Welcome! Log In Create A New Profile

Advanced

Guitar tapestries

Guitar tapestries
July 05, 2010 09:25AM
I've been obsessing over the Church lately, in particular the interplay between guitarists Peter Koppes and Marty Willson-Piper. I love the way that they, like their most obvious predecessors, Tom Verlaine and Richard Lloyd, often eschew the traditional lead/rhythm roles for a more intertwined approach, a la "Reptile."

And it occurs to me that I'm woefully ignorant of other such guitar teams. Can anyone recommend any other artists who take a similar approach to weaving guitar tapestries? I'm particularly interested in newer bands, whoever's continuing the tradition. (Please don't cite the Strokes, who I already know I can't stand.)
Re: Guitar tapestries
July 05, 2010 01:12PM
I listened to and was amazed by Reptile this week as well.
Last time the Church played in CO I stood a few feet away from Koppes and tried to learn. There's a lot of intricacy in his style that's subtle.

When Fucked Up came back a few months ago I thought "it's not going to effect me as much as the first time" but I still walked around goofy and brain-retreiving for a couple days. Josh Zucker and 10,000 Marbles guitar interplay (though I think more traditional rhythm/lead than what yr asking for).



Post Edited (07-05-10 15:16)
Re: Guitar tapestries
July 06, 2010 01:34AM
Michael Toland wrote:

> Can anyone recommend any other artists who take a
> similar approach to weaving guitar tapestries?

Definitely not a new band, but Adrian Belew & Robert Fripp of King Crimson might fit that description nicely. A good example would be the song Discipline off of the album with the same name.

Re: Guitar tapestries
July 06, 2010 05:56AM
You're right, they certainly do. I haven't listened to the 80s stuff in quite a while - I'll have to drag those back out.
Re: Guitar tapestries
July 06, 2010 06:41AM
Can't think of a new band in that vein, but Felt are right in there (even named for Verlaine's use of that word--ie, felt--in the song "Venus"). I personally recommend The Strange Idols Pattern and Other Short Stories LP (Cherry Red, 1984).
Re: Guitar tapestries
July 06, 2010 08:04AM
I've got a Felt collection that I haven't spent as much time with as I should. I'll haul that one out too. Thanks for the tip.

Update 7/12/10: listening to Absolute Classic Masterpieces right now. Specifically the gorgeous "Dance of Deliverance."



Post Edited (07-12-10 09:42)
Re: Guitar tapestries
July 06, 2010 10:03AM
Reg Smithies and Dave Fielding from The Chameleons U.K. spring to mind almost at once.

I'd name more, but all of a sudden ... that feels like quite enough already.

I love that band.
Re: Guitar tapestries
July 06, 2010 10:15AM
I've got lots of Chameleons - haven't listened to them in ages either. That's a good one. I'd forgotten about them.
Re: Guitar tapestries
July 06, 2010 10:36AM
Well, the Thurston/Lee intertwinings in the jammier SY songs are a pretty obvious reference too. And on the mathier side of things, some of the stuff Don Caballero did, especially on the last albums from the original lineup (i.e., not just Damon and a bunch of sidemen) was pretty cool. I'd put Polvo in a similar category, and I think their album from last year is pretty great.
Re: Guitar tapestries
July 11, 2010 01:22PM
Is In Prism a good Polvo to start with?

The only Don Cab I've heard is one of the later ones on Relapse.
Re: Guitar tapestries
July 11, 2010 01:47PM
In Prism is a great place to start! Drop the needle on The Pedlar and step away from the turntable. The only other record of theirs I love is Todays Active Lifestyles. Polvo's guitar playing is sick. Crazy alternate tuning postmodern riff madness.

I've actually been thinking about this thread a lot in the last week but have come to no clear conclusions. There's obviously a lot of great two guitar bands but the concepts of "interplay" and "guitar tapestry" are much more elusive.
Re: Guitar tapestries
July 11, 2010 08:08PM
I listened to samples of both Polvo records on Amazon today. In Prism was the most immediately appealing, but I think I'll find myself getting both.

Maybe Longwave or Lotion as well?

I suppose Jawbox fits...I was thinking more dreamy, but that's a band that doesn't follow the typical lead/rhythm guitar parts.

Guitar tapestries is a tough one, I admit. But I think everyone's risen to the occasion.
zoo
Re: Guitar tapestries
July 09, 2010 02:46PM
Smithies and Fielding are probably the best recommendation.

The Midnight Oil duo of Jim Moginie and Martin Rotsey are good as well. Their music is a bit more "riff-based" than the Chameleons and Church, but worth a careful listen nonetheless.

The other I'd recommend is Big Country--the great duo of Stuart Adamson and Bruce Watson. A LOT going on guitar-wise in those early songs.
Re: Guitar tapestries
July 10, 2010 08:08AM
I haven't listened to The Crossing in quite a while - good call.

