Welcome! Log In Create A New Profile

Advanced

The Paranoid Style, Comet Ping Pong, Washington DC, February 28, 2026

The Paranoid Style, Comet Ping Pong, Washington DC, February 28, 2026
March 07, 2026 06:21AM
The Paranoid Style
Comet Ping Pong, Washington DC, February 28, 2026


Another DC band, another one about which I've written in the past. The Paranoid Style is a critics’ band in every sense of the word, because it is a band led by a critic, whose music is also adored by critics.

As I have written before, Elizabeth Nelson is a fantastic rock critic and commentator, and she also happens to lead a rock band. I have seen the Paranoid Style playing with fellow DC band friends and allies, but this is the first time I've actually seen them as a headlining act, such as anyone can describe a band playing at Comet Ping Pong after 11 o'clock to a group of 40 something-year-olds.

Because of Nelson’s writerly voice and resume, she gets media attention and acclaim outsized to her relative sales audience. NPR just did a seven-minute radio story about her newest album, Known Associates, which I doubt they do for most bands that can get 50 people into a ping-pong parlor on a Friday night. Bands led by music writers are always going to get attention from other music writers (hello Pet Shop Boys, Pretenders, etc.) and I think the NPR story is an exercise in hyperbole, but I agree that the Paranoid Style’s music is getting better and better.

Nelson, wearing a Conway Twitty t-shirt, leaned into semi-ironic country melody, power pop urgency, and prolix and overstuffed lyrical references. I kept thinking of songwriters whom she resembles, and while I don’t think there is a conscious linkage, it did occur to me that both Scott Miller (Game Theory/Loud Family) and Alanis Morrisette paired tuneful and catchy classic pop compositions with complex lyrical structures and sometimes oblique references, albeit with wildly different commercial outcomes.

Most of the set at Comet Ping Pong was from Known Associates, her fifth full-length (“on Bar None Records, www.bar-none.com, the place to go to buy records”) but the Paranoid Style has a pretty deep catalogue and they tapped into their older songs as well.

The tricky bit about Nelson is that she’s enormously in debt to classic pop and country song structures, where lyrical economy is prized, but her own lyrical voice is profoundly verbose. Sometimes it works fine, but (like Elvis Costello, whom she resembles quite a bit as a songwriter) sometimes she has so many ideas that she never remotely approaches scansion. And tbqh she’s just not a great singer; she gets around that with urgency and speech-singing at times, but that weak singing can undercut a classic country song, like when she does Lucinda Williams’ “Passionate Kisses,” a composition whose lyrical economy and concision can really only be carried by a great vocal (Lucinda or Mary Chapin Carpenter).

On the other hand, “Shut Up and Deal” shows that Nelson can figure out that tricky marriage of country-pop form with snark and erudition, as the NPR radio piece spotlighted.

Hey, pretty baby. Are you ready for me? I'm a Long Island girl living in D.C.
I'm a tall drink of water standing 5-foot-2. I'm an engineer's daughter. I've been peer reviewed.
Hey there coyote, do you like to wager? Do you like it in minor or do you like it in major?
They're going to make you an offer. They're going to give you a pager.
They're going to call you a doctor. You're going to owe them a favor.


Half the fun of the Paranoid Style is noting the informed allusions that run through Nelson’s songwriting, both lyrical and musical. (Count the lyrical citations starting with “Shut Up and Deal”’s opening Steve Earle rip.) She’s a critic first, and namedrops and in-jokes come through the songwriting continually, like “White Wine Whatever,” which kinda seems like a poke at upper-middle-class liberal women and their political activism but might be more generally about cultural slumming. 



Standing at the table, talkin' Cain and Abel.
Are you ready for the country? Are you fully unstable? White wine whatever.
Talking out of school about a government text. Who do you answer to?
Whatcha think's going to happen next? White wine whatever.
Keeping profits in mind, keeping working folks apart. The boot of oppression is the expression of their art.
Baby what's your name? Is that even germane? Are you Northern Virginia or “Virginia Plain”? White wine whatever.


Opening for the Paranoid Style were Dot Dash, the long-running and much-loved DC power-pop and punk-pop ensemble. I’ve seen them in a lot of contexts, mostly opening for touring bands at places like DC9 and the Black Cat. I don’t know their own work that well, but I’ve enjoyed them in concert before. There is always a lot of energy and catchy riffs in spades; I just wish most power-pop bands had better singers. These are some 50-something-year-old DC dudes whose love of the form is sincere, starting from the Wire reference in their band name, and their musical execution is good, but their singing and lyrics drag them down a bit.
Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.

Click here to login