Welcome! Log In Create A New Profile

Advanced

RIP

RIP
May 25, 2009 04:04AM
Jay Bennett.

Only 45.



Post Edited (05-25-09 06:11)
No Subject
May 25, 2009 09:59AM




Post Edited (02-12-10 18:51)
Re: RIP
May 25, 2009 03:52PM
I remember hearing a Titanic Love Affair album prior to Wilco, on which he was lead guitarist. Because of this, when I first saw Wilco at SXSW '95 (at what I later found out was one of their first out-of-town gigs, maybe their first), I thought, "Isn't that dreadlocked guitar player the guy in Titanic Love Affair?" I'm such a geek.

The Palace at 4 a.m., his duo record with Edward Burch, is quite good. It should have been heard by more people.

45 is way too fucking young.



Post Edited (05-26-09 09:57)
Re: RIP
May 29, 2009 09:34AM
The best take I've seen on Bennett's role in Wilco and how he'd been cast as just another obstacle Jeff Tweedy had to overcome in his ascent to godhood, but now that he's dead he can be appreciated.

[washingtontimes.com]

Although this article gives props to Kot's biography of Wilco, and Kot earned my ire on Sound Opinions one week when he was as an illustration of someone being superfluous he said "It's like having been that other guy in Uncle Tupelo." (although in fairness, it might have been DeRogatis who said that, but I think it was Kot).

Tweedy is a talented musician and in general a decent guy. But his work is moderately above-average at best when he doesn't have someone named Jay hanigng around kicking his ass to make it great.
Re: RIP
May 29, 2009 12:20PM
there really are people that consider tweedy a god?
Re: RIP
May 29, 2009 01:56PM
I hadn't intended to run down Tweedy, either, but more the overboard idolization of him in some quarters. He's a good guy and a talented musician, and speaking as a fellow native of the Illinois side of the St. Louis area, I'm damn proud of him.

However, ever since Yankee Hotel Foxtrot the coverage of him in certain circles (I'm looking at you, Sound Opinions, the Onion, and Magnet) has sometimes bordered on the surreal and unfortunately it often entails Tweedy enthusiasts running down his collaborators.

This isn't Tweedy's fault in the least, and I'd like to amend any statements I made that sounded otherwise. I've got no beef with Tweedy, just some of his more overenthusiastic supporters who've insisted on painting Bennett as some sort of deranged nutjob and Farrar as an emotionally constipated tyrant.

I do stand by the assertion that Tweedy's best work comes when he has someone else in the band pushing back at him, though, and the three albums where he has been the unquestionable driving force (AM, A Ghost Is Born. Sky Blue Sky) are good but not great, and nowhere near as good as the albums where he's butting heads with someone.
Re: RIP
June 24, 2009 03:17PM
Quote

there really are people that consider tweedy a god?

I'm always rooting for Sylvester ...

Seriously though. I never once read a thing about Wilco in all my life that made me want to run out and buy / borrow / steal / download their music (which isn't their fault, I suppose). When I finally snagged a freebie of Being There I ... wasn't impressed. I worked in Philadelphia with guys who claimed to really like Wilco (and one who firmly averred that Sonic Youth wasn't any good). After listening to what I would describe as "way too many other Wilco titles," I still don't see what all of the fuss is about. The stuff certainly isn't the worst, but so what? Gimme Souled American any day. They were the shit!

Now ... having said that ... I did enjoy following Wilco's nearly epic struggles with the "business end" of the music industry.

OH HELL DEPT: I realized what the thread was about just as I hit the "post" button. Sorry. No matter what I think about the music, I do try to maintain some respect for the recently deceased. I'm wearing a black armband mentally for the rest of the evening. Sorry.



Post Edited (06-24-09 17:23)
Re: RIP
May 29, 2009 07:45PM
My thoughts on Jeff Tweedy are pretty much that he was better before everybody told him he was an "artiste".

Being There and especially Summerteeth are strong records, YHF is mostly good but full of pretentions and at times it's dullsville.

Post-YHF, I haven't had much interest.

