Welcome! Log In Create A New Profile

Advanced

Biopics

Biopics
September 05, 2014 10:35AM
Talk on this board about the Scorsese/Ramones project got me thinking about why I dislike this genre of movie so much (beyond the obvious: having to suspend belief as semi-lookalike actors play well-known musicians and singers). The INXS biopic is now playing on Showtime, and I caught 20 minutes of it . . . and it led me to the conclusion that my biggest issue is the effort to encapsulate historical plot points with godawful dialogue. Picture a bunch of actors in poodle-mullet wigs standing outside a Perth, Australia, nightclub in "1979": "This is the moment ... from now on we only play our own songs!" (rousing agreement from group). Or, "Dad, I want to be the best drummer in the world." OR:

"Now, there's a new station in America called MTV. If we head there now . . . "

Maybe this is why the Scorsese film will work . . . because you have a legendary auteur at the helm to iron out things like this.

Too bad about Jon Farriss never becoming the best drummer in the world.



Post Edited (09-05-14 12:51)
Re: Biopics
September 05, 2014 10:52AM
Quote

semi-lookalike actors play well-known musicians and singers
That's always bothered me. I've never been able to watch a Beatles biopic for that reason - buncha guys in shaggy hair wigs attempting Liverpudlian accents. I'm like: why?! It's the 'uncanny valley' effect.

The only way to rise above it is to create what is in effect a new character, like what Martin Landau did as Bela Lugosi in "Ed Wood." He never really looked like Bela, he was clearly Martin Landau, but whatever it was it was great.

Quote

my biggest issue is the effort to encapsulate historical plot points with godawful dialogue.
For some reason "The Doors" is held in high regard, but I thought it was awfully hokey for exactly that reason. Not just dialogue, but scenes in general where, for example, "Break On Through" magically comes together in rehearsal.

So I haven't seen even some of the supposed good biopics like 'Ray,' or the Johnny Cash one. "Control" the Joy Division one was really good, tho. Like "Ed Wood," also in black-and-white, so maybe that helps? I kinda liked the Germs one - an excellent lead performance def helped. What you-all think about "The Runaways"?
Re: Biopics
September 06, 2014 04:50AM
I think The Doors movie succeeds despite those flaws. Like the Erik states, the genre is already flawed. Stone's dreamy, psychedelic direction and Kilmer's flawless performance make it one of the best films of this genre. Stone was still in the midst of a pretty decent run: Platoon, Wall St, Talk Radio, Born on The 4th, Doors, and JFK. I think the wheels started to fall off with Natural Born Killers. I personally hated the movie. It is a quintessential 90's movie though (stylistically speaking.) After that, Nixon and Any Given Sunday had alot of good in them, but wouldn't put them up there with his earlier stuff.

I remember watching The Runaway's film, but I barely remember it. It left no impression. Same with the Johnny Cash one.
Re: Biopics
September 06, 2014 08:54AM
I can generally get past the casting issues, etc. My issue with the genre is the basic "We will encapsulate an entire life in two hours and tell you the major theme of it" conceit, which has turned to a cliche.

I groaned when I went to see Walk the Line and in the opening scene it shows the band waiting in the wood shop to go onstage at San Quentin and Johnny Cash eyes the big mechanical saw, and I thought "Oh God, we're going to go back to childhood and his brother's death yadda yadda yadda..." Same problem with Ray and Man on the Moon, although I'd argue that one almost overcomes it. Not quite, but almost.

Biopics can work pretty well when they're reasonably tightly focused on one aspect or time period of the subject's life - i.e., Control, which told the story of Joy Division through the lens of Ian Curtis' marriage, or Ed Wood, which used Wood's friendship with Lugosi as the major engine of the story. Neither movie spent much time going back to the subjects' childhoods and using dimestore psychology to try to tease out the root of their idiosyncrasies.

However, for me to consider a movie to be a "biopic", it can't be so tightly focused that it's are more of a story about one event in a life itself instead of giving some sense of the entire life - thus, Downfall is a great movie, but it's not a biopic of Hitler. It's the story of the events of the last week of the Third Reich. (Though I guess maybe it could be considered a biopic of Traudl Junge.) Same with Valkyrie - a pretty good movie about the plot to kill Hitler, but not something I would consider to be a "biopic" of Klaus von Stauffenberg.

Biopics that I'm reasonably fond of:
The Last Emperor
Control
Ed Wood
Backbeat
24 Hour Party People
I Shot Andy Warhol
The Whole Wide World
The People Vs. Larry Flynt
Gods and Monsters
The Notorious Bettie Page
The Aviator
Rush
(the car racing movie from last year, not the cops on drugs one from the 90s)
Moneyball
Raging Bull
Dreamchild


I'm looking forward to Big Eyes later this year - not only is it about a subject I don't know a whole lot about but am intrigued by, but it reunites Tim Burton with the writers of Ed Wood and, more importantly, will hopefully shake Burton out of the "If I put funny make-up on Johnny Depp and tell him to say 'OH!' in a shocked and effeminate tone of voice 50 or 60 times, my work on this movie will be done" phase he's been in for the last 10 or 15 years.
Re: Biopics
September 06, 2014 12:21PM
Raging Bull, of course, is great . . . which is even more of a reason to look forward to the Ramones project. On the topic of boxers, I also have a fondness for Somebody Up There Likes Me (1956), the Rocky Graziano biopic that was an early Paul Newman performance. The acting is not great, but much of it was shot on the streets of downtown Manhattan in the mid-1950s.
Re: Biopics
September 06, 2014 10:25AM
Most of these problems were present in the Dewey Cox biopic too, but I think it was a better film for embracing them.
Re: Biopics
September 06, 2014 06:13PM
I thought Sid & Nancy definitely was a self-inflicted razor cut above most biopics. I also enjoyed 24-Hour Party People, even though it told you more about a scene in a place with a certain group of bands. And anybody remember how enjoyable Amadeus was? But don't worry, I think the biopic can only get better. All is by my side.

Some bios I'd like to see:

Gene Vincent
Eddie Cochran
Frank Zappa
The Shangri-Las
Emmylou Harris
Syd Barrett
The Residents

and so much more!



Post Edited (09-06-14 20:17)
Re: Biopics
September 06, 2014 07:43PM
erik,
if you like bands with three brothers, you'll love a band w/four sisters!

[www.youtube.com]



Post Edited (09-06-14 22:03)
Re: Biopics
September 06, 2014 08:05PM
Re: Biopics
September 08, 2014 08:38PM
Jon Farris can thump 'em. Word has it in the production caper
that he's particularly serviceable in the studio.
Re: Biopics
September 09, 2014 08:54AM
> ... he's particularly serviceable in the studio.

That could be taken so out of context.

Actually, Jon Farriss is a very good drummer. Not the greatest in the world, but definitely good.

Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.

Click here to login