Welcome! Log In Create A New Profile

Advanced

REM (list time)

REM (list time)
December 16, 2010 11:20AM
I think you can tell a lot about a person from their favorite REM songs. Here are my 10 favorite in no particular order.

Moral Kiosk
Catapult
Harborcoat
Driver 8
Finest Worksong
Hairshirt
Its The End Of The World As We Know It
Shiny Happy People
Me In Honey
Nightswimming
New Test Leper

Obviously, I am deeply uncool based on this list. I find much of Reckoning through Life's Rich Pageant muddy and not-totally-satisfying anymore, especially those songs with the Indian titles. (Seriously, I've heard Fables at least 200 times and still cant recall the names of some of the songs) On the mid period records, Stipe just become so exuberant and emotive. Also, anything after Up hasnt even crossed my radar. Michael Stipe just became too Michael Stipish. I still hold out hope that they may put out another winner someday. The new one comes out in March. The lead off track is called "Rediscoverer". Not a promising title.



Post Edited (12-16-10 17:34)
zoo
Re: REM (list time)
December 16, 2010 11:54AM
Welcome to the Occupation
Maps and Legends
Good Advices
Feeling Gravity's Pull
The Flowers of Guatemala
World Leader Pretend
Oddfellows Local 151
Green Grow the Rushes
Cuyahoga
Swan Swan H


The Reckoning through Lifes Rich Pageant era is my favorite, BTW.
Re: REM (list time)
December 16, 2010 01:07PM
I don't know if you can tell all that much about a person from his/her Top Ten R.E.M. Songs list ... unless said list either (1) contains nothing but the obvious hits, or (2) skips those hits entirely.

But in my case, it's probably ...

Carnival of Sorts
Radio Free Europe
Harborcoat
Don't Go Back to Rockville
Feeling Gravity's Pull
Driver 8
Cuyahoga
Crazy
Finest Worksong
Pop Song '89

R.E.M. pretty much lost me with Out of Time. I truly can't remember the last time I listened to that disc start to finish. Automatic for the People gave me hope that Out of Time was just an aberration, a slip-up ... but it's been downhill ever since for the band, IMO.

Actually, you probably can tell enough from a person if he/she even has a Top Ten Songs list of any artist. (Seriously, when's the last time you met anyone with a list of his/her ten favorite Journey songs? Or ten favorite Bon Jovi songs?)

Re: REM (list time)
December 16, 2010 01:09PM
I'd be more deeply uncool...I loved Accelerate and I'd probably pick at least 3 songs from it. So I'll spare you all the heartache and myself the ridicule.
Re: REM (list time)
December 16, 2010 01:11PM
Awww come on, Michael. Where would this board be if I took that same attitude?

Re: REM (list time)
December 16, 2010 02:04PM
Nightswimming
I Believe
Fall on Me
Electrolite
Hope
Sitting Still
Wolves, Lower
Harborcoat
Life and How to Live It
Losing My Religion
Star Me Kitten

I'm sure it would change on any given day for me, but this is what I'll go with today. And since Nosepail's top 10 went to 11 so does mine.
Re: REM (list time)
December 16, 2010 02:38PM
And my ranking of the albums:

Automatic For the People
Murmur
Lifes Rich Pageant
Reckoning
Dead Letter Office
Up (I think it's their most underrated album by far.)
Green
Fables of the Reconstruction
Accelerate
Document
Out of Time
Reveal (The REM album most likely to be completely forgotten about by anyone assembling a list like this.)
New Adventures in Hi-Fi
Around the Sun

and, in last place, the only REM album I actively dislike and probably even hate:

Monster (Only "Bang and Blame" approaches even being tolerable.)
Re: REM (list time)
December 16, 2010 02:46PM
Wow, Dead Letter Office #5. I mean, that King Of The Road cover is a lot of yucks, but......
Re: REM (list time)
December 16, 2010 02:53PM
"Toys in the Attic," man. I never appreciated Aerosmith until I heard R.E.M. rock that bitch into the ground.
Re: REM (list time)
December 16, 2010 04:04PM
I ranked Dead Letter Office that high on my list mainly for the inclusion of Chronic Town, but do like quite a few of the odds and ends. But mainly it was to recognize Chronic Town which I didn't feel could be included on its own because it was only an EP, albeit a nearly perfect one.
Re: REM (list time)
December 16, 2010 02:22PM
Fine. In alpha order (and I'll go Spinal Tap as well):

Don't Go Back to Rockville
Driver 8
Living Well is the Best Revenge
Losing My Religion
Man On the Moon
Near Wild Heaven
Orange Crush
Radio Free Europe
Shiny Happy People (am I the only one that hears this song as satirical?)
Supernatural Superserious
Until the Day is Done

It's all singles and pop tunes. Clearly I've never been a serious R.E.M. fan. Ask me about Husker Du instead.

