Welcome! Log In Create A New Profile

Advanced

MP3 players

MP3 players
April 06, 2010 06:31AM
Who has what?

Can I get some opinions on mp3 players? What are the experiences of tpr's? You know, stuff like sound quality and use of interface. Places like CNET compare the sound of Nanos to $300 mp3 players so that does me no good. Also interface is important because I will be using it while driving.
Thanks, this is Much appreciated.
Re: MP3 players
April 06, 2010 06:52AM
I can offer a rather limited, technophobic review of the two mp3 players I've owned.

The first was a Samsung (don't laugh!) that had enough room for about 100-odd tunes. My newer one is a little blue RCA that I snagged at a ubiquitous discount retail joint. I won't bother offering product numbers or details - both products were already heinously outdated when I bought them. The Samsung did have a very simple and easy-to-use interface. The RCA allows you to upgrade the memory with those tiny chips that also get used in digital cameras. I thought this was cool until I realized that the processor gets mired down trying to sort out the extra data (I'm assuming that is the cause of the slowdowns). Additionally, every few times I turn the thing on, it fails to fully boot up. Which is obnoxious. It does hold a ton of music, however. Once it's up and running, I put into 'random" mode and it'll go for hours and hours. Good for car rides. But it's virtually useless for immediate demonstrations, because it takes ten minutes to boot up!

What I do like about both products is that they both run on standard batteries. The Samsung ran on a AA and the RCA on a AAA. So there isn't this reliance on proprietary battery formats like the iPod. That sort of business drives me nuts. But I suspect that the iPod must have a very nifty interface. What else would explain it's popularity?

...

As far as sound quality goes, I base my expectations on the sound of old cassette Walkmen, so I am never disappointed.
Re: MP3 players
April 06, 2010 07:15AM
My first one was a Diamond Rio, with 32MB of storage. Lots of listening time there! If I relied on 128kbps, I could store one of the Ramones' classic albums on it. (Go right ahead and laugh!!) A friend had gotten it at a conference, along with some other schwag, and gave it to me because he couldn't make heads or tails out of it. I still have it, in a box somewhere.

Since then, I've gotten two iPod classics. The first was an 80GB, the second 160GB. Both work great. (I sold the earlier one to a co-worker; she still uses it and likes it a lot.) Good sound, good interface, and very reliable. The 80GB took a minute or so to boot up, but the 160GB is up & ready to play in nuthin' flat.

How will you be using it while driving? Will you just be listening to it on headphones (which is illegal while behind the wheel, in some states) or will it interface with your car stereo? With some high-end stereos, you don't even bother touching the iPod, after you connect it; the stereo's controls take over from there. If it's just an auxiliary/cable connection, then yeah, the iPod's interface works very smoothly. The challenge, with such low-end stuff, is hitting on just the right combination of iPod's volume and stereo's volume to give you good, undistorted sound. It can be done.

I rip my CDs at 192kbps, and get very good sound using that rate (although not as good as the source). The improvement gained by using any higher bit-rate, to my ears, is negligible.
Re: MP3 players
April 06, 2010 08:03AM
2 or 3 years ago, I inherited an 60GB iPod Classic (fourth generation) from a friend who'd recently purchased an iPhone. Then, last year I snagged a new 120GB iPod Classic (sixth generation) for the wife via iPodMeister...

I've been happy with both of them. I know there are some who feel limited or frustrated with the whole Apple thing, who don't want to feel like they're buying into a bunch of hype, but the product actually works.

I concur with Delvin re. the sound quality–you're just going to have to accept a lower standard of fidelity when files are compressed. Otherwise, both iPods boot up quickly (the old one takes maybe 10 seconds, the new one is instant), are a breeze to transfer all kinds of stuff onto, have intuitive controls and battery lives that surpass the manufacturer specs.
Re: MP3 players
April 06, 2010 08:52AM
The battery in the 80GB iPod did pretty well, I thought ... but the one in the 160GB continues to astonish me. I listen to that sucker at least an hour every day, and can go a couple weeks between recharges, no sweat.

