Welcome! Log In Create A New Profile

Advanced

My War

My War
December 18, 2017 12:22AM
Thanks to Spotify, I listened to Black Flag's MY WAR for the first time all the way through. I can only understand why this album was so polarizing and widely hated in 1984 through the narrow-mindedness of the punk scene of the time and the fact that people couldn't be aware that proto-grunge bands like the Melvins and Green River were about to arrive on the scene and make '70s hard rock influences a lot more acceptable. The lyrics are the weak point - the angst is way too overdone and sounds like something an emo band would write now - but Ginn's guitar playing is incredible, at times synthesizing Tony Iommi with way more avant influences like Fred Frith and Sonny Sharrock. This isn't DAMAGED 2, but I'd rather hear the band move on instead of catering to the skinheads in their fan base who wanted to mosh to "Police Story" and "TV Party," and side two seems like a natural step from what bands like Flipper and Swans were doing shortly before, except that MY WAR brings the metal element back to their heaviness. The Iron Maiden comparison from Maximum Rock & Roll is still way off base.
Re: My War
December 18, 2017 03:32AM

There are elements of that record that I like and it definitely influenced a lot too though you wouldn't have known it at the time - but to me that style of music was almost entirely invalidated by Zen Arcade from the same year. That's odd because Husker Du clearly had a time of intense Black Flag wannabe/worship but ended up for my money at least expanding that genre and obliterating it at the same time.

Zen Arcade served as a gateway album for me but very little of it lead to hardcore punk - it just seemed like a new direction. Everything about it seemed fresh and new and Beatles-y classic in a way and My War - seemed ........old in a way - or lacking charm or a way into the music - maybe because it did sound Sabbath-y I guess, not part of the precise moment and that's I think it is down to those lyrics which do make it sound like 2 different bands (one lyrically/one musically) wrestling to get out at times.

Re: My War
December 18, 2017 08:57AM
The lyrics on MY WAR sound more typically "punk" than the music, but after listening to sludge metal bands like Crowbar and Baroness, side two sounds absolutely fine to me, no more of a slog than the Swans' first 2 albums. Yeah, ZEN ARCADE is a better album, but it has a pop sensibility completely missing from MY WAR. Both are rooted in hardcore punk but take it into adventurous new territory. The thing with MY WAR is that I think it sounds much better now that it has influenced so much music than it could have in 1984, especially if people were shocked by Henry Rollins and Greg Ginn growing their hair out.
Re: My War
December 18, 2017 08:43AM
I really liked My War when it came out. As Steevee said, it wasn't Damaged: The Sequel (much less The Next Four Years), so it was a big surprise to me. Side one still holds up well, but side two is a serious slog.

But Zen Arcade ... that album ended up being my personal soundtrack for the second half of 1984. (No mean trick, in a year that also saw the release of Let It Be, Reckoning, Ocean Rain, A Pagan Place and The Unforgettable Fire ... to say nothing of Purple Rain. But a slowly crumbling relationship makes an album like Zen Arcade that much more meaningful.)

Re: My War
December 18, 2017 08:46AM
For years I just stuck with Damaged and a compilation, but I was in my favvorite record store a few months ago and they were playing some instrumental thing that sounded like Last Exit (who I adore). I practically ran up to the counter to ask what it was, and it turned out to be The Process of Weeding Out. It made me think I really need to explore Black Flag's "metal" years.

Greg Ginn lives in Taylor, not far from Austin. Our local alt.weekly has done a feature on him.
Re: My War
December 18, 2017 12:16PM
... no more of a slog than the Swans' first 2 albums.

I rest my case.

Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.

Click here to login