Welcome! Log In Create A New Profile

Advanced

Pazz n Jop 2017

Pazz n Jop 2017
January 22, 2018 08:13PM
Here's the Village Voice's Pazz n Jop poll results: [www.villagevoice.com]. I guess this is the top 50 list of 2017's music we will see. As much as I admire Robert Christgau, I think he's straining to find something like political salvation in this poll's results (and he should perhaps also check out albums that came out in 2017 from artists as different as Armand Hammer, the Downtown Boys and Roger Waters that didn't make the poll.) Half my top 10 list made the top 40, but no album landed higher than SLEEP WELL BEAST at #14.
Re: Pazz n Jop 2017
January 23, 2018 07:27PM

I think the magic of this poll sort of has sort of been lost in the diversity of pop music. I can remember religiously reading the poll results in the 80s and thinking that the coverage of say REM or X - bands that always ranked high - hinted at a shared experience between fan, band, critic. So the poll was very much a taste maker in that way that now I think you could only find outside the top records maybe.

The War On Drugs - a band with 4 albums I guess seems to me to be the big story here, that's a #3 and a #6 finish for their last 2 releases which leads me to think maybe I didn't listen close enough to either record.........I can't think of a straight up Rock band matching that lately unless I'm just drawing a blank.

Re: Pazz n Jop 2017
January 23, 2018 07:53PM
To be honest, the War On Drugs bore me, and I don't really understand why they are one of the few rock bands who are relatively popular and excite me - they just seem like an indie-filtered take on late '70s AOR. Steve Gunn and Kurt Vile do something similar better. I much prefer Big Thief, Priests or the National, to name three rock bands who made the Pazz n Jop top 40.
Re: Pazz n Jop 2017
January 24, 2018 07:03AM
I liked TWOD when they first came out (or, rather, first broke into national consciousness) - to my ears they sounded like Tom Petty crossed with motorik. I've seen them several times (for a while they seemed to be on the bill of every festival I went to), and sometimes they're great and sometimes not. Their ACL taping was pretty magical, but the gig I'd seen about six months before was awful.

But they have only that one shtick, which reached its apex for me on Lost in the Dream, and I'm over it. I listened to the single from the latest record, thought "meh," and moved on. I suspect the two CDs I have will eventually end up in the "sell" pile, and I'll dial 'em up on Spotify whenever I want to listen to them - which, given my tastes these days, probably wouldn't be very often.

(There's a potential future thread - bands with whom one was especially enamored, but only for a brief period of time.)

I can't get into Kurt Vile. I tried. I bought a "deluxe" version of Smoke Ring For My Halo and was kind of impressed by it, but I never listened to it after the first couple of spins. A pal of mine loved b'lieve i'm goin' down, but I didn't like it at all. I saw him play with said pal at a festival, and thought it was a bad performance, though he loved it. There's a fine line between loose/open and sloppy/careless, and he crosses it for me. (This coming from a Nikki Sudden fan, mind you.) But I know lots of folks whose opinion I really respect who love him, so maybe he'll suddenly jibe with me one day. It's happened.

I like Steve Gunn a lot, but I hear him as more of an electrified American response to the late 60s/early 70s British acid folkies then as similar to what TWOD is doing, though I know he came from the same scene. Someone needs to do a TP entry on him.
Re: Pazz n Jop 2017
January 25, 2018 02:33PM
Quote

I think the magic of this poll sort of has sort of been lost in the diversity of pop music. I can remember religiously reading the poll results in the 80s and thinking that the coverage of say REM or X - bands that always ranked high - hinted at a shared experience between fan, band, critic.

True dat! Tho the alt rock crowd loved some critically-reviled acts (Devo, Nina Hagen, etc), the crits were spot on with the afore-mentioned REM, X, as well as the SST stars, "London Calling," "Metal Box" etc., So there was always a slight disconnect, but at least it felt like the fans and the critics were sharing the same culture. The recent explosion of culture into an infinite enumber of micro-cultures has indeed made being a critics fave fairly useless, as the crits don't pull much weight anymore.



Post Edited (01-25-18 17:02)
Re: Pazz n Jop 2017
January 25, 2018 02:44PM
Wha…??!! Nina Hagen is critically reviled??! Say it isn't so!



Former TP subscriber [81, 82, 83, 84]

[postpunkmonk.com]
For further rumination on the Fresh New Sound of Yesterday®
Re: Pazz n Jop 2017
January 25, 2018 02:58PM
Well, "Dean" Christgau only bothered to review one of her albums, the masterwork "Nunsexmonkrock." He gave it a C+, writing
"Hagen is one of those Yurrupean artistes who consent to perform "rock" because it's vunderful theater. Big of her with her operatic training and all, dontcha think?" No, I don't think - for one thing, I don't believe she even had any voice lessons.