As for sound quality, well, it depends on what you connect it to. A friend of mine has a pretty high-end car stereo, and gets great sound from his iPod. And mine sounds terrific on the Bose noise-cancelling headphones.

Re: MP3 players
April 06, 2010 09:17AM
I actually have a 120 GB Zune (now who's laughing at who) that I really like, but they don't make those anymore. The new Zunes look very cool, but they're touchscreen which I'm not a huge fan of and which I can't imagine using while you're driving. One very basic and inexpensive player that gets pretty high marks is the Sansa Clip+. Way cheaper than a comparable iPod. The screen is basic and utilitarian (no album art or coverflow), but that might be good for what you want it for. It also has expandable memory, though, as noted above, that can increase your startup time. Actually, this ties in nicely to another board I obsessively lurk at (much like this one): Anything But Ipod. As the name suggests, you won't find any iPod info there, but their stated goal is to cover alternative players. Lots of obsessives there who can give you some suggestions, help, and unprompted rants.

Re: MP3 players
April 06, 2010 01:03PM
> Lots of obsessives there who can give you some suggestions, help, and unprompted rants.

Sounds like my office. Except the obsession there is politics, not music.

iPod, take me away!
Re: MP3 players
April 06, 2010 06:25PM
Thanks for the opinions and I am very encouraged. I have an axillary jack in my car, but the stereo doesn't have the ability to control the player so the sound quality is good but the controls will be a pain in the ass.
I have been using Itunes for some time now so I am leaning toward getting an ipod (for the interface.) So I am happy to hear that most of you approve of the sound quality. I have been using Sandisks for a long time and they have always sucked as far as sound goes. I am not a brand name type of guy but if a company makes a good product then it shouldn't be held against them.
Thanks again
Re: MP3 players
April 07, 2010 01:33AM
sound quality depends on the quality of headphones
sound quality between devices is inaudible at this point - unlike stereos of yore, with MP3, the quality (consistency wise) is inherent in the technology (as it should be)

if budget is a concern, apple is 4x$ what it's worth (you can get devices that provide the exact same function without having to fit in at school)
if you like fetish technology and cost isn't an issue, buck up, they work fine.
but apple uses a proprietary format - you have to use specific software for transfer, etc. some people like the interface, others find it constricting
apple likes to think their compression is fine - others disagree (i would say it's NOT the industry standard for a reason)

i had an ipod shuffle - worthless, imo gave it away (it took hours to charge, among other probs)

flash memory is smaller, cheaper, but generally not as big, if large storage is an issue. since it doesn't boot from a drive, it can be faster (or slower if you overwhelm the processor). i prefer managing a couple dozen titles at a time and changing them out every so often convenient, so flash works for me

i like AAA batteries, recharging is too much hassle for me

RCA as a company went under in 1986. since then, companies license the trademark and make stuff of variable quality

sound won't be lower fidelity - that's a myth (in a previous thread I linked the lab reports that support the data versus the "golden ears fallacy"). humans can't hear a difference

great players can be had for $20 - which isn't much investment.
$20 headphones, however will sound like shit.
i have a pair of sennhesiers. a friend of a friend was telling me his earbuds sounded great. i let him plug in my senns and he threw his buds away. it's that drastic. they do take more juice

Re: MP3 players
April 07, 2010 07:54AM
Paganizer - let's have some specific product placement for the $20 great players of which you speak. My ancient iPod crapped out recently and I really don't want to spend much money on another one.
Re: MP3 players
April 07, 2010 07:59AM
I still listen to CDs in the car, but I do find a flash drive useful for transporting music (especially rare music that I can't find in a physical format) from home to the office.
Re: MP3 players
April 07, 2010 09:30AM
This has been a very interesting discussion. I'm not in the market for an MP3 player, but found one that looks like a pretty good deal:

[us.store.creative.com]
Re: MP3 players
April 07, 2010 05:13PM
sure, bren000

Before a flight, we stopped at Walmart because one of my nephews had nothing to use on the plane. We got a stick-style player for $19.95 and I gave him a pair of Sony phones; chucked the buds it came with (buds by nature can not reproduce low frequencies). Sounded good. Even the sticks have up to 2G flash these days. WalMart always has something on sale.
Here's what they have online right now. In-store sales might be better?

