weeks. It was so omnipresent during the summer and fall of 1979 that it spawned the Knuke the Knack movement, which sold a decent amount of t-shirts and buttons. I think I had a Knuke the Knack button, which I would love to find now. People literally wanted to punch Doug Fieger in the face. That was for one song that was annoyingly popular for a couple of months.

Multiply that annoyance by several years of absolute, inescapable cultural domination and I still don't see DDN as anything much more than a statement of "we are so very sick of this stuff."

Disco Demolition Night became a legend because it was such a fiasco. Setting off explosives and causing a riot in the middle of a baseball field between games of a double header is a batshit insane thing to have been allowed to happen. Had it gone off without a hitch, or been something more contained, like running over a pile of records with a steamroller, it would be a forgotten little blip in history, kinda like Knuke the Knack. But because it was a huge, loud fiasco, it made a bigger impression on the historical record which caused later learned minds to have to analyze its broader cultural importance and "shock jock who lost his job because his radio station changed to a disco format does something shock jockish in response" wasn't as resonant as "ignorant white folks lynch an entire genre for being queer and black but thank God we're more enlightened now."

The flip side no one mentions is that the white folks at DDN were probably consuming more Black culture than most of the people criticizing them now do. It rarely gets brought up how massively huge shows like Good Times, Sanford & Son, The Jeffersons, Fat Albert and What's Happenin'? were in the 70s. What's the last majority Black oriented TV show to gain a comparable audience share to those shows? Hipsters loved Atlanta, but that's about it. The monoculture contributed greatly to disco fatigue, but it also put Black entertainers into the living rooms of white folks nationwide, and the white folks didn't blow up their TVs because they saw Jimmy Walker on them. Nowadays, with the death of the monoculture, it's a heck of a lot easier to only seek out your own ilk.

And anyhow, disco music never died anyway, it just changed clothes to fit the times, incorporated a few different beats into its vocabulary and now we're celebrating New Order being inducted into the RRHOF. But New Order's music was never played in discos. It was played in "dance clubs." Places where pre-recorded music is played at loud volumes while people dance the night away buzzed out of their gourds on their drug of choice. Totally different from disco!
Re: The Death Of Disco Was An Inside Job
August 18, 2026 06:24AM
> New Order's music was never played in discos.
> It was played in "dance clubs."

And the Pet Shop Boys -- a band that (correct me if I'm wrong) has a wide fan base within gay culture -- can release remix albums called Disco, Disco 2, Disco 3 and so on, and nobody bats an eye.
Bip
Re: The Death Of Disco Was An Inside Job
August 18, 2026 01:55PM
Really good (and brave?) post Mr fab, and savvy comments by Delvin steevee and breno.

My two cents:

my simplistic mother thought the village people were wonderful —- totally clueless about any gay overtones. I think all of America just saw them as performers whose gimmick was to dress like Indians cops and construction workers and sing/ dance in unison, nothing more.

Black music was ALL OVER Kasey Kasem’s American top 40 in the 70s, pre disco. Just look at the charts. I listen to replays of his show every Sunday morning and am always happily surprised to hear something like ‘troglodyte’. (It was the early mtv videos that shunned black artists, not the top 40 charts.) White folks had been digging black music long before the ‘disco scourge’ came about.

Disco did indeed get lousy, overproduced with strings and horns. My grandmother had an Ethyl Merman disco album. Love Boat reruns reveal how bad it got. It’s not like all disco stayed as cool as Donna Summer’s ‘I feel love’.
Reply Quote
Re: The Death Of Disco Was An Inside Job
August 18, 2026 11:57PM
I do remember roller skating to disco music when I was very young (79-80) and I was somewhat conscious of the fact that disco was all about escapism, just turning inward and forgetting about the problems of the world (which were aplenty during the late 70's and early 80's). From what I gathered, the end of disco wasn't really about racism and homophobia; more likely, I think, is that disco's dominance had put rock 'n' roll on the back burner of the radio airwaves and Middle America wanted it's rock music back, a point which punk rock hammered home with it's message about rebellion against (unsympathetic) government and the corruption within it's ranks. The punk ethos was invariably the opposite of disco; action instead of escapism.



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 08/19/2026 01:21AM by Fleeingbandit.
Reply Quote
Re: The Death Of Disco Was An Inside Job
August 19, 2026 02:05AM
Of course, punk was rejected by the U.S. mainstream of the time pretty decisively, with the first band from the punk movement to achieve any sort of success doing so with a disco song.
Reply Quote
zoo
Re: The Death Of Disco Was An Inside Job
August 19, 2026 05:49AM
Disco...dancing to songs about dancing to songs about dancing.

Though I appreciate Mr. Fab's blog entry (and I certainly will go back to read more--nice writing!), I don't see how anyone could be confused about why it didn't last. It was empty and vapid.
Re: The Death Of Disco Was An Inside Job
August 19, 2026 05:58AM
You would think so, zoo, but there's been this narrative for some years now that disco was doing great, was widely beloved, until it was killed by a dastardly racist/homophobic conspiracy. Apparently, a PBS documentary pushed this angle, it's caught on, and hasn't gone away. Even David Byrne said it in his otherwise excellent book "How Music Works." It seems to be becoming canon, so time for us to step up.



