Welcome! Log In Create A New Profile

Advanced

liz phair

liz phair
July 07, 2010 05:30AM
Has anyone actually heard the album she released via her web site yesterday? I heard one track where she "raps" and goes Raga and it was inexplicably dreadful. Very very strange. People haven't been so bewildered by an album release since Paul Westerberg's 49:00.



Post Edited (07-07-10 07:35)
Re: liz phair
July 07, 2010 06:32AM
Funstyle might be fun for her, but not me.



Post Edited (07-07-10 08:36)
Re: liz phair
July 07, 2010 03:12PM
She seems to have misunderstood that the free preview track is supposed to entice listeners to want to hear the entire album, not cancel their internet service in fear that it might somehow sneak back into their house again.

Poor Liz. God knows I've tried to give her the benefit of the doubt over the last decade, but I think she's joined M Night Shyamalan in the ranks of promising artists who've ridden their muses straight into Batshitsylvania.

Although I must say I'm curious as to whether the entire album can be as horrendous as "Bollywood." One shudders to think that she might have chosen that for the preview because it's the best thing on it. I guess I pretty much have to bite the bullet and get the damn thing.

I'm scared, Mom....
Re: liz phair
July 07, 2010 03:26PM
It's so painful to listen to I'm almost tempted to say it mets the criteria of a successful experiment, like, say, the movie adaptation of Naked Lunch, or Ivan Meets GI Joe by The Clash.



Post Edited (07-07-10 17:27)
Re: liz phair
July 07, 2010 03:23PM
So THIS is what it takes to bring Brad back to the board!

(Quite a tongue-twister, that.)

That's it, morbid curiosity is gonna drive me to check this song out...
Re: liz phair
July 07, 2010 03:31PM
I just listened to it. Good gravy, she make Fergie sound like Chuck D.

Her supporters are saying it's a joke, a music biz parody. So? Then it's an unfunny joke with lame music.
Re: liz phair
July 07, 2010 03:41PM
Well, of course it's a joke and a music biz parody, but it's a joke and a showbiz parody on par with Joe Esterhauz's An Alan Smithee Film - just because it's intended to be satire doesn't excuse it from being shite. (A lesson I wish at 2/3 of the shows on Adult Swim would also learn.)

And Fab, I actually did try to make a post the other day - I was going to suggest that "The Tennessee Bird Walk" was the first synth-pop hit, but my internet connection dropped halfway through so I said screw it. But this seems like as good a place as any to bring it back up.

[www.youtube.com]
Re: liz phair
July 07, 2010 03:41PM
deleted last statement,
due to contextual discrepancy.

hello st louis!



Post Edited (07-07-10 17:49)
Re: liz phair
July 07, 2010 05:45PM
"just because it's intended to be satire doesn't excuse it from being shite."

And, here, our friend Brad whittles the issue down to its essential elements. Well played, sir.
Re: liz phair
July 08, 2010 07:08AM
Check this out:

[www.theawl.com]

If nothing else, Liz Phair prompted an enjoyable review that includes this sentence: "Ugh, way to be a bonerkiller."

Maybe that was her goal.
Re: liz phair
July 08, 2010 05:30PM
I always thought she was at best, highly overrated, and frequently bad.
Re: liz phair
July 08, 2010 11:12PM
I've now listened to the whole album, and feel like I should quarantine myself from society for a couple of weeks just to be safe. This thing is Bubonic Plague bad. It's like Millard Fillmore set to music. The heat wave that's been roasting the continental US since roughly the time this album came out is the punishment of an angry God on the nation that could produce such a horrific ogre of an album.

I'm sure I'm hyperbolizing right at the moment from the shock of the whole thing, but I honestly think it might be the single worst album I've ever heard. And I've heard the newest Editors album.
Re: liz phair
July 09, 2010 06:22AM
Quote

It's like Millard Fillmore set to music.

Ouch.

Somewhere, Warren G. Harding is breathing a sigh of relief.

...

And why does Liz Phair even merit a discussion at this late date? Her output since EIG has been crap after crap after crap. She should release official versions of those Girlysound demos and then arrange to die in a plane crash.
Re: liz phair
July 09, 2010 06:28AM
Quote

Her output since EIG has been crap after crap after crap.

I disagree. Her three 90's records are all very good IMO, though EIG is clearly the best of the lot. I despised the Matrix-produced record she put out early in the decade, but that now seems like an interesting and promising career move by comparison.

I dont know - I guess I am always compelled by musicians who receive a ton of limelight but in their public statements consistently indicate they are not that into music, and publicly dismiss their own records. That's at least why I am always interested in reading about what Liz Phair is doing (though I have stopped actually listening at this point). Plus, she's a seriously juicy Mommy!



Post Edited (07-09-10 08:28)
Re: liz phair
July 11, 2010 06:02PM
Quote

I despised the Matrix-produced record she put out early in the decade

What is the Matrix-produced record?

