Welcome! Log In Create A New Profile

Advanced

Music critic finds new way to use the word "angular"

Music critic finds new way to use the word "angular"
June 10, 2017 09:39AM
Re: Music critic finds new way to use the word "angular"
June 11, 2017 02:25PM
Yes. But not as funny as the critic who reviewed the Black Crowes latest album without ever listening to it.
Re: Music critic finds new way to use the word "angular"
April 16, 2022 02:23AM
The New Music for Old Punks/New Wavers Facebook page posted this Florida band's video with the description "lots of angular sounds":

<tinyurl.com/2s22w3pp>

That reminded me of this old post, and also made me wonder who the first band was to be described as "angular" and how long the description has been in use. It definitely feels like it was coined during the Post-Punk era to describe Verlaine/Levene/McGeoch/Laughner/Gill/Wilson-derived sounds, but it wouldn't surprise me to find out it was a description lobbed around in jazz or prog circles or something before that.

A quick search on Rock's Backpages shows that the word was used in a 1964 article about Long John Baldry & Rod Stewart, but I don't have a subscription so can't read the context it was used in there. It looks like it appears in a smattering of articles from the late 60s/early 70s, but unsurprisingly really starts showing up in 77-78, with Jon Savage and Paul Morley accounting for multiple useages. Per this search, the earliest TP article that looks to use the word is a Jim Green article on Gentle Giant from 1976 ( which I could look up on this site, no subscription needed) - "In true GG fashion, this is alternated with some angular rock in 4/4 time with some bars of 5/4 thrown in at appropriate lines." So there it is in a prog context a year before it became almost exclusively a descriptor of a certain strain of post-punkery, where no one can precisely explain what it means, but everyone knows it when they hear it.

A search of this site indicates that "angular" turns up in entries for 54 artists, only one of which was written by me - somewhat to my surprise, given how fond I am of amorphous words to attempt to paper over my nonexistent understanding of any actual technical music terms.



Edited 5 time(s). Last edit at 04/16/2022 02:36AM by breno.
Re: Music critic finds new way to use the word "angular"
April 17, 2022 04:24PM
That’s some impressive research there! I would have thought that a Gang of Four review would have been the first use of “angular.”

But this does point to a frustration I’ve often had with music writing- a lack of ability to describe it. Lyrics? Sure, that’s easy. But what does it sound like? I do think music writers should use more music terminology. Does angular mean “discordant”? Or “syncopated”? A combination of the two? Other elements? Music writing doesn’t necessarily have to be like dancing about architecture, as the old line goes.
Re: Music critic finds new way to use the word "angular"
April 19, 2022 09:18AM
I don't think there is a way to embed an image here, but I did a Google nGram search of the words "angular" and "music" and it appears to have risen starting in the late 1970s, peaked in the late 1990s, and stabilized at a lower level in the 2010s and onward. I will have to see if I was one of the malefactors smiling smiley
Re: Music critic finds new way to use the word "angular"
April 19, 2022 01:55PM
If academia was this interesting, I'da gone to grad-school. Interesting where the peak of that usage occurred - but I don't really recall the music of that era being very angular-y? Maybe that was more like the peak of the words (over)usage, not necessarily how music sounded then.
Re: Music critic finds new way to use the word "angular"
April 20, 2022 04:54AM
I would hazard a guess that while the music of the late 90s wasn't particularly what we'd think of as "angular" (the angular music revival started in earnest in the early 00s), it was likely the period when writers who grew up in the post-punk era - when usage of the description first spiked - really began making their presence felt in music writing.

Thus, while the music of the era wouldn't seem to have been overly angular, the music writers of the era had grown up when the word first became ingrained as a common musical description, and were apt to deploy it more readily.
Bip
Re: Music critic finds new way to use the word "angular"
April 21, 2022 03:41AM
This conversation is hilarious. Not without merit, just hilarious.

We all know what sounds angular and what doesn’t, I guess. Yes Gang of 4. I think the guitar riff in ‘space age love song’ by Flock of Seagulls is angular. Why angular and not ‘jumpy’ or ‘skittish’?

Like porn, I know a angular when I (see) hear it.

Seals and Croft, not angular.

Is the opposite of angular ‘flat line’? Something that’s SO smoothed out? As in ‘the Grateful Dead are flat-lined’?
Reply Quote
Re: Music critic finds new way to use the word "angular"
April 21, 2022 04:36AM
Pretty sure Jerry Garcia has been flat-lined for a long time. (Ba-dump-ksssh! Thanks, I'll show myself out.)
Reply Quote
Re: Music critic finds new way to use the word "angular"
April 21, 2022 08:05AM
I would say that the opposite of angular is smooth, but then am confronted with the fact that what appears to be the one entry on this site where I described a band as angular is for the xx, who are, in fact, pretty fucking smooth. But in an angular way.
Re: Music critic finds new way to use the word "angular"
April 21, 2022 12:35PM
Now this has me wondering if anyone ever had a Eureka moment and coined the word "jangular" to describe a band that's both angular and jangly. An online search shows that jangular is indeed a word, but it seems to have something to do with gaming and computering - I don't see any usage of it in a musical context, which seems like a real missed opportunity.

"OH-OK's jangular sound draws equally from R.E.M. and Pylon..."

"Reading, Writing and Arithmetic, the stellar debut from the Sundays, proffers a jangular brand of dream-pop..."

The music scribes of yore let us down by not coining this very useful word.
Bip
Re: Music critic finds new way to use the word "angular"
April 21, 2022 01:36PM
Right…..while Slayer goes for the jugular, Let’s Active go for the jangular.
Re: Music critic finds new way to use the word "angular"
April 21, 2022 08:34PM
I'm pretty sure Talking Heads are the angular champs (rounded up several reviews in a few minutes).

Early in their career, Talking Heads seemed to be a manifestation of frontman David Byrne’s physiology: lean, angular, and severe.

“Found A Job” finds Jerry Harrison appear next to Byrne to add anther guitar and the original Talking Heads quartet is in place, playing their angular art rock and winning the audience over hand over fist

Talking Heads themselves fashioned their angular funk partly because it suited the acoustics of CBGB, the box-like New York club that launched them.

Wilfully geeky and angular in their earliest work while, barely two years later, writing the template for white ethnofunk (and, thus, a whole slew of what we now know as 'world' music) they are a fine example of the kind of band that, having set a precedent, almost made themselves redundant. Talking Heads may have receded in the public consciousness, but Once In A Lifetime should serve as a useful aide de memoire.
Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.

Click here to login