Welcome! Log In Create A New Profile

Advanced

Imitation: the sincerest form of flattery

Imitation: the sincerest form of flattery
October 01, 2022 09:49AM
Bands/artists who are blatantly imitative of other artists?

Some, of course, are like Kingdom Come or Greta Van Fleet: they make themselves look ridiculous by insistently denying that they're aping their influences, even though you'd have to be deaf to miss the mimicry. But others, from the Stray Cats to Interpol to Muse, have been unmistakably imitative of their influences, but have come up with results that still work on their own terms.

And yes, this is for a possible radio show. (My wife suggested the theme.)



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 10/01/2022 09:55AM by Delvin.
ira
Re: Imitation: the sincerest form of flattery
October 01, 2022 10:55AM
Goo goo dolls and mats
Reply Quote
Re: Imitation: the sincerest form of flattery
October 01, 2022 11:58AM
There are artists like Jet, and the Cult, who blatantly steal from various sources, but don’t necessarily sound like one particular band at all times. Some artist tend to sound like the sum of the record collection, e.g.: Cornelius. Which is not necessarily a bad thing if they have a GOOD record collection.

Dwight Youkum has the Buck/Merle thing down pat.

We had a discussion on here once about Birthday Party clone bands like Le Muerte, Gallon Drunk, Inca Babies
Re: Imitation: the sincerest form of flattery
October 02, 2022 09:10PM
Menswear and Elastica - Wire.
I've mentioned it here before, I think, but Elastica insisted it came about because them and Wire were a "mutual admiration society". This was refuted by Wire who basically said they wouldn't be caught dead listening to Elastica.
Re: Imitation: the sincerest form of flattery
October 04, 2022 07:47AM
> Elastica insisted it came about because them and Wire were a "mutual admiration society".

Oh man, I never heard about that. If it's true ... sheesh, what a foolish claim for anyone in Elastica to make. I mean, that's just inviting a hard rebuke from the band you're imitating. They could've just acknowledged Wire, saying they enjoyed & admired the band, and left it at that.

A real pity, because, derivative or not, Elastica's debut is one of my favorite albums of the '90s. Truly an all-killer-no-filler album.
Re: Imitation: the sincerest form of flattery
October 04, 2022 02:21PM
They were really good live when they toured their debut as well, although their set didn't go far beyond a half hour. The guy next to me calling out "Outdoor Miner!" for the encore thought he was pretty funny.
Re: Imitation: the sincerest form of flattery
October 05, 2022 04:30AM
Yeah, I got to see Elastica on their 1995 tour as well. I remember them as being a really terrific live band, and being really enthusiastic about finding a good audience in America (or at least in Denver).
Re: Imitation: the sincerest form of flattery
October 03, 2022 04:44AM
I am going to go with Sigue Sigue Sputnik. Sound kind of like Suicide and the look kind of T-Rex, NY Dolls etc. I must confess at the time of release I did not know the music of Suicide. However once I discovered the Suicide album later in life I immediately heard the influences. The very first time I heard Cheree I was like, man this would be a good SSS song if it were just a tad faster! I played the Sigue album to death when it came out and the various LP singles I picked up.



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 10/03/2022 04:45AM by upper90.
Reply Quote
Re: Imitation: the sincerest form of flattery
October 04, 2022 06:43PM
Sigue had a much more bubblegum sound than Suicide. They came across as a fake band from a movie like BLADE RUNNER to me
Re: Imitation: the sincerest form of flattery
October 03, 2022 05:20AM
There are lots of early Pavement songs that sound like The Fall. Mark E. Smith was reportedly not impressed. Several of their early their album covers also take a lot of inspiration from Hex Enduction Hour.
Bip
Re: Imitation: the sincerest form of flattery
October 03, 2022 11:31AM
Well, utopia did that whole album where each song tried to mimic a different era of the Beatles. (Deface the music, right?). Of course, that was intentionally tongue in cheek.

Camouflage sounded alot like depeche mode… ‘the great commandment’, no?

The band Komputer is obviously aping kraftwerk.
Re: Imitation: the sincerest form of flattery
October 03, 2022 12:08PM
there really was a band called Deep Jimi And The Zep Creams. I could never bring myself to check them out...
Reply Quote
Re: Imitation: the sincerest form of flattery
October 04, 2022 04:06AM
Deep Jimi & the Zep Creams! One of my co-workers lent me a CD by that band, back in the day. They didn't sound anything like any of their namesakes. Basically a funky, very obviously white-boy-generated groove, like a very poor man's Red Hot Chili Peppers, or like the Spin Doctors without any actually decent songs.

