Welcome! Log In Create A New Profile

Advanced

worst...and best...subject to revision

BCE
worst...and best...subject to revision
November 09, 2014 03:13PM
Worst:
U2
Foo Fighters - please tell me it gets better on repeat listens
Hozier - please, don't let "Take Me To Church" be this year's "Somebody I Used To Know" or "Royals," because that would really suck

Best:
Alla-La's
(tie) Bleachers & Taylor Swift
Flowers
The Hotelier
James - the Dias de Los Meurtos-looking album - loved it
Joyce Manor
Bob Mould
New Pornographers
Real Estate
Simple Minds
Sinead O'Connor
Thurston Moore
The Vaselines
Re: worst...and best...subject to revision
November 10, 2014 07:58AM
Quote

Foo Fighters - please tell me it gets better on repeat listens

Do you mean the band in general? Or do they have a new album out?
BCE
Re: worst...and best...subject to revision
November 10, 2014 08:04AM
Sonic Highways - it's the soundtrack to their "infomercial" on HBO. Boring. I liked Sound City a lot better.
zoo
Re: worst...and best...subject to revision
November 10, 2014 08:04AM
I'm not ready to make a full "best of" list yet, but I can say that the new Simple Minds is really good.

I'm also digging this Museum of Love album that I'm hearing for the first time today. Very John Foxx-ish.
NY Times Popcast has a hilariously mean-spirited and extended takedown of not only the new Foo Fighters record, but Dave Grohl's entire post-Nirvana career. I have never paid the slightest attention to the band; Grohl seems like a basically decent guy without a shred of creativity or novelty in the music he makes. [podcasts.nytimes.com]
Re: worst...and best...subject to revision
November 11, 2014 09:02AM
I know next to nothing about Foo Fighters and kind of half-listened to some of this podcast because I'm always interested in a good evisceration. I quickly got tired of these podcast guys who obviously love the sound of their own voices, and came to the conclusion from what I learned that DG must be Phil Collins circa 1980 - nice guy, hard worker, in every magazine/MTV show, once in a cutting edge band but now making dull but extremely marketable pop music, safely outside my radar because the music he's making is not intended for me. How wrong am I?
zoo
Re: worst...and best...subject to revision
November 11, 2014 09:59AM
Well, Phil Collins was a better drummer, and Genesis were (at one time) better than Nirvana could have ever hoped to be. The main difference, though, is that Grohl can still "rock" which Collins ceased to do once he became a giant star in the mid-'80s.

Re: worst...and best...subject to revision
November 11, 2014 10:58AM
Jesus Christ, it always comes down to bustin up ole Phil around here. The unsalted, boiled potato sound of the Foos is not nearly as good nor important as Phil solo. Hell, the drum fill/roll in In The Air Tonight could possibly be the most loved and recognized piece of drumming in rock/pop ever. [thequietus.com]
Having said that, I respect people who can eek out a career in music like DG. Good for him and his fans.
zoo
Re: worst...and best...subject to revision
November 11, 2014 07:10PM
Most drummers would kill to write a drum part as good as "In the Cage."

Anyway, Phil deserves HUGE props for stepping out from behind the drum kit and fronting Genesis after Gabriel left. His vocal performances were a revelation on the two post-Gabriel albums, in addition to the live Seconds Out album. It really wasn't until Hackett left that the pop started to emerge in a big way. I've said it many times before, the truest prog musician in Genesis was Hackett, who in the year 2014, is the only member of the band still actively gigging and releasing albums...and darn good ones at that.
Re: worst...and best...subject to revision
November 11, 2014 01:09PM
Quote

And I blame him for steering a once-respected band into the fake-rock cul-de-sac.

That's actually a bit of a false assumption. Because he was the frontman, people blame Collins for Genesis' descent into MOR pop (understandably so, and it was reinforced by the fact that his own solo work didn't sound a whole lot different), but Genesis was predominantly Tony Banks' band and he called the shots. It was butting heads with him that largely caused Gabriel and Steve Hackett to eventually leave the band.

Many of the Genesis songs that people blame on Collins were in fact written by Banks or Mike Rutherford.

Rutherford probably had equal or maybe even greater share in the band's sound than Collins, also. And if you want to compare solo careers, Collins' worst songs had more going on for them than the best that Mike & the Mechanics ever belched up.

Collins is one of those guys who has an artsy side and a side that loves mainstream pop & soul. The artsy side was funneled into Brand X and his work with Gabriel and Eno, while the pop & soul side went into his solo career.

Showtime has had a Genesis documentary on heavy rotation for the last month or so that delves into a lot of this stuff.
Re: worst...and best...subject to revision
November 11, 2014 12:02PM
> The unsalted, boiled potato sound of the Foos is not nearly as good nor important as Phil solo.