He similarly dismissed The Cramps, The Dickies, etc. Like I said, there was always a bit of a disconnect.
Re: Pazz n Jop 2017
January 26, 2018 02:19PM
You're spot on. "Nunsexmonkrock" was indeed a masterwork! I guess DEVO were hated because they hailed from the midwest. Like Lux from The Cramps, now that I think of it. Biased much? The midwest was primary in building the foundations of post-punk. Pere Ubu are peerless in this regard. They were so far ahead of so many for so long, it's not funny.



Former TP subscriber [81, 82, 83, 84]

[postpunkmonk.com]
For further rumination on the Fresh New Sound of Yesterday®
Re: Pazz n Jop 2017
January 28, 2018 03:50PM
I'm currently reading Rip It Up and Start Again, Simon Reynolds' book on postpunk, and just finished the chapter on Akron/Cleveland. Reynolds points out (backed up by interviews with Mark Mothersbaugh and Jerry Casale) that Devo essentially rejected everything that came before - from the blues- and folk-based composition style that ruled rock & roll to the peace-and-love idealism of the hippie hordes from which many rock critics sprang.

So Dave Marsh and his generation of folks for whom rock & roll was still strongly connected to both black music and teenage rebellion had no context in which to place Devo's mockingly sneering deconstruction of rock. To them it was a gimmicky fuck you to everything they believed in. No wonder they hated Devo.

I'd argue that the generation after them, and subsequent generations of critics (and fans) since, got it. If there's any hatred there, it's due to the band turning its form into formula and allowing itself to be peddled as a new wave nostalgia act.
Re: Pazz n Jop 2017
January 28, 2018 06:28PM
All of that is implicit in their cover of "Satisfaction," which I think was their first single. Reynolds also makes the point that they were disillusioned ex-hippies, I believe, radicalized in a completely different way by Kent State. I think you are also right that the generation after Dave Marsh got Devo. Musicians too. St. Vincent's MASSEDUCTION, which was #3 in the 2017 Pazz n Jop poll, reminds me of a lot of FREEDOM OF CHOICE/NEW TRADITIONALISTS-era Devo, except that she plays more lead guitar.
Re: Pazz n Jop 2017
January 25, 2018 07:30PM
Devo were critically reviled? I thought their first and third albums were hits with critics. Personally, I think the first four - and the 1977 live album Rykodisc issued - are brilliant, although I wonder what would've happened if they'd stuck to the more rock-oriented sound of the first two. I've actually never heard Hagen.

Looking over Pazz n Jop over the years, I do notice things like every John Hiatt album made in the '80s charting, while the Birthday Party, Swans and Flesheaters never did. Landmark hip-hop albums like READY TO DIE and ILLMATIC made the list around #34, while the now-forgotten Arrested Development topped the poll. I have one Hiatt album, and it's OK, but I would never put it on one of my top 10 album lists, much less seek out everything else he recorded. The past five years' incarnation of the poll is probably about as eclectic and indie-friendly as it's ever been: I was astonished when a Carcass reunion album landed in the top 40 a few years ago.
Re: Pazz n Jop 2017
January 26, 2018 12:42AM
Oh yeah, critics seemed to froth at the mouth at the mere mention of Devo. "Are We Not Men" only got as high as #20 on the Pazz and Jopp poll, and that would be their only appearance. "Freedom of Choice" wasn't even on the 1980 list. "To say that this critic despises Devo does not go nearly far enough."- Dave Marsh, Rolling Stone
Re: Pazz n Jop 2017
January 26, 2018 08:39AM
To me, Dave Marsh has always been the embodiment of David Lee Roth's famous jibe, "Why do critics like Elvis Costello but hate Van Halen? Because most critics look like Elvis Costello."

I've met plenty of people over the years who found Devo either laughable or puzzling. Indeed, that's part of what heightened my interest: seeing them on SNL when I was in high school, and then hearing all my classmates laugh about the band the following Monday. ("My classmates all are ridiculing Devo, and my classmates are assholes, so logically, this band must be worthwhile.") But this probably is the first time I've been aware of anyone despising Devo.

Re: Pazz n Jop 2017
January 26, 2018 11:08AM
I reviewed a documentary about Frank Zappa two years ago and it showed a brief clip from a music video he made mocking them. I pointed out in my review that by the early '80s, songs like "Beautiful World" and "Freedom of Choice" were much closer to the spirit of satire and social commentary of Zappa's best albums like WE'RE ONLY IN IT FOR THE MONEY and ABSOLUTELY FREE than the music Zappa himself was making at the time. But even Lester Bangs disliked them, I know.
Re: Pazz n Jop 2017
January 26, 2018 01:29PM
I certainly can see someone disliking Devo, or finding them irritating, or dismissing them as gimmicky or as a novelty act of some kind, or just plain not getting them and therefore not bothering to try. And I've heard plenty of stories from punks and new wavers who got called "Devo" as some kind of bullying taunt, back in the day. (I've been on the receiving end of that myself ... although I can't take that one too personally, being that I have the full yellow coveralls and red energy dome in my closet, even as I type.)