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 08/19/2026 06:00AM by MrFab.
Re: The Death Of Disco Was An Inside Job
August 19, 2026 06:22AM
I don't know if it was a PBS doc that pushed the theory - there was an episode of American Experience on the topic, and while it did mention the theory, I felt like it came down fairly solidly on the oversaturation leading to exhaustion angle. But there may have been another PBS doc on the topic that did push the theory more vigorously.

The first place I ever remember encountering the racism/homophobia angle was on the AV Club, of all places. But since then, sites like Pitchfork have trotted it out like it's settled history and its retrograde to disagree with it. Pretty much anytime I see such an article, I note the byline, look up the writer's bio online, and they're invariably born way too late to have had any firsthand experience of the disco era.

And, as Fab said, stuff like that does make one wonder how much history reflects the reality of the people who experienced it.
Re: The Death Of Disco Was An Inside Job
August 19, 2026 08:34PM
I was between nine and eighteen years old during the 70's . All I had to do was take a wood raft tied together with rope, me & my brother (four years my junior) made across a canal, tie it off to a stake we had earlier hammered into the ground on the other side. From there I was on my own. Alan was too young, so I sent him home. Now, it's a simple matter of walking across a field that held an occasional cow or three, hop a barbed wire fence and voila Hollywood Blvd. Later in high school, I learned to stop boasting about my unfailable route to the stadium. It wasn't because my friends at school warned me that my method was dangerous. No, they always wanted me to slow my efforts to my destination, STOP and look for magic mushrooms. "Fuck that shit" (kinda funny now, because I've heard that magic mushrooms are supposed to grow under cow shit) I thought, I ain't got time for that. I gotta get a ride to the show .

I knew what ROCK MUSIC was, and I wanted it LOUD and LIVE. Ticket prices were between $4 to $6 at the Sportatorium. $10 for Pink Floyd (or Led Zeppelin at Miami Baseball Stadium) From age 15 - 17, (1976-78) I saw probably 25 concerts. Patti Smith, Alice Cooper, Queen, Cheap Trick ('78 In b/w & color), okay, that was Gusman THEATRE , I think) this is really hard for my 15 yr old self to admit here, KISS '76 Destroyer -first concert/ ninth grade, (I feel like I'm peeling off layers of skin here), ELP (not bad, how, I wish it was THE NICE instead) AC/DC '76, Uriah Heep, ELO (them lasers was cool!) So many more, it really doesn't matter. Except that I was always safe. People were so cool to me. Someone /anyone would pick me up hitching a ride, and tell me "hey man, if you need a ride back, just meet me here after the concert" . How fucking cool is that?
Double (FF) Fast Forward... 50 years.

Looking back, I think there was an extremely large group of young people that understood ROCK music as an important and unifying spiritual gift to be passed on to theve next generation. I' ve always felt as if I was experiencing a cultural rite of passage. I felt then, and still feel today, that I am part of a group of people that value artistic expression over propaganda. Don't get me wrong, I'm not above Kathleen popping in a Donna Summer CD in our car player (I swear and shit you not, that was the Trouser Press Fan Club Prez' only requirement in purchasing our latest vehicle) but I could never embrace another genre of music the way rock music has embraced me.



Edited 7 time(s). Last edit at 08/21/2026 10:03AM by STEVE.
Reply Quote
zoo
Re: The Death Of Disco Was An Inside Job
August 20, 2026 07:57AM
Ah, the late, not-so-great Hollywood Sportatorium. I also attended a few shows there in the late '80s when I my friends and I became old enough to drive up from South Miami. We always called it the "smogatorium" for reasons you can guess. The place was on it's last legs, and if there ever was a glory days for that building, I'm guessing it was during the time frame STEVE mentioned.
Re: The Death Of Disco Was An Inside Job
August 20, 2026 11:02AM
Great memories you've shared, Steve. I do believe that the "extremely large group of young people that understood ROCK music as an important and unifying spiritual gift" was the monoculture that Reno and Steevee have mentioned in this thread.

I never hitchhiked to a concert, but then, I was the younger brother (by three years). Rather than sending me home, though, my brother consistently brought me along, for all sorts of events, provided they were all-ages. (I never had any rancor over being excluded for that reason; we both knew I never could have passed for over 18). He knew that he could count on me to step up when needed. He knew I wouldn't slow him down or cramp his style. And he knew that if he overdid it, he could count on me to take the wheel and get us home safely.

The music was definitely an important, unifying spiritual gift we shared, and still is. Of course, he wasn't "passing it on" to me ... but I did a little bit of that later, taking our sister (seven years my junior) to her earliest shows (ZZ Top, Run-DMC/Beastie Boys, and of course, our beloved B-52's). I took her to see several of the cooler local bands when I was still in college. (The director of the student center knew my sis was under 18, but also knew I'd keep an eye on her. And she had absorbed a crucial lesson from her big brothers: if she kept her nose clean, she'd be welcome to come see the next cool band.) I took her to The Rocky Horror Picture Show her first time. And we used to go dancing quite a bit too.
Re: The Death Of Disco Was An Inside Job
August 21, 2026 10:07AM
I certainly feel very lucky to have survived my naivety. Maybe, to warn people not to do what I did!
Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.

Click here to login