Ohhh jeez, I haven't thought about that band in years! (Which tells you just how memorable they sounded when I did hear them.) If I sound enthusiastic, it's much less about the band than about the other memories surrounding that particular time.

POSTSCRIPT: I never saw Deep Jimi live, so I can't say what they were like onstage. I've heard from more than one source that Royal Crescent Mob were a top-notch live act.



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 10/04/2022 06:32AM by Delvin.
Re: Imitation: the sincerest form of flattery
October 04, 2022 05:58AM
That sounds eerily similar to a band that used to play around the University of Cincinnati quite a bit back in the late the 1980's - Royal Crescent Mob. They were an absolute riot to see live, some of the best shows I have seen honestly. They had a legion of fans in college towns - RC Mob!
Re: Imitation: the sincerest form of flattery
October 04, 2022 06:18AM
I saw Royal Crescent Mob in Atlanta in 1987 or so and they were indeed an insane live band. I've got a couple of their records and the one called Omerta is actually pretty good. So still maybe a poor man's Chili Peppers (at least then when the Chili Peppers were still making good records), but WAY better than the goddamn Spin Doctors!

Back to the subject at hand, there were of course a ton of bands in the Southeast (and likely elsewhere) aping R.E.M. in the 80s, though I always thought that both Dreams So Real and Miracle Legion were unfairly tagged as R.E.M. imitators.
Re: Imitation: the sincerest form of flattery
October 04, 2022 06:31AM
Oh jeez! You touched a nerve there! I can't vouch for other cities, but that Hib-Tone single hit like an atom bomb in 1982! Before R.E.M. even got signed to I.R.S. there were clone bands in Orlando! 7000 Gifts. Stumble. When 7000 Gifts were musing over names I thought that Kickstand would have been good, but that fell on deaf ears. By the time that "Murmur" came out" I was already getting sick of R.E.M. I had liked "Radio Free Europe" a lot myself, but never bought a copy since whenever I left my house, I heard it playing …at record stores, parties. I wish I had bought one. Could have seriously flipped that in times of low budget!

Former TP subscriber [81, 82, 83, 84]

[postpunkmonk.com]
For further rumination on the Fresh New Sound of Yesterday®
Re: Imitation: the sincerest form of flattery
October 04, 2022 06:30AM
> There were of course a ton of bands in the Southeast (and likely elsewhere) aping R.E.M. in the 80s ...

Oh yeah. My wife spent her college years checking out a few of those bands regularly. Will & the Bushmen jump to mind.

She & her friends used to jokingly call their college radio station "WREM."
Reply Quote
zoo
Re: Imitation: the sincerest form of flattery
October 04, 2022 08:13AM
Marillion's first album is highly derivative of Genesis, especially with songs like "Garden Party" and "Chelsea Morning," though that influence faded before too long.
Re: Imitation: the sincerest form of flattery
October 04, 2022 10:00AM
I love Robyn Hitchcock, but...Syd Barrett.

An article about Zoogz Rift described him as the "thrift-store Zappa."



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 10/04/2022 10:04AM by MrFab.
Re: Imitation: the sincerest form of flattery
October 04, 2022 10:13AM
The Jam had some imitators, like Secret Affair and the Lambrettas at the turn of the 1980s, and a decade and a half later Ocean Colour Scene and British Sea Power.
Re: Imitation: the sincerest form of flattery
October 04, 2022 02:19PM
> The Jam had some imitators ...

Which is saying something, for a band that got accused of being Who imitators, practically from day one.
Re: Imitation: the sincerest form of flattery
October 26, 2022 05:21PM
This thread caught my attention because a few hours ago I was spinning Steve Hurley & his Cockeyed Rebels album, Human Menagerie, and I was struck with the thought that Jeremy Enigk (not to mention John Lydon) must have also spun that record a few times, and picked up Hurley's phrasing before recording "The Frog Prince"

Then, there's the fact that "Human Menagerie sounds more than a wee bit like early Sparks...



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 10/26/2022 05:30PM by STEVE.
Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.

Click here to login