Welcome! Log In Create A New Profile

Advanced

Husker Du

kwk
Husker Du
December 11, 2010 03:16PM
Just picked up my copy of the Husker Du book by Andrew Earles. Anyone else have a copy yet? And btw, has there ever been a better band who's catalog has not been remastered and repackaged?
Sound quality on Metal Circus, Flip Your Wig, Zen Arcade, and New Day Rising is positively dreadful. As a kid in the 80's, I didn't care. I do now!
Off to read my book.

Re: Husker Du
December 11, 2010 05:39PM
I used to do the Du years ago. My tastes have mellowed a lot. Apparently, so has Mr. Mould's.
Re: Husker Du
December 11, 2010 06:00PM

Haven't seen the book yet but I'll pick it up for old time's sake.

They meant a ton to me in my formative years and I still spin their last 5 records and the 8 Miles High single from time to time.

Re: Husker Du
December 11, 2010 07:13PM
The Dü meant a lot to me, too. I'll never forget the riveting HD show I saw in Denver, on (as it turned out) the band's final tour. I've talked about it on this board before; Paganizer, it turns out, was at the same show.

Re: Husker Du
December 13, 2010 08:09AM
Sadly, the author ignores the Warehouse era. He spends about 10x more time discussing Land Speed Record. But at least there's a HD book out there now.
Re: Husker Du
December 13, 2010 08:42AM
I've heard it's got a bias to certain eras, and that Mould's lack of participation hampers it. But, as you say, at least there's a book out there now, and it's a start. Maybe when Mould's book comes out it will fill in the blanks.
Re: Husker Du
December 13, 2010 09:19AM
Best band ever. I am asking for this book for Christmas!

"Sound quality on Metal Circus, Flip Your Wig, Zen Arcade, and New Day Rising"

Can we forget Candy Apple Gray? The album with some of the worst-recorded drum sound in history? I dont mind the sound quality on Metal Circus, Zen Arcade, and New Day Rising - the guitars just sound so damn gnarly - but Flip You Wig and CAG are pretty bad. I dont think it's anything a remaster could help with much.
Re: Husker Du
December 13, 2010 09:22PM
Hüsker Dü.
The Replacements.
R.E.M.

If forced to admit that one of those three meant next to nothing to me at the time ... I'd have to say it was Hüsker Dü.

Did they smell too much like hardcore? Maybe. Somehow, Westerberg and his band's hardcore-sounding stuff didn't bother me at all. So that cannot be it. I just never really saw what all the fuss was about. The same goes double for Sugar.

...

But I once met a woman who claimed to be Bob Mould's sister.

"Divide And Conquer" is an insanely good tune.

...

Sorry folks!
Re: Husker Du
December 13, 2010 09:34PM
I think you dont really mean it, Kay. If you like Divide and Conquer, put on New Industry or I Apologize or Celebrated Summer or Real World, or Eight Miles High and be prepared to blown to smithereens. If you need convincing on Sugar, put on Tilted, perhaps the heaviest song in the history of any music in any genre. I love the Replacements and REM more than most, but really these two legendary bands cant even approach the intensity of any of the songs I just mentioned. Seriously, drop the pre-conceptions, and give it one more try.

Sincerely,
Craig ("Nosepail")



Post Edited (12-13-10 23:35)
Re: Husker Du
December 17, 2010 10:13PM
Quote

I think you dont really mean it, Kay.

I do.

However, I don't mean to imply that the band sucks or anything. Obviously, my excuses will never be enough for anyone who loves the band. If I told you that there are just some bands that I feel are best left to other people, perhaps that would be sufficient?

Their reputation is well deserved. As kwk said, that's one hell of an oeuvre considering it was basically done in the blink of an eye.

I also started on their last album. That can't have helped at all. I have a copy of Zen Arcade on LP somewhere.

The other day, I checked New Day Rising from the library (whoever's working acquisitions for them deserves a raise) ... I was hoping to be floored, but it didn't do much at all for me.

Maybe you have to be a youngster? Maybe having weaned myself on Rush as a grade schooler, there just wasn't enough room in my life for another power trio? Hah!
Re: Husker Du
December 18, 2010 08:43AM
I cant imagine hearing New Day Rising and not being floored. Perhaps one of the three or four most devastating records ever. But I respect your choice, Kay smiling smiley
kwk
Re: Husker Du
December 18, 2010 01:56PM
In all fairness to Kay, those of us who cannot understand being floored by Husker Du are coming from an entirely different place than she is. We were all (I'm assuming) originally floored in our more formative years, and those growls of pain and syrupy melodies got attached to us when our young selves were full of the same teenage angst. Those albums that defined you when you're a teenager never leave you.
So coming at an emotional powerhouse like Husker Du after the fact really couldn't have the same impact. Judged as simply a band, they were damn good. But if you ever cried after a breakup while "Hardly Getting Over It" played in your room, or pumped your fists and felt like a super-hero while blasting "Eight Miles High", or sang "Green Eyes" to a girl you were madly in love with who had "the prettiest eyes I have ever seen"...well, you get the point.
You know what they say, you had to be there.
Re: Husker Du
December 14, 2010 08:32AM
For me, Zen Arcade was the soundtrack to a major break-up. I played those four sides at demolition volume, over and over, during the time this relationship was falling apart. Except when she was home. I was looking for catharsis; I wasn't looking to piss her off with loud music that she'd hate. (Even then, I wasn't the type of guy who liked to splash gasoline on the fire.)

Sometimes, you find the right album for bad times ... and when you've made it through the bad times, you don't feel like taking the album with you. Remarkably, though, ZA remains high on my list of all-time favorites. Maybe it's because, when I think of that ex-gf, I remember the things that made the relationship great and meaningful, and don't dwell on the breakup. Or maybe it's because the album is just flat-out great.

Everything the Dü released afterward is high on my list, too. Including the Warner albums.

kwk
Re: Husker Du
December 15, 2010 12:36PM
Out of the thousands of songs I've heard in my life, there are about 100 that shook me to my core and got permanently etched on my brain and imbedded in my heart. I'd put Celebrated Summer and Pink Turns to Blue on that list. For no reason at all I often start humming quietly "no more rope and too much dope she's lying on the bed, angels pacing, gently placing roses 'round her head"
Unbelievable band. Think about it...that entire body of work (minus Land Speed which is terrible), was produced in about 5 years. That's one hell of a 5 year span.
Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.

Click here to login