[tinyurl.com]
I haven't seen a walmart that has decent headphones in store.

I've ordered from B&H in Manhattan in the past.
[tinyurl.com]

I like the Sonys and Sennheisers in the $30-50 range; sound quality versus price. Turtle Beach might have a good low-end phone for the price. B&H gives you an idea what's available, at least.
IMO, the Sennheiser PMX100 are equal to studio phones I've used costing $300.
The PMX60 are about the same as Sony MDR570 - both good.
I've also heard the Sony MDR7505 - great, but pricier.
You do get what you pay for in phones (up to ~$90 anyway, beyond that it's fetish as far portable is concerned)

I understand if principles prevent you from shopping WalMart:
Also check Overstock.com, Price Grabber , and Price Line
for online stuffffff


edit:
I see the range is now $25-50 for those Sonys and Sennheisers
(I'm sure the Shure are good, etc., I just haven't heard them)
and sticks have up to 4G now - even in the low price range - but I'm not sure the processors are beefed up to boot up the extra storage efficiently - I have a 1G stick that's immediate - most record voice memos and have FM as well - beyond $50, they should have a vid screen; the technology is cheap now and at these prices, if the interface isn't what you want, you can give it to a kid or co-worker



Post Edited (04-07-10 19:39)
Re: MP3 players
April 07, 2010 05:53PM
Well, this is good timing. Like breno, I’ve just recently had an ancient (32g iPod Picture)
player die on me. I’ll probably go for the iPod Classic but the Zen looks interesting but as the missus already had an iPod Touch, the Classic might be easier.
MY iTUNES QUESTION TO YOU IS:
My wife hates a lot of what I listen to. Is it possible to have 2 iTunes accounts or do you have to implement some kind of sharing thing?
Can anyone help me?
Re: MP3 players
April 07, 2010 09:05PM
If you're using Windows, you can set up separate user profiles complete with separate iTunes accounts. They can use the same music library, but each user can pick & choose which songs on that menu he/she wants to include.

It's been too long since I've used Mac, so I have no comparable advice for that OS.

Re: MP3 players
April 08, 2010 12:28AM
No - using Windows - many thanks.
Re: MP3 players
April 08, 2010 12:58AM
You mentioned a couple of key things here. Interface and sound quality. As has been mentioned before the type of headphones you use play a large part in sound quality. The other aspect is the bit rate you have for your MP3's. If you are ripping your CD's to put onto your MP3 player make sure you are ripping at least at 192 kbps. Higher rates will eat up too much room on your storage drive and lower you will notice a drop in sound quality.

The interface: you really can't beat Apple here. This is their reason for being and the interface is elegant and easy to use, especially while driving. Other MP3 players have more features and capabilities for less money (The Zune as an example) but Apple is still tops in this regard.

The other aspect to bear in mind is content management. If you have a lot of music being able to organize it and to create playlists of things you want to listen to is very important. Again, Apple wins this with the iTunes software package. Especially when it comes to creating smart playlists that you can easily import to your player iTunes really excels. Also if you are going to buy music the iTunes store's only real competitor is Amazon and having the store built into your management software is an advantage.

One more note to consider, I have just over 100 GB of music in MP3 and I have blown through two iPod classics. The issue is that the classic still uses a physical hard drive and all hard drives fail. I am active and my players take a lot of abuse. If you resemble me in that regard you might look at the iPod Nano. It is a solid state drive and is much more reliable. Less storage, but if you massage your smart playlists correctly in iTunes it will rotate your music around in the player each time you sync you won't notice as much that not all your music isn't on the player. If you aren't hard on your equipment than go for the storage.
Re: MP3 players
April 08, 2010 04:54AM
Actually, I will rarely be using head phones. Mostly in my car, and the stereo at work has an auxillary jack too. Some of those Sennheisers are pretty reasonable and will eventually pick them up.
I ordered a nano because of the management and interface, although that Creative is a good deal. i have about 40gbs on my 'puter and about 200 CDs that aren't on there, that I occasionally put on there.
As long as the sound quality is good, management and interface become very important to a busy person. After using all the music programs I have come to love Itunes.