...

I'm going to retract my "she should die in a plane crash" statement.

It was unduly harsh in light of the fact that I've not purchased any of her records aside from EIG (used). If you say that her other stuff is worth listening to, I'll have to take your word on that.

I had a friend who used to play her second and third albums all the time, but they just never made the least impression. They just lacked the same whatever-it-was that made her debut so appealing. Perhaps it was simply the novelty factor?

But I'm sorry that I said she should die in a plance crash. That was wrong.

But I do think her demos deserve an official release. I know she's wanting to sell some product ... I'd pay for those.
Re: liz phair
July 12, 2010 09:04AM
Aitch, it's much worse than the Katy Perry song, which is one of those serviceable chunks of top-40 product that I can't get too worked up about one way or the other.

Basically, much of this new Liz Phair album plays like the extended tantrum of someone who never expected to actually have to work for a living shrieking about the injustice of having to do so and seeming to think she deserves sympathy for it. (The filler tracks on it are not so offensive. They're no good, but at least they aren't insulting like the manifesto tracks on the album.)

Dimestore psychology moment for the day: Phair was raised by well-off parents in one of the most upscale Chicago suburbs, was an Art History major at a liberal arts college (i.e. "I don't expect to ever need employment") who lucked into becoming a minor phenomenon with her first album and went on to marry a movie producer. I'm sure after that she figured life was going to be champagne brunches and garden parties from there on out.

But it turns out that cult stardom isn't enough to maintain that lifestyle once the hubby is gone, so she tried hitting it big in the mainstream, and that also was a whiz bang success first time out of the box and she seemed to think once again she was set for life but then found out the hard way that maybe the mainstream audience will buy a lot more of one of your albums but they aren't going to be particularly loyal and when her next album didn't connect with the mainstream but she'd already told her original audience to fuck off, she was left even worse off than she was before.

So now she's been doing tv soundtrack work and seems appalled by having to do so - a musician creating music for a living seeming to be a terrible thing in Phair's eyes. I doubt that very many poets working in insurance offices to survive or sculptors driving forklifts in warehouses would have much sympathy for this point of view, and most of them don't have Hollywood connections calling them on the phone offering them work, something Phair seems to be not particularly grateful for on that godawful "Bollywood" track.

Sam Phillips and Andy Partridge have both done TV soundtrack to name but two, and you don't hear them bitching and moaning about it. But I doubt they ever expected life to continue handing them things on a platter the way it apparently did for Phair the first couple decades of her life.

I was a Phair defender longer than most, but I don't know that an album has ever pissed me off more than this thing. It's such an insulting, solopsistic pity party that I really want to slap the woman.

And if the music were any good, I'd be more forgiving. But this is a tantrum set to the most excruciatingly bad music I've heard all year.



Post Edited (07-12-10 11:59)
Re: liz phair
July 12, 2010 09:20AM
Right on the money, Breno! This analysis dovetails beautifully with her tendency to denigrate music in general, and her own albums in particular, at every opportunity.

Quote

...poets working in insurance offices ...
Wallace Stevens reference?
Re: liz phair
July 12, 2010 01:13PM
I agree. That was the best thing I've read in a long time.
Re: liz phair
July 12, 2010 02:52PM
To clarify, it's not the overall concept I have an issue with - if Phair had done a thoughtful album dealing with disappointment and disillusionment, it could have been something worth hearing. But instead she took the more petulant tack of flipping the bird to anyone who dares listen to it. Not sure how that's supposed to help her situation any, but I guess it has gotten her closer back to the limelight than Somebody's Miracle ever did.

And Nosepail, I wish I'd been bright enough for that to be Wallace Stevens reference, but no, I just know someone who works in an insurance office who used to write poetry for the yearbook.
Re: liz phair
July 12, 2010 03:11PM
"...was an Art History major at a liberal arts college (i.e. "I don't expect to ever need employment")..."

wish my the head of the art history department at my school had been this honest ten years ago...
Re: liz phair
July 12, 2010 05:07PM
Well, now I feel bad...
Re: liz phair
July 12, 2010 08:16AM
I assumed once she started appearing as a talking head on those VH1 Classic "100 Greatest Songs of the _____" shows that she was no longer relevant.

I haven't listened to Exile in Guyville in well over a decade. Don't even own it anymore. I never could get into Whip-Smart or Whitechocolatespaceegg, and never went any further than that in her career. I'm sure she deserves better, but I just can't bring myself to care.

Re: liz phair
July 10, 2010 06:08PM
Just played it.

That was excrutiating ...........

Re: liz phair
July 11, 2010 06:00PM
Is it as bad as Katy Perry's smash hit California Girls?
That's as bad as anything bad I've heard so far this year.
Re: liz phair
July 14, 2010 10:24AM
More in Pitchfork today, if anyone's still paying attention:

[pitchfork.com]
Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.

Click here to login