Welcome! Log In Create A New Profile

Advanced

Longevity

Longevity
July 24, 2013 09:30PM
So 2013 marks Radiohead's 20th year as a recording unit. They've managed to go that entire time without having any line-up changes or break ups that were retroactively re-labelled hiatuses.

This combination of longevity and stability seems to be pretty rare. The only other band I can think of off the top of my head that is active 20+ years without ever having any line-up changes or break-ups is U2 (33 years since the release of Boy).

And I guess De La Soul fits the criteria - 24 years since 3 Feet High and Rising and it's still the same three guys. And maybe a Tribe Called Quest?

I'm sure there are others I'm not thinking of. And I'm not really counting duos like the Proclaimers or Tegan and Sara (who wouldn't meet the longevity standard anyhow) where it's just two people who form the actual "band" plus hired hands for albums and tours. I'm looking for actual multi-member bands that have stuck together for the long haul with no personnel changes.
Re: Longevity
July 24, 2013 10:37PM
you might check some of these

Aerosmith 40+?
Rush 45?
The Fall
ZZTop 40+

Sonic Youth went 28 years with the same members
Flaming Lips - 27 w/same
Doesn't Metallica have the same mouthbreathers? (over 30 years)
AC/DC ?

Beverly Sisters went 1952-2009 and aren't officially broke up

do Buzzcocks qualify for anything?
(i was kidding about The Fall)

Chuck Berry is 86.

Green Day - 23 years w/Tré Cool lineup
Rancid - 20 years w/Lars Frederiksen
[edit:: I forgot that they changed drummers a few years back]

Roxy aren't broke up

YLT - 21 w/McNew

JSBX - 22

Golden Earring claim as such when they tour but I'm doubtful of the metric fit

Los Lobos may have something

Some of those 80s hair bands still tour
(Zebra?)

Pet Shop Boys?

Cranberries
these guys


CS&N are still touring

Neville Bros?



Post Edited (07-25-13 04:25)
Re: Longevity
July 25, 2013 05:47AM
Good choices, let me examine them....

Aerosmith - Joe Perry left around 1980, band had pretty much broken up until Run-DMC reunited them and Perry returned to the fold.

Rush & ZZ Top definitely go on the list.

The Fall - You were kidding

Sonic Youth - line-up changed when Jim O'Rourke joined, and Richard Edson was their drummer before leaving after the first album

Flaming Lips - parted ways with Ronald Jones, Jonathan Donahue and others

Metallica - bye to Dave Mustaine, Jason Newsted, Cliff Burton.

AC/DC - Bon Scott. For all I know they've been a stable line-up since then, but I'm looking for bands that have been the exact same line-up over an entire long recording career, which may not have been clear in my original post. (Personnel changes made before recording anything don't count.)

Buzzcocks - Devoto left after Spiral Scratch, band broke up & reunited, Maher & Garvey long gone.

YLT - definitely stable since the addition of McNew, but had multiple other members before he showed up.

Roxy may not be officially broken up, but their line-up has been lava lampish in its consistency.

Los Lobos - ALMOST qualify, but Steve Berlin wasn't an actual member on ...And a Time to Dance and I don't think he was on either of the Spanish language albums prior to that. Pretty damn close, though, and I'll give them the nod just because they're Los Lobos.

Cranberries qualify, I guess - looks like they never announced a break-up before their lengthy hiatus, even though everyone assumed they did.

Spencer Explosion works, as near as I can tell. And I think the Pet Shop Boys do, too.

The wilds of hair metal is a place I leave unexplored. There may very well be some bands that fit the bill lurking in there, but I don't care enough to find out.
Re: Longevity
July 25, 2013 06:24AM
I think ZZ Top is going on 43 years with the same lineup, don't know how active they are but I don't think they've officially retired.
Re: Longevity
July 25, 2013 06:54AM
They put out a new record last year - definitely still active.
Re: Longevity
July 25, 2013 09:43AM
I think bands should be disqualified if they haven't put out anything half-decent in 10 years. You can decide who that eliminates.
Re: Longevity
July 25, 2013 07:18AM
I think ZZ Top will likely be the champions, with Rush #2 and U2 #3. But we'll see if anyone comes up with any other contenders.
Re: Longevity
July 25, 2013 07:19AM
except Rush's first drummer couldn't tour so they nabbed Peart
ZZTop had 1st single w/different lineup

So I think with that metric you'll mostly be looking for family acts & hair bands (Zebra @ 38yrs).

I'll give Sonic Youth a longevity nod though (not adding "with Jim O'Rourke" on product labeling doesn't bother me, nor playing live with O'bold). They're the ones I point out when the question comes up (and it does). Somebody always answers "the Stones!" but the metric then usually changes to something like "but Wyman quit" or "but Jones died". So my standby is Sonic Youth and if they don't exactly fit the metric at hand, I squeak them by because the people I'm talking to have never heard of them anyway and don't care enough to check their phones.

Looks like yo longevity winner heah is the - lemme say it right now - the Blues Explosion. Yeah! The Blues Explosion. Yeah! Say it one more time with me now uhuh. Blues Explosion! We're gonna get right down on it now. Longevity hah! Lonegvity hah! (twang, skronk, the guitars re-enters mix).

A couple years back I was at a dinner party where the digestif game was a round where each person had to name a band with the next letter of the alphabet. Everyone says U2 for "U". A friend of mine was next, in front of me, and when he got the second "U" he said "Ultravox" (because as far as we were concerned the game was still very easy). A few people murmured disbelief for Ultravox (I don't remember the disqual punishment but it was a drinking game of sorts) and then I got the second V. I could have said Velvet Underground, Vaselines, Violent Femmes or, hell, Vangelis but for some reason (other than beng legally drunk) I said "Voivod". "What?!". "VOIVOD". BOO! BOO! -cups and liquid splatter flew through the air at us - THESE GUYS ARE FULL OF SHIT! THERE'S NO SUCH BANDS AS ULTER VOX and VOY VOD!

Re: Longevity
July 25, 2013 07:31AM
No love for the Four Tops?? To adapt a Small Faces line, there were but four Four Tops from 1953 to 1997, until one Top died.
Re: Longevity
July 25, 2013 12:38PM
That's right. No love for the Four Tops! In fact, I hold special enmity for Frankie Valli. How I hate hearing his whiny, nasal falsetto when forced to hear The Four Tops in public places.



Former TP subscriber [81, 82, 83, 84]

[postpunkmonk.com]
For further rumination on the Fresh New Sound of Yesterday®
Re: Longevity
July 25, 2013 07:56AM
My number one favourite band, Sloan, formed in 1991 with four members Chris Murphy, Jay Ferguson, Patrick Pentland and Andrew Scott, has been together for 22 years. Now despite a little hiccup in 1996 when the drummer [Andrew] was moving from Halifax to Toronto, while the rest of the band wanted to remain in Halifax, I'd argue that they've been one of the most consistently unchanged, and unbroken-up bands in Canada.

Around 2006 they started adding some keyboard work into their albums, and as such they now have a 'fifth member' Greg Macdonald, who typically just does the keys, maracas, and air-horn during live shows. All album work is still done by the original four.

I'd say these guys make the cut.
There's a great interview about their history, and their opinions on other bands that have stayed together for a long time here. Also covered: a reasonable explanation of 'Sloan Fanaticism' as mentioned on the board a few weeks ago.
zoo
Re: Longevity
July 25, 2013 08:32AM
Quote

Los Lobos - ALMOST qualify, but Steve Berlin wasn't an actual member on ...And a Time to Dance and I don't think he was on either of the Spanish language albums prior to that. Pretty damn close, though, and I'll give them the nod just because they're Los Lobos.


I'm pretty certain Los Lobos added a second drummer a while back so Louie Perez could play more guitar on stage. [Leaves TP to go check it out.]

[Returns] Turns out I was correct. According to Los Lobs website,

Los Lobos still are:
Louie Perez- Drums, Guitars, Percussion, Vocals
Steve Berlin- Saxophone, Percussion, Flute, Midsax, Harmonica, Melodica
Cesar Rosas- Vocals, Guitar, Mandolin
Conrad Lozano- Bass, Guitarron, Vocals
David Hidalgo- Vocals, Guitar, Accordion, Percussion, Bass, Keyboards, Melodica, Drums, Violin, Banjo
Enrique "Bugs" Gonzalez - Drums/Percussion
Re: Longevity
July 25, 2013 01:18PM
I guess your monastic order doesn't require you to shun most public places.

Re: Longevity
July 25, 2013 02:12PM
> I guess your monastic order doesn't require you to shun most
> public places.
>

Or to differentiate the Four Seasons from the Four Tops.
Re: Longevity
July 27, 2013 07:09AM
D'oh!! My profuse apologies for confusing The Four Tops with The Four Seasons. Apart from the number of members and period of primary activity ['63-'70], there's no comparison. But obviously I have a big problem with Frankie Valli for that hair trigger to snap so carelessly.



Former TP subscriber [81, 82, 83, 84]

[postpunkmonk.com]
For further rumination on the Fresh New Sound of Yesterday®
Re: Longevity
July 28, 2013 08:46PM
U2 added a member for a one-off performance. Some cash-strapped Canadian called Cohen, in order to slaughter his Tower Of Song.
Re: Longevity
July 29, 2013 07:58AM
Quote

no solo albums either by any of them. unless the edge did some soundtrack work. did any of the guys on los lobos do any solo work? prob not cause they are definitely not constricted to one sound
According to the book Killing Bono,

The Edge has released one or two soundtrack albums, one of which featured one of Sinead O'Connor's first vocals. And the entire band had the Passengers side project, in which Eno was added as a member.

Don't know if any of the Lobos have done a solo album, but Hidalgo and Perez were/are members of Los Super Seven, I believe.
Re: Longevity
July 29, 2013 08:45AM
Cesar Rosas put out a solo album called Soul Disguise in 1999.
Re: Longevity
July 29, 2013 11:47AM
Quote

Cesar Rosas put out a solo album called Soul Disguise in 1999.

Oh yeah. The sad part is, I have that album and like it, but forgot all about its existence.

It's hell getting old.
Re: Longevity
July 25, 2013 06:28PM
And on that note, we cue the music:

[www.youtube.com]
Re: Longevity
July 25, 2013 07:26PM
By contrast, Fankie Valli's tears never inspired anyone...
Frankie Valli's Tears
July 28, 2013 10:57PM
Frankie Valli's tears did inspire this charmer

"We Proudly Welcome Tony Orlando"
The State Fair marquee reads
Inside, a thousand people with yellow ribbons sing
And clap on 1 and 3

Watch him burn
He's dropping to his knees
Watch him burn
A medley: hits from Grease
Watch him burn
He never fails to please

Meanwhile in Tahoe outside Casa Tony
Wet rags of gasoline
A jealous Frankie Valli says, "Dawn, I want you back"
Lights a match and counts to three

Watch it burn
Reluctantly he leaves
Watch it burn
Acrid smoke making him wheeze
Watch it burn
Humming "Sherry," splits the scene

"We're sorry to inform you
Tony Orlando has been postponed."


Re: Longevity
July 28, 2013 07:54PM
I asked this question a couple of years back on this thread.
I believe u2s lineup from the first dfay they were formed ws edge larry mullins, bono n adam clayton? if someone can confirm that to be true o false.
no solo albums either by any of them. unless the edge did some soundtrack work. did any of the guys on los lobos do any solo work? prob not cause they are definitely not constricted to one sound
Re: Longevity
July 29, 2013 07:01AM
Edge's older brother left right before they dubbed themselves U2 and moved into their definitive history. . .
zoo
Re: Longevity
July 29, 2013 02:21PM
Hidalgo and Louie Perez made two albums (w/ Tchad Blake and Mitchell Froom) as Latin Playboys. The first album is VERY good, IMO.

Hidalgo has also done some other stuff here, but I don't think he's done a solo album under his name alone.
Re: Longevity
July 30, 2013 10:23AM
Did The Shaggs ever officially "break up" or have any retroactive "hiatuses?"

Just wonderin' is all.
Re: Longevity
August 05, 2013 06:33PM
Buffalo Tom
(1987, though still not the Aerosmith span)
Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.

Click here to login