When I was younger, "It's the End of the World As We Know It" would've been on the list, but I confess to being sick to hell of it now.
Re: REM (list time)
December 16, 2010 03:01PM
i agree with ya brad on 1 & 2, but i'd move reckoning to 3rd & green to 4th. I think dead letter office is right where you got it.

whatevers, those are the five i keep handy anyway.
Re: REM (list time)
December 16, 2010 02:20PM
a GREAT band...
radio free europe
driver 8
pilgrimage
superman
pretty persuasion
rockville
finest worksong
ignoreland
perfect circle
orange crush



Post Edited (12-16-10 16:21)
Re: REM (list time)
December 16, 2010 03:17PM
For what it's worth, here is my album ranking. Yeah, I love their mid-period.

1) Murmur: The absolute classic. Put it in the time capsule. Will eternally retain it's mystery and beauty.

2) Document: Their hardest rocking and most consistent record. Only one song beneath 4 stars for me. Dont understand the lack of love for this one.

3) Out of Time: Yes, it's flawed but it captures them at the peak of their newfound exuberance. Great variety. Not their third best, but damn I put it on a lot. Lots of swoony, lovely strings and background vocals.

4) Green: Three, count 'em three, folksy mandolin classics that could have been on Led Zep 4. Plus, Dreams, and Orange Crush, and that wonderful hidden track.

5) Reckoning: Great songcraft. Lacks the mystery of their first record but the Rickenbackers sound is astonishing throughout. Too much of the Michael Stipe moaning-singing.

6) Lifes Rich Pageant: Superman, Flowers of Guatemala, Fall On Me are all A+. A little too much revved up folksy jingle jangle among the remaining.

7) Fables of the Reconstruction: Some great songs here, but a lot of mush. I'm amazed people even remember the names of half these songs.

8) Chronic Town: It's great, but it's still only an EP.

9) Automatic For the People: I hated it in college but now recognize its beauty. Docked 3 positions for Everybody Hurts.

10) Up: Agreed its under-rated. Did someone call it chamber music? Still, without drums, a lot of these songs are slow, slow, slow with minimal energy from the frontman.

11) Dead Letter Office: A very decent odds and sods collection. Not much more.

12) New Adventures in Hi-Fi: Experimenting all over the place and failing in almost all attempted genres.

13) Monster: One of the worst Jump The Shark records ever!

<the other three>

I am much more confident in the album list than the song list. They have so many great ones to choose from.



Post Edited (12-16-10 18:20)
Re: REM (list time)
December 16, 2010 10:11PM
Hmm. Top Ten R.E.M. Tunes?



Voice of Harold
Kahoutek
Life And How To Live It
Harborcoat
Stumble
Carnival of Sorts (Box Cars)
West of the Fields
Letter Never Sent
Laughing
Time After Time (AnnElise)


...

I'm forced to confine myself to the earlier material. There just isn't enough room for anything from a later vintage. Unless you allowed me an entire CD's space (or a Top 20, perhaps) I'd have to formulate an entire new list for anything from a later date.

I do really like everything up to Green without any reservations. Well ... "The Wrong Child" is a peg-legged travesty of a song, but aside from that, I'm solid.

That's the sort of song you write after you hang out too long with Natalie Merchant, I suppose. It sounds like it, anyway. Listen to that tune and ask yourself if you're really all that surprised by "Everybody Hurts."
Re: REM (list time)
December 16, 2010 11:05PM
As I've relayed on this board before, I pretty much gave up on following R.E.M. after seeing them with 15,000 frat boys at Clemson University's Littlejohn Coliseum in 1987. Plus, I didn't think all that much of Document at the time, and Green was little better. And until I picked up Automatic for the People on CD for a dollar within the last year, the last actual R.E.M. purchase I made was Fables (I taped Pageant, Document, and Green off friends in college). Thus, every one of my top 10 songs would come from Chronic Town and the first two albums, so what's the point? I like some songs on Fables - or at least I did the last time I listened to it, which is probably close to two decades ago - but not enough to supplant anything from those first 3 recs.

But all this has made me feel like going back and listening to all those albums again - and some for the first time - to reassess my views of R.E.M. Or maybe I should just stick with what I like and go listen to Big Plans For Everybody again....
Re: REM (list time)
December 17, 2010 06:50AM
I'm with ya on Big Plans...ultimately Let's Active means more to me than anything R.E.M. has done.
Re: REM (list time)
December 17, 2010 10:46AM
I'm not sure I'd go quite that far, as all three of those first R.E.M. records meant a hell of a lot to me at the time. And I still do listen to Murmur pretty regularly, though not as often as I do Big Plans. If I had to choose between the two to take to the desert island with me, it would probably be Let's Active by a hair, mostly because I couldn't bear life without "In Little Ways".
Re: REM (list time)
December 17, 2010 09:45PM
Quote

I pretty much gave up on following R.E.M. after seeing them with 15,000 frat boys at Clemson University's Littlejohn Coliseum in 1987.

15,000 Frat Boys or 10,000 Maniacs. You decide.

...

Edited to include:

Jog my memory. Which Cat Stevens tune did 15,000 Frat Boys cover?



Post Edited (12-17-10 23:49)
Re: REM (list time)
December 18, 2010 12:04PM
Yo La Tengo covered "Here Comes My Baby," my favorite Cat tune.

I kind of don't ever listen to "Peace Train" anymore after that whole Salaman Rushdie/Fatwa thing. Not that I ever really liked it in the first place. I saw 10,000 Maniacs/Merchant twice, and both by mistake. The first time was at TPAC (Nashville in 88 or 89). Camper Van was opening, and that was who I had come to see. The second time was at a Bob Dylan concert (1998 in Binghamton, NY). She was opening; I had no idea. Talk about unintentionally seeing somebody perform.
Re: REM haiku
December 17, 2010 03:01PM
Chronic Town
does it have 5 songs?
if so, repeat
Re: REM haiku
December 17, 2010 04:51PM
Short and sweet.

1. Automatic (I deeply wish they'd broken up after this album. It's a perfect capper to a career, and I said so at the time)
2. Document (This was the CD I listened to the most after 9-11 -- it gave me hope, let me vent, and unfortunately reminded me of how we'd react: see "Exhuming McCarthy")
3. Murmur
4. Reckoning
5. Chronic Town
6. Accelerate (Hopefully, a revival.)
7. Green (would be higher without "Inside Out" and "California". They just drag.
8. Reconstruction of the Fables (it just doesn't have enough energy for me, even though I realize there is some great stuff there)
9. Lifes Rich Pageant (too much muscle, not enough brain, at times)
10. Out of Time (there's an amazing EP in here, but not enough solid song craft)

And has any band jumped the shark harder than they did on Monster? I remember feeling sick listening to it the first time -- it was just so bad. I know the album has its champions -- esp. at Spin -- but it's a huge drop in songwriting and creativity at a turning point for the band, with Buck choosing to "rock out" more and Stipe writing more direct songs. It all just crashes down.

I can deal with all the rest, although none of them really even contain the sort of jaw-dropping hooks the band used to write in its sleep. That's why I like Accelerate so much -- it seems like they're really trying now, as opposed to just trying to experiment.

BTW, this is the sort of thing I love about this board. I could do this sort of career evaluation thread all day long. But I have Beefheart to listen to, and miles to go before I sleep.

And Big Plans... is as good as any R.E.M. album -- well, except maybe for the first three on my list.



Post Edited (12-19-10 08:49)
Re: REM (list time)
December 18, 2010 09:41AM
> Which Cat Stevens tune did 15,000 Frat Boys cover?

I was thinking "Another Saturday Night," but Stevens didn't write that one. Still, it does sound like a frat party sing-along ... at least compared to the rest of Stevens' repertoire.

Re: REM (list time)
December 18, 2010 01:29PM
A great band at the start, a good one in the middle, post-Green, is nap time. Their new song is a dud as well for me.

In particular I have always hated AFTP - except for Ignoreland and Nightswimming. I know this is going to be greeted with some raised eyebrows.

No order :

Ages of You
Radio Free Europe
Begin the Begin
It's The End of The World........
You Are The Everything
Nightswimming
Perfect Circle
Standing Still
Harborcoat
Feeling Gravity's Pull



Post Edited (12-21-10 09:13)
kwk
Re: REM (list time)
December 18, 2010 02:54PM
green grow the rushes
harborcoat
driver 8
don't go back to rockville
radio free europe
gardening at night
ages of you
laughing
letter never sent
pretty persuasion
nightswimming
Re: REM (list time)
December 19, 2010 02:28PM
Actually, the first song I heard by Cat Stevens was his 1973 single "The Hurt," which did have enough drive and energy to catch my attention. I was a bit surprised by the bulk of his other recordings; they were so lightweight in comparison.

Re: REM (list time)
December 20, 2010 08:11PM
greetings, REM fans. I cannot express the geeked out thrill I feel at joining this board to comment on this thread. It was only the central subject of nearly every waking moment of my high school life. So yeah, here are my initial lists.

I realized in making these lists that there are really at least two to start- my personal favorites that moved me, changed my life, and are still sacred- and those that are obvious or hidden gems that are greats and deserve to be on the list- and also faves of mine, even if they're not on the first ultra magic list.

my list (kind of in order):

wolves, lower
this one, I had the reaction michael stipe said he had to patti smith, or something like it. I didn't throw up. But I freaked out.

I believe
gorgeous lyrics, banjo makes me happy.

perfect circle
exquisite afternoon sun

orange crush
the first REM song I ever heard, the harmonies at the end made me swoon and see things that weren't there. I loved them on first listen.

belong
moe gorgeousness. Hard to explain why this one.

king of birds
imagery and storytelling

pilgrimage
crazy, redemptive harmonies again.

time after time (AnneElise)
I forget exactly why...kind of haunting and prism-like

texarkana
same as above. Yeah, I'm predictable. And without mike mills' voice, none of this works.

7 chinese brothers
magic

There's a theme here. the lush layers and harmonies rock my world so.

Here's my great and known or hidden gem list. They all are brilliant and adored, and not in order- but world leader pretend was at the top because it was so incredibly obvious (and amazing) and I must honor it even though it's not on my first list.

world leader pretend
carnival of sorts
swan swan H
you are the everything
sweetness follows
gardening at night
fall on me
shaking through
cuyahoga
low

To the dude who hates out of time- you won't get that last one, but then, I think it's one of their best albums. Has anyone here ever seen the video for low? brilliant and beautiful and maybe my favorite video ever...

And to the person who posted ages of you- total respect.

Nosepail, I was surprised by your moral kiosk at the top!
Re: REM (list time)
December 20, 2010 08:19PM
ooh- totally forgot to put pretty persuasion on that second list. I'll replace, um, fall on me with it. Maybe just because I've heard fall on me too much.

(I took a 5 year break from reckoning, and now it's much better again.)
Re: REM (list time)
December 22, 2010 04:54PM
I'd take breno's top four albums and turn it upside down (+ maybe get rid of Automatic, too)
Re: REM (list time)
December 22, 2010 06:47PM
Aitch,

I have to admit, I've never bought into the Automatic thing. I understand that it's a good album, but I just don't see it up there with the IRS stuff or the best of what REM had to offer (note the past tense).
Re: REM (list time)
December 23, 2010 08:14AM
Here's my defense of Automatic: I listen to Murmur and Document a lot more, but from a song quality point of view, I just think it's their best. It doesn't sound like R.E.M. at times, but when I listen to it, it feels like an R.E.M. album -- the last one that has the weirdness and (stealing from everyone else here) cathedral sound that makes their best work transcendent. Murmur has the best hooks for me, and they seem to come so naturally on that one: "Pilgrimage's" chorus just appears out of nowhere, like a vision, and "Moral Kiosk's" chorus gets better and better as the song goes and they add more power and instrumentation. Document has more power than anything else they've done, and that first side works better than anything else they've done, for me. It sounds like they're having a damned good time when they play, and it makes the political edge stand out stronger. However, it does get a bit bogged down at the end.

Unlike Automatic, which leaves its best songs towards the end, and which makes it a better overall album for me: it flows better, and leaves me with a batter, nostalgic feeling every time I listen to it. I do wish they'd broken up then, because it works so well as an endpiece. And then, dear God, Monstershowed up. I'm glad you like it if you do, but I can't stand it.

Accelerate is a decent collection of songs, and the best album (for me) since Automatic.

Also, also, I can't remember the title, but years ago I heard what I think is one of their best albums, but it was a live bootleg of songs that I don't think have ever been on any of their albums -- really early stuff. Loud, fast, and full of hooks, but I can't remember the title, and it was loaned out sometime in the 80's and never returned....
Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.

Click here to login