Welcome! Log In Create A New Profile

Advanced

BMX: A band that could've been?

BMX: A band that could've been?
June 04, 2013 03:23PM
I picked up a secondhand copy of the Richard Thompson tribute Beat the Retreat last weekend. Judging from the cover of "Turning of the Tide," am I the only one here who wonders if Bob Mould would've made a good addition to X, following Billy Zoom's departure? I wouldn't label Mould a "replacement" for Zoom, but he does sound great playing in front of John Doe and D.J. Bonebrake. (Billy's shoes always were far too big for Tony Gilkyson to fill. Heck, just skip back three tracks on this disc, to X's cover of "Shoot Out the Lights," and judge for yourself.)

Or would it have been a case of a new band member bringing perhaps a bit too much to the table, considering Bob's own substantial moxie as a singer and songwriter?

That's a great cover album, by the way. I am a big Mould fan, and relatively modest in my interest level for X. I never saw a huge overlap of styles, but I guess there are some commonalities. Someone more knowledgeable of X would have to weigh in.

I think you just win on the basis of coming up with the BMX acronym.
Re: BMX: A band that could've been?
June 04, 2013 10:05PM
Quote

Billy's shoes always were far too big for Tony Gilkyson to fill. Heck, just skip back three tracks on this disc, to X's cover of "Shoot Out the Lights," and judge for yourself.

Better Idea: Listen to Live at the Whisky A Go-Go on the Fabulous Sunset Strip and hear Gilkyson prove to be a perfectly suitable replacement for whoever it was he actually replaced in X.
Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.

Click here to login