I don't have a problem with that Killers song. Doesn't mean I like it, but I don't like much of their work (or Springsteen's for that matter, whether they sound like him or not). It's the sincerity of that song which makes it OK for me. Is it heavy handed and overwrought? Of course, but hasn't that been the Killers' MO for a while now?
As for Sharon van Etten...wow. Those are some good songs. I've never heard her music, possibly haven't heard of her period but I can't say for sure. I'll be sure to check out her new album when it comes out later this week. Thanks for sharing!