Sky Blue Sky sounded like easy listening music to me.

Re: RIP
May 29, 2009 09:49AM
It's sad how he became the "heavy" in some sort of cultural we-love-Wilco narrative. I have friends who hate the guy simply because they're huge Wilco fans, and have never thought about Tweedy as anything but a god. I think he's damned talented, certainly, but he's much better when his collaborators challenge him a bit.

It was sad to see Bennett start the legal processes to get some money, which I assume it was partially for health issues, but also to try and get his name cleared.

All that said, this new album sounds better than anything they've done since Summerteeth, but I haven't listened to it enough to see how the lyrics and themes hold up. Damn, I still sound like a Lit teacher when I write that stuff. I miss teaching.
Re: RIP
May 29, 2009 11:28AM
sir blast O,
no regrets brudda.
email me, i'll have you adjuncting full time (along with all the part time benefits too!) in a heartbeat.

in the meantime, we all, the us, of the TP will devise a questionnaire of sorts for you to submit alongside your results with selected essays's, once again, posted and found here.

Here's to jumping ship headed to new shores mate!



Post Edited (05-29-09 17:29)
Re: RIP
May 29, 2009 12:30PM
Let's not get carried away here, folks. Jeff Tweedy may not be a visionary, but he's not a hack, either. By the time Uncle Tupelo released and toured Anodyne, many fans felt like he needed to ditch Farrar, not the other way around. It's not like the dude is Forrest Gump, just meandering from one golden moment to the next.

Being There is certainly a quantum leap from A.M., and Jay Bennett deserves a ton of credit for that development...and so does everyone else involved. At the same time, I felt like they hit another creative peak with Sky Blue Sky. In any case, the show I saw them play last month is as good as any I attended in the Bennett years (saw them 7 or 8 times between 1996 and 2001).

If there's a perception that Jay Bennett was mistreated/misrepresented by the film I am Trying to Break Your Heart (apparently Mr. Bennett felt that way), perhaps filmmaker Sam Jones deserves to be vilified. Or Jim O'Rourke. None of it will make any difference at this point.

Bennett's death and his circumstances at the time are both extremely sad. Jeff Tweedy is certainly a very intense individual. To take these facts and promote the idea that Tweedy simply used and discarded Jay Bennett, however, is revisionist history.
Re: RIP
May 29, 2009 12:46PM
"there really are people that consider tweedy a god?"

Yup. I know a few of them. I had a friend send a "Fuck you Jay Bennett" e-mail around in support of the band, and all it did was compare Tweedy to Dylan and The Beatles. The mass e-mail's replies weren't far from it.

I hope my entry didn't sound like I was putting down Tweedy, who I do think is a damned talented individual, but one I think works better with some collaboration/confrontation. I just wonder if the documentary -- (hey, all documentaries take sides (Lake of Fire comes the closest to a neutral one as any I've seen, and is mindblowingly fantastic but will make you question every thought you've ever had about abortion, regardless of your current stance)) -- and its portrayal of Bennett actually hurt his ability to make music. Did people -- other artists -- see that and decide they didn't want to work with him based on how he seems to come across in the film? That would be damned cruel.

Well, what do I know? I'm now both wishing I'd finished my degree and heading off to the local Hastings to pick up the just-released-over-here DVD of The Fall and Rise of Reginald Perrin, and then starting a Fall listening party with the wife. Awesome weekend in store.

Edited for some seriously sloppy typing.



Post Edited (05-29-09 14:47)
Re: RIP
May 29, 2009 02:50PM
[originally posted in a different edit elsewhere]

I generally avoid music shows (don't like the volume or crowds) but one of the best I've seen was Wilco in 2000.

Jay Bennet was the guy who made that such a great show. The stuff he conjured up on multiple instruments (sometimes during the same song) was fantastic, enhancing every song. You could tell he was having a blast, and the crowd loved him. The only person who didn't seem to be having a great time was Jeff Tweedy, who just crossed his arms and frown-smirked during one extended Bennet-solo, even though Jay's stage-theatrics took nothing away from any of the other band members or performance, and only served to make a better show and new Wilco converts that night.