But despising Devo? That just seems extreme. Especially since they've played to packed houses every time I've seen them.

Then again, most people I personally know would find it hard to believe I despise Journey and Styx as much as I do.

Re: Pazz n Jop 2017
January 26, 2018 03:33PM
The best I can come up with is that people saw Devo as a lame novelty act who came up with an elaborate marketing plan around themselves that had huge pretentious of social commentary yet didn't have a message in the way, say, the Clash's "Hate and War" or even the Dead Kennedys' "Holiday in Cambodia" did. Early on, I believe they got compared to the Tubes a lot.
Re: Pazz n Jop 2017
February 11, 2018 10:33PM
Quote

guess DEVO were hated because they hailed from the midwest. Like Lux from The Cramps, now that I think of it. Biased much?

I think you're on to something there Monk. So far as TP bands go, the RnR Hall has inducted only two Midwesterners: cheap Trick and the Stooges (three if you count Chrissy Hynde as 1/4 of the Pretenders.) For that matter, they've only inducted one Southern group (REM), one New Englander (Cars), one North-westerner (Nirvana), a few Brits, none from elsewhere in Europe, and a truly random handful of Californians: Zappa, Green Day [!?], Joan Jett, Red Hot Chili Peppers, Tom Waits. Because if you really want the story of California alt, sure, that's it, kids!

But Jann n friends sure do love New Yorkers:

- VU
- Ramones
- Blondie
- Lou Reed solo
- Patti Smith
- Talking Heads

All acts that deserve to be in any Hall of Fame, just pointing out the bias. The American alt score is currently at:
New Yorkers: 6
entire rest of the country: 10



Post Edited (02-12-18 16:03)
Re: Pazz n Jop 2017
February 12, 2018 07:57AM

..............though they'll poke out their eyes clutching their Eagles records before they ever let Johnny Thunders in........whatever!!

Re: Pazz n Jop 2017
February 13, 2018 08:39AM
> If there's any hatred there, it's due to the band turning its form into formula and
> allowing itself to be peddled as a new wave nostalgia act.

Allowing itself? I'd find it hard to believe that they haven't deliberately, intentionally embraced that marketing focus. After all, this is a band that's never been shy about marketing itself ... and I'm sure they recognize their primary market.
Re: Pazz n Jop 2017
February 13, 2018 02:12PM
Perhaps, but they have said in interviews that Warners used to leave them alone - they were a "prestige" band used to boost WB's rep as an 'artists' label' - until "Whip It" hit, and then they took much more of an active interest in Devo, pestering them for another hit.



Post Edited (02-13-18 16:13)
Re: DEVO vs the critics
September 16, 2018 05:56PM
Other reasons the critics hated Devo, according to a recent interview with the spuds in Vice:

"We were roundly criticized and called "sell-outs" by the rock press for creating self-designed merchandise. We were attacked by preeminent music critic, Robert Hilburn, for integrating film with our live show, where characters and objects were in sync with our musical, theatrical performance. He said, “If we wanted videos, we could go to an arcade. Rock 'n' roll or stay home Devo!”
Re: Pazz n Jop 2017
February 13, 2018 02:16PM
After they broke up for the first time, they signed to Enigma and then did a much later reunion album for Warners again from their own free will.
Bip
Re: Pazz n Jop 2017
September 17, 2018 08:01PM
Have you ever just crafted a lengthy post then accidentally deleted it? Ugh.

I was sad to see that the Voice was officially kaput 2 weeks ago (print ended last year, right?). I was never an avid reader but I did enjoy their music coverage when I was able to get my hands on it. For podcast-types, the 'NY Times popcast' just did a nice two parter on the voice's music writing with lots of good interviews (christgau, chuck eddy, etc).

As for this thread...I don't recall devo being maligned by critics. They were treated like, say... the Residents. Not seen as Amazing but critics appreciated their quirkiness/spudliness. Of course, I can't refute the evidence presented so maybe I was just oblivious in that '79-'81 era I discovered them in.

Mid-west bias? Criticism of their merchandising? I really missed all that. Of course I kinda lacked focus as a young teen. (Although seeing the satisfaction video was just as exhilarating as my first sip of Mountain Dew!)
Re: Pazz n Jop 2017
September 18, 2018 07:44AM
The Voice's music coverage went downhill over the past few years, probably due to their budget shrinkage. They went from running 3 or 4 articles/reviews each issue to 1. It's amazing to think that they used to run a monthly column about experimental classical music by Kyle Gann.
Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.

Click here to login