I couldn't disagree more. The Foo Fighters may not be the most creative band around today, but they've put out plenty of songs that hit my pleasure buttons. Phil's solo work is mostly pop mush to my ears. And I blame him for steering a once-respected band into the fake-rock cul-de-sac. Seriously, post-Gabriel Genesis isn't much better than Journey or Supertramp, IMO.

"In the Air Tonight" is one song that makes me lunge to change the station. Give me Dave's drumming at the start of "Smells Like Teen Spirit" any day.

(NOTE: This isn't to say that Phil isn't a good drummer. As part of Clapton's touring band, he showed himself to be a fine drummer and a great team player. Which is where he belongs.)

Re: worst...and best...subject to revision
November 12, 2014 03:36AM
Delvin, you cheated! The argument was Phil vs Foo not Phil vs Nirvana. I'm not a Nirvana fan at all, but obviously they were way more important than Phil solo. And like I said, the Foos are cool by me. I remember sorta liking the the Mentos video song. But are they really that much different than their arena rock cohorts Kings of Leon, Nickleback, etc. except they are moderately alt'd out?
Re: worst...and best...subject to revision
November 12, 2014 10:10AM
> Delvin, you cheated! The argument was Phil vs Foo not Phil vs Nirvana.

Didn't mean to cheat, Totaji. Reading through the thread, I began to see it as Phil vs Dave. And, by extension, Phil's whole career vs Dave's whole career.

> ... are they really that much different than their arena rock cohorts Kings of Leon,
> Nickleback, etc. except they are moderately alt'd out?

To me, the difference is that the Foo Fighters have continued to put out songs that have, as I said, pressed my pleasure buttons. Kings of Leon did that on their first two albums, at least, before they steered down a more mainstream path and started putting out crap like "Use Somebody."

As for Nickelback, well, to be honest, I haven't heard a note of their music (as far as I recall) other than "How You Remind Me." They certainly have the reputation of being a soulless mainstream band, but to be fair, I don't have a dog in that fight.

Re: worst...and best...subject to revision
November 12, 2014 10:23AM
Delvin wrote:

> Didn't mean to cheat, Totaji. Reading through the thread, I
> began to see it as Phil vs Dave. And, by extension, Phil's
> whole career vs Dave's whole career.

Well, it was me that brought up Phil in the first place, and I didn't mean to start anybody versus anybody. My point was that their career trajectories and public personae were very similar. To the point where it's not really useful to separate one from the other. I'll just throw them both in the file of nice, talented, hard working guys who will likely never do anything I will need to listen to or care about ever again.
Re: worst...and best...subject to revision
November 12, 2014 03:29PM
Its all good Delvin. You prove to be a man of impeccable musical taste and what ever tickles your M-spot (musical pleasure zone) is totally cool. And R.Totale's view is spot on... I guess I have a soft spot for some Phil.
Re: worst...and best...subject to revision
November 12, 2014 04:12PM
"Collins is one of those guys who has an artsy side and a side that loves mainstream pop & soul. The artsy side was funneled into Brand X and his work with Gabriel and Eno, while the pop & soul side went into his solo career. "
Does this make him the Bob Hoskins of rock?
Re: worst...and best...subject to revision
November 12, 2014 11:59PM
Didn't he and Bob Hoskins play brothers in a movie or something?
Re: worst...and best...subject to revision
November 13, 2014 04:02AM
They were both in Hook but not as bros.
Re: worst...and best...subject to revision
November 13, 2014 07:59PM
Quote

Does this make him the Bob Hoskins of rock?

I can think of one Bob Hoskins scene in particular that I'd love to see Phil Collins in.
Re: worst...and best...subject to revision
November 13, 2014 08:22AM
Why thanks, Totaji. Although, honestly, I wouldn't describe my own taste as "impeccable." But hey, whatever my taste is, I do get to inflict it on the general public every week. That does tend to ensure that I steer it away from its more embarrassing pitfalls.

Re: worst...and best...subject to revision
November 13, 2014 10:35AM
Pehaps you need to spotlight a drum-off on your next show and let the listeners decide.

Re: worst...and best...subject to revision
November 13, 2014 12:17PM
> I've said it many times before, the truest prog musician in Genesis was Hackett,
> who in the year 2014, is the only member of the band still actively gigging and
> releasing albums...and darn good ones at that.

Yep. Got tickets to see him next month.

Re: worst...and best...subject to revision
November 13, 2014 05:08PM
As a result of all this, I now have Easy Lover in my head.
zoo
Re: worst...and best...subject to revision
November 13, 2014 07:15PM
Quote

Yep. Got tickets to see him next month.

Hackett's Genesis Extended tour actually came to my neck of the woods, but I just couldn't get there because of my schedule. I've watched many a clip on You Tube...you are in for a treat.
Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.

Click here to login