Some cars their making now have a SD card slot in the dashboard which is I think is by far the coolest. You can get 4gb cards for $12 a pop.
Re: MP3 players
April 08, 2010 10:48AM
I was right there with ya till about 6 months ago, Nosepail. I ended up cashing in some of my credit card points on an iPod Touch, mainly to make travelling with my 4-year-old easier. I don't use it a ton - even for its originally intended purpose - but it is useful when doing housework. I do not intend to convert to digital only and I still bristle at the idea of downloading albums (tho I may hafta do it for that new Sloan b-sides comp, I suppose). But I guess I'm now only a semi-noble savage.
Re: MP3 players
April 08, 2010 09:31AM
> The issue is that the classic still uses a physical hard drive and all hard drives fail....
> You might look at the iPod Nano. It is a solid state drive and is much more reliable....
> If you aren't hard on your equipment than go for the storage.

My iPod Classics have been pretty reliable, but I don't kick them around too much. At the rate they're going, I'm guessing the iPod Touch (which uses solid-state memory) will overtake the Classic for storage space in a year or so.

Re: MP3 players
April 08, 2010 09:42AM
Never bought one or used one and never will. Regards, Noble Savage Nosepail
Re: MP3 players
April 09, 2010 03:10PM
i enjoy the iTunes interface. it is uncanny how the shuffle feature will toss out a fabulous long-lost and/or unheard tune. the ease of making playlists and the elegance with which large libraries can be managed makes it easy to buy into Apple. The ability to wirelessly control my entire library with an Ipod touch and run the whole shebang through my old-school stereo continues to amaze me.

I agree with Paganizer's headphones comment, though i believe the case can be made that a high-resolution, adequately powered speaker system could justify ripping cd's at rates higher than 192kbps.

I happily replaced my car's cd-changer with a hard-wired iPod connection, (if you can do this there is a most definite improvement in fidelity over using the aux input from headphone jack...(there may be a way to get a line-out adapter for iPod)

for car use i find the iPod classic better in terms of capacity but that the touch is easier to steer.

if you pop for the sloan bsides, let us know if it's all that.



Post Edited (04-09-10 17:12)
Re: MP3 players
April 09, 2010 08:10PM
Quote

the case can be made that a high-resolution, adequately powered speaker system could justify ripping cd's at rates higher than 192kbps

To some extent. We talk about this endlessly over on the tech sites.
I've already posted the math behind transparency (and comparing LAME, AAC, Fraunhofer, etc.) that shows the necessary bit rate.

For this justification, however, if it's on a top-end stereo, could the original CD be used when source quality is of importance?

Try this:
[www.noiseaddicts.com]

In a double-blind test, on portable devices and on an average home stereo, I've yet to see somebody statistically (beyond mean) ascertain which was the CD and which was the 128kbps MP3. Logic gets overwhelmed by confirmation bias, and post-consumer rationalization.

Public listening tests even suggest that (given an ideal CoDec) 128kbps was transparent enough to make 96kbps is viable:
[listening-tests.hydrogenaudio.org]
which isn't surprising, given the reference math for MP3.

Hyrdrogen Audio performed testing over 2 years and found that only a few individuals could tell a difference between CD and MP3. Nobody (at a statistical mean) could tell a difference above 192k between MP3/CD and at 192k and up, nobody could tell a difference between CoDecs.

The elephant behind psychoacoustics is the adage:
Audiophiles listen to equipment
Consumers listen to products
Music fans listen to music

Another interesting link:
[scienceblogs.com]

Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.

Click here to login