I'd been a fan since BEING THERE, and was blown away by SUMMERTEETH (and loved both Bragg collabs) but I didn't bother hearing YHF until it was released commercially, and I've never seen the doc (IATTBYH.) I actually thought YHF was a minor disappointment compared to what came before (and I'm much more apt to put on GHOST,) but after seeing that 2000 performance (and knowing how that run of albums was overwhelmingly influenced by Jay Bennet) I've always considered Tweedy a bit of an ass, and looked forward to seeing which genius he exploits and cuts loose next [Sorry, Nels Cline. The clock is ticking.] Jeff Tweedy might be (?) a pretty damn good songwriter (who knows,) but "A circle can only have one center?!" Who the fuck cares when you've got an asset like Bennet?

Sure, I wouldn't even try to deny that some relationships deteriorate and just can't work out. But it does seem like Tweedy's got a talent for launching himself out of collabs that appear anything but unproductive.

I heard TRACE around the same time I heard BEING THERE, and found that it had a couple of great songs and not much else to recommend it. So I was amazed when I sought out ANODYNE and heard just how superior Farrar's songs were. Tweedy obviously grew as a songwriter over his run with Tupelo, but I cannot believe that any reasonable listener would think that Farrar was hurting the music they were producing. Tweedy always comes across as a talented-though-lesser light in Tupelo. And A.M. was no ANODYNE.

All that being said, it's my shame to admit I never "got around" to spending one cent on Bennet's post-Wilco career. Not one cent, not one album. I never even bothered to preview his songs for free, or even write him one short supportive email.

So dumb.

Re: RIP
May 29, 2009 03:46PM
Interesting discussion, gentlemen. I'll count myself among those who felt Farrar's post-Tupelo career would outshine that of his former bandmates. Seeing them on that last tour, however, the tensions were obvious, and it seemed like everyone would've been happier ending what had become an unpleasant relationship. I've never really listened to Uncle Tupelo's stuff as "Tweedy songs" vs. "Farrar songs"...

I believe I've referenced this before on another thread, but Tweedy can be quite confrontational with his audience. He's never struck me as a natural frontman. At the same time, I've seen shows where the band gets in a groove and everyone in the place is just havin' fun.

Being There is my favorite Wilco album. My least favorite is Yankee Hotel Foxtrot. I continue to enjoy their new work. I don't understand the interpersonal dynamics of the band, but they've definitely earned at least 3 spots in my top 10 concert experiences, most recently about 6 weeks ago.

In conclusion, I'll cite the final paragraph from an e-mail the Jay Bennett mailing list sent out earlier this week:
Quote

So, please spend some time this week engaging in Jay's favorite passions: listen to a Nick Lowe album, watch some Mythbusters on Discovery, play Warren Zevon's "Roland the Headless Thompson Gunner," rent Pay It Forward (one of his favorite movies), write a song with the TV on and the sound off, and focus on how Jay always concluded his communications: "Love, Jay."
Re: RIP
May 29, 2009 02:54PM
signed,
forever haunting the band from now on.

edit button...there it is.
see the movie CLOSER.
godamnit, i mean CONTROL.



Post Edited (05-29-09 16:57)
Re: RIP
May 30, 2009 10:40AM
Jim DeRogatis just referred to Tweedy as the Bob Dylan or Neil Young of his generation on Sound Opinions.

Again, I like Tweedy. But I definitely believe that if David Kahne had just let Yankee Hotel Foxtrot be released as originally scheduled and not unwittingly cast him as the heroic artist fighting against The Man, Tweedy would be spoken of about the same way as Jason Lytle is - a well respected cult artist who puts out pretty good albums that no one goes overboard on the hyperbole about. If not for Kahne handing them a compelling story, no one would be going overboard on the Wilco adulation.

But because of the whole getting dropped from the label, YHF became one of those pre-ordained classics that have been discussed on other threads on this board. No way was Kahne going to be proven right, that the album would have been a hard sell commercially and probably wouldn't even have matched Summerteeth's pretty dismal sales figures. