Welcome! Log In Create A New Profile

Advanced

Is it still satire when no one (or everyone) gets the joke?

Is it still satire when no one (or everyone) gets the joke?
February 17, 2010 08:31AM
[www.cnn.com]

When Debbie Harry became an actual sex symbol, was she still satirizing sex symbols?

When people can't comprehend fairly unambiguous lyrics and call radio stations to dedicate "Every Breath You Take" or "The One I Love" to their significant others, do those songs become actual love songs?

And if Devo uses focus groups and marketing experts and the major label system and actual manage to get any hits out of it, will they be satirizing the process all the way to the bank? Will they be making fools out of the people who don't get it, or making even bigger fools out of the people who think they DO get it?

At the end of the day I just hope they make an album as good as Q: Are We Not Men? If they manage to pull that off, I won't give a damn who the joke is on.
Re: Is it still satire when no one (or everyone) gets the joke?
February 17, 2010 08:45AM
"In 1981, Devo wore green Energy Domes while performing "Whip It" on the Solid Gold television show. In a 1984 Diet Coke advertisement, Devo sported white Domes. In 2004, for Devo's shows on the Nike-sponsored Run Hit Wonder race/concert, blue Domes were used.The first versions of these Domes were made of white plastic, spray-painted red. These were later replaced with domes made in a solid red plastic in 2004, manufactured by Chaser Shirts.. In 2005, NECA Collectibles began manufacturing Energy domes for Devo out of thin, off-color plastic."

Looks like they been doing the corporate thing with the domes for awhile.
Re: Is it still satire when no one (or everyone) gets the joke?
February 17, 2010 08:48AM
I'm reminded of the guys from The KLF burning a million pounds after they "retired" from the music business.
Re: Is it still satire when no one (or everyone) gets the joke?
February 17, 2010 09:05AM
Wow, how did I not know about that? That is tooo awesome. But you shouldnt trust my opinion, since I still believe in "selling out" winking smiley
Re: Is it still satire when no one (or everyone) gets the joke?
February 17, 2010 06:55PM
I got a new copy of Duty Now for the Future for my jogging MP3 stick, an album I hadn't listened through in a couple decades, and totally dug it.

Devo are always a great show in person and it's excellent that Mothersbaugh is still spouting the same shtick to the press ("De-evolution happened and now everybody agrees") that only the fans find hilarious.

"We're playing ball with corporate society," Casale said.

Funny.

That first EP and the 1st two albums are must-haves.

It's still satire. Be Stiff or Duty Now (can't remember which) came with an order sheet of hilarious "join our corporation" products. Friends and I ordered a few items to see what would happen. As (somewhat) expected, we received snarky junk merchandise. This element was/is ahead of its time.



Post Edited (03-12-10 18:42)
Re: Is it still satire when no one (or everyone) gets the joke?
February 17, 2010 07:37PM
Paganizer, are you in a touring band? Can you give us details?
Re: Is it still satire when no one (or everyone) gets the joke?
February 23, 2010 11:34PM
@np
I was just filling in for somebody.

Imagine what it would take to be enough of a music fan to want to play in a rock band but then have no idea who the Ramones were. It boggles the mind.



Post Edited (02-24-10 01:46)
Re: Is it still satire when no one (or everyone) gets the joke?
February 24, 2010 05:37AM
All I know is that Jonathan Swift was a bad, bad man for wanting people to eat babies. Shame on you, Mr. Swift!
Re: Is it still satire when no one (or everyone) gets the joke?
April 12, 2010 04:52PM
it depends on what you regard as "rock." you might be a big krautrock fan. you might worship kraftwerk and love other Germanic/electronic acts such as neu, tangerine dream, amon duul ii, etc. and you might wish to emulate these acts by forming your own group. in which case you might never come into contact with the music of the ramones (or the velvet underground, for that matter). such an individual may even feel that contact with the "harder edge" of alt rock only INTERFERES with one's appreciation of the more "important" minimalist synth tradition........

i'm sure there are a lot of "rock" artists in dusseldorf who've never heard of the ramones........

in any case, i'm not from dusseldorf and i DO dig the ramones.
Re: Is it still satire when no one (or everyone) gets the joke?
February 17, 2010 09:58PM
Paganizer wrote:

> Even worked up a few
> versions (though I wouldn't show them to the guys I play with -
> when I was playing -at Whistler Village, actually- during our
> Canada foray a couple winters back, I tried to work in some
> Ramones. They all shook their puzzled heads "no" in
> non-recognition).

That was with Settled in Silence?

Re: Is it still satire when no one (or everyone) gets the joke?
February 18, 2010 06:33AM
I still think that Devo 2.0 is one of the greatest practical jokes ever pulled off by a rock group.
Re: Is it still satire when no one (or everyone) gets the joke?
March 05, 2010 09:26AM
Re: Is it still satire when no one (or everyone) gets the joke?
April 12, 2010 04:40PM
i think you can have it both ways. you can be a sex symbol while still satirizing sex symbols. debbie harry did this and, to a lesser extent, marilyn monroe did it before her.
as for devo, they may have used focus groups, marketing experts, and the major label system. but they DID use these "tools" in an ironic fashion. and sure, they may have had a few "hits," but in the end they managed to leave their record companies with red ink. so they may have been "using" the system much more than that system was "using" them........
Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.

Click here to login