Welcome! Log In Create A New Profile

Advanced

Girl Talk

Girl Talk
October 06, 2009 07:16AM
So is Gregg Gillis, the mash-up king behind Girl Talk, a subversive genius of sonic collage or just Stars on 45 for the new millenium?

I can't decide. I guess it's possible he's both.
Re: Girl Talk
October 06, 2009 11:18AM




Post Edited (10-06-09 13:20)
Re: Girl Talk
October 06, 2009 11:20AM
He's okay, but I don't get all the hype. There's about a 100 masher-uppers in internet-land that are alot better. GoHome Productions, Evolution Control Committee, rx, People Like Us...man, I could go on and on.

But then again, they don't just use obvious top 40 sources, they're wickedly satirical and subversive, and funny, have a better technical command (e.g. actually getting things in key).

It's like when I was a huge fan of stuff like Public Enemy & De La Soul , but everyone loved Tone Loc.
Re: Girl Talk
October 06, 2009 02:19PM
I kind of have the same feeling towards him, I guess. Listening to his stuff is undeniably fun in the "what's coming next?" vein, but I don't see a whole lot of point to it beyond "ain't it fun to stick all this stuff together"?

I'll check out the other people you mention - I'd like to hear this sort of thing with more of a point to it.
Re: Girl Talk
October 06, 2009 03:03PM
Tell me what you think of this:
[virb.com]

The stuff from "Dirt Bacharach"seems to be a particular favorite in web-world.
Re: Girl Talk
October 07, 2009 11:55AM
When I'm on a long run (10+ miles), Girl Talk tracks are welcome when they come up on the iPod shuffle. Gillis is a little different from most other mash-up type folks, because he puts together really long, continuous mixes. Also, he's not interested in subversive tone of Negativland or (to a lesser extent) Evolution Control Committee.

Have things progressed much since Steinski and Coldcut first gained attention way back when? Probably not.

Then again, there's always the gold standard for this type of thing.



Post Edited (10-07-09 13:56)
Re: Girl Talk
October 07, 2009 11:57AM
I long for the days of "Mr. Jaws".
[www.youtube.com]
Re: Girl Talk
October 07, 2009 02:08PM
Mr. Jaws cracked me up. I remember when I first bought it. They had just come out with the $2 bill, and my dad said are you gonna waste that neat nifty currency on a dumbass 45? Yes. It was almost as funny as MAD magazine's 45, the super fantabulous day, if you remember that as well.
Re: Girl Talk
October 07, 2009 02:53PM
Is it me, or was the novelty single's last heyday in the mid- to late-seventies?

Obviously, a "Pac-Man Fever" or a "Grandma Got Run Over by a Reindeer" may have slipped through the cracks now and again, but things have really declined in the world of novelty songs the past few decades.

This is all supposing we can agree on what constitutes a novelty song.
Re: Girl Talk
October 08, 2009 05:26PM
Watcha gonna do now that the novelty is gone? Can't rest on your laurels now, that's the main thing. Or else you'll wind up like all the other shlups.

-- Joy Division, Novelty
Re: Girl Talk
October 09, 2009 09:04AM
I had all those Mad 45's, and am still waiting for the Billy and the Boingers reunion.
Re: Girl Talk
October 20, 2009 12:32PM
Picked up a Girl Talk disc (Secret Diary) at the library yesterday after this discussion a few weeks ago and am listening to it now. Nigh unto unlistenable so far. Maybe someone said it above, but there's just no flow to it, which readily distinguishes it from Stars on 45. This is about as far away from something I'd want to listen to out running as I can imagine....
Re: Girl Talk
October 20, 2009 02:32PM
Gillis's early stuff is pretty jarring. His last two full lengths (Night Ripper and Feed the Animals) are much more cohesive and enjoyable.

Personally, I think he's more an idiot savant than anything else.
No Subject
October 20, 2009 05:48PM




Post Edited (01-13-10 16:39)
Re: Girl Talk
October 24, 2009 11:37PM
go gos rule!
Re: Girl Talk
November 16, 2010 01:55PM
He's back:

[illegal-art.net]

Updated because I failed to link the link. Oops.



Post Edited (11-16-10 21:41)
Re: Girl Talk
November 16, 2010 04:05PM
I downloaded and listened to the new album and am still bugged by him the same way I previously was - it's fun, but I just don't get the point of it. I guess it doesn't really need to have a point beyond being fun, but if I'm going to bother listening to it more than a couple of times, I'd like for there to be some sort of Negativland angle to it or something..

It also dawned on me that nearly all his "lead" vocal tracks are raps, meaning they could be picked up and dropped over any pretty much any backing track and they'd work. He doesn't particularly challenge himself with trying to match up a vocal melody with a different backing melody, the way GoHome Productions, for example, does with Smells Like Rockin Robin, or the Stroking Cristina Aguilera link Jermoe posted above.

[www.youtube.com]
Re: Girl Talk
November 16, 2010 04:15PM
Quote

It also dawned on me that nearly all his "lead" vocal tracks are raps, meaning they could be picked up and dropped over any pretty much any backing track and they'd work.

Because when he does go for melody, it's out of key (e.g.: his Rihanna v. Fugazi mash). Here's a guy that corrects it:

[hawkinsmashups.blogspot.com]

And check out the one below that uses X's "Los Angeles"! Really good. So of course, he'll probably be as obscure as Girl Talk is celebrated...
Re: Girl Talk
November 16, 2010 02:01PM
Yep. Touring too. Pretty substantial itinerary, in fact. (Of course, when your entire setup of stage equipment is a laptop, I guess that makes it easy.)

Re: Girl Talk
November 17, 2010 09:25PM
never heard it before, just listened... annoying.
Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.

Click here to login