Welcome! Log In Create A New Profile

Advanced

Fred Neil

Fred Neil
July 15, 2009 07:38PM
I've got the 2-disc Many Sides Of Fred Neil comp, and I find it pretty much unlistenable.

Between the tar pit of his baritone and the raga jams, it's just not worth it.

On the upside, there are a handful of classic songs, and the live album [[i]Sessions?[/i]] it includes is not bad.

But Fred Neil is just not for me.

I'd rather listen to other people cover his songs.

[[i]"Dolphins"[/i] is the most covered song in my collection. Right up there with "To Love Somebody" and "Dark End Of The Street."

Re: Fred Neil
July 15, 2009 11:04PM
M. Johnson wrote:

> I'd rather listen to other people cover his songs.

For the most part that's how I feel about Bob Dylan's music.
Re: Fred Neil
July 16, 2009 07:21AM
There are lots of good covers, but I prefer listening to the man hisself. I didn't realize until I finally heard a bunch of his stuff that without Fred Neil there would be no Tim Buckley, and I've always been a Tim fan, too.
Re: Fred Neil
July 16, 2009 07:26AM
I've been interested in Neil ever since I read Richie Unterberger's book on folk-rock. Despite M's dislike of it, is the two-disk set a good place to start?
Re: Fred Neil
July 16, 2009 09:34AM
Michael Toland wrote:

> I've been interested in Neil ever since I read Richie
> Unterberger's book on folk-rock. Despite M's dislike of it, is
> the two-disk set a good place to start?

Sure, it's a good selection and might be all you need.
Re: Fred Neil
July 16, 2009 07:38AM
Bob Dylan: “Fred used darkness as a musically potent weapon...but as skilled and powerful as he was, there was something that he lacked as a performer.”
Re: Fred Neil
July 17, 2009 02:14AM
When I listened to his 1967 album 'Fred Neil' the first thing I noticed was how his voice sounds distant and thin in the mix...his mouth too far from the microphone, the vocal drowning in reverb. What's more, he tends to pull even further away from the mike when he sings louder, which takes away the impact of his delivery.

When you move a directional mike progressively further from your mouth your voice sounds thinner and loses the lower registers due to what is known as proximity effect. It, together with the deep reverb, makes Fred sound far away, lost in an overly large acoustic space, disconnected from the instrumentals and seemingly from his own lyrics. It's disconcerting and makes it hard to get emotionally connected to the message of the song. Put that together with a narrow range of vocal expression and the result is that I never feel like he really delivers the goods.

It is problems like these that make a song ripe for covering by another performer who is better able to interpret the lyrics and package the performance.
Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.

Click here to login