I'll add Eleventh Dream Day to my mental list as well.
Re: Guitar tapestries
July 10, 2010 03:57PM
I like the curdling, trebly twin Tele sound Robyn Hitchcock and Kimberly Rew used in the Soft Boys. For me Underwater Moonlight is ground zero for everything I like about guitars.
Re: Guitar tapestries
July 10, 2010 10:23PM
Wow, there's one I haven't played in...god knows how long. Definitely dragging that one out later.

Update: Sunday morning. Played it during breakfast. I'd forgotten what a fantastic album it is. Loved the guitars! (Not to mention the songs.)



Post Edited (07-11-10 14:06)
Re: Guitar tapestries
July 10, 2010 11:49PM
Well played, willie. Underwater Moonlight is in my top 5 fave albums of all time and the only reason I can think of that I neglected to mention it is that, even more than with Television, one guitarist (i.e., Rew) seems to stand out more than the other. But it's true: a song like "Old Pervert" is some of the best guitar interplay one could hope for. I think I'm going to put it on right now....
Re: Guitar tapestries
July 11, 2010 12:08PM
Thanks to everyone for the suggestions, it's going to be quite a period of rediscovery. I've already spun Underwater Moonlight for the first time in ages and really dug it.

That said, with the exception of Paganizer's mention of Fucked Up, there were no new(er) artists recommended. Does this mean we're all old, or that there aren't any young groups doing that intertwined guitar thang?



Post Edited (07-11-10 15:21)
Re: Guitar tapestries
July 11, 2010 06:10PM
Dan Rumour and James Cruickshank from The Cruel Sea always seemed to interweave really nicely, especially when Tex Perkins takes a back seat.
Re: Guitar tapestries
July 11, 2010 06:17PM
Quote

That said, with the exception of Paganizer's mention of Fucked Up, there were no new(er) artists recommended. Does this mean we're all old, or that there aren't any young groups doing that intertwined guitar thang?

Did anyone mention Thin White Rope?

Would you accept Archers of Loaf? They're certainly not new, but they're newer than The Chameleons, Television, or The Soft Boys.

...

I'll cop to being older. Fiddle-dee-doo.
Re: Guitar tapestries
July 11, 2010 08:06PM
Man, I haven't listened to Rope in..decades? I don't even own any of their music anymore. Maybe I should.

I never liked Archers of Loaf, to be honest. Too Pavementy for my tastes. Thanks for the suggestion, though.
Re: Guitar tapestries
July 11, 2010 09:55PM
I like Polvo's Exploded Drawing, especially Feather of Forgiveness.
Re: Guitar tapestries
July 12, 2010 10:38AM
I agree that the newest Polvo is the best place to start. I liked all their albums back in the 90s, but I think this new one is the best of the bunch.

Thin White Rope is another great call. Moonhead is a great album that I still pull out and listen to at least once a year.

As for Don Cab, I'd say any of the first three albums are good examples of the guitar interplay and are pretty different from the later Relapse stuff.
Re: Guitar tapestries
July 12, 2010 10:58AM
Good info, thanks.

This thread has been particularly informative (as least on the stuff us old farts listen to) - thanks, guys!
Re: Guitar tapestries
July 12, 2010 11:15AM
And I am racking my brain trying to come up with some more recent examples of some good guitar interplay (not counting reunions of 90s bands). There's gotta be some....
Re: Guitar tapestries
July 12, 2010 12:56PM
When I was looking up Polvo, Chavez and the like on All Music, the name Minus the Bear kept coming up in the "followers" section. Though I listened to some on Amazon and it sounded like neo-new wave stuff to me, without much real six-string interplay.
Re: Guitar tapestries
July 12, 2010 03:27PM
I've got a few of their albums and I haven't been overly impressed. I think one of the guitarists came from a Seattle hardcore metal math rock band called Botch (who were great), but you wouldn't know it from the guitar work on the MTB albums, which leaves no impression. Plus, their singer is pretty annoying....
Re: Guitar tapestries
July 12, 2010 05:13PM
You'd think for a band with three guitarists that Radiohead would figure into this conversation, but I have a hard time thinking of very many songs where they pull out the fireworks. They seem to be three guitarist laying down textures more than weaving tapestries.
Re: Guitar tapestries
July 12, 2010 09:48PM
I was thinking the Nectarine No 9 are still going but they're older than even me.
Re: Guitar tapestries
July 13, 2010 04:49PM
Edit on the Don Caballero suggestions after going back and listening to some of that early stuff again: start with What Burns Never Returns and work backwards from there if it interests you. The early stuff is noisier (like Bitch Magnet or Bastro) than I remembered and has less of the guitar interplay. American Don is cool too, but they were down to just one guitarist at that point.

Now I'll shut up about Don Caballero unless someone wants to reopen the best drummers discussion.
Re: Guitar tapestries
July 13, 2010 12:42PM
The problem is that there are too many bands fitting this description.
Re: Guitar tapestries
July 14, 2010 09:37AM
Are there? Lay 'em on us. Especially if they're recent practitioners.
Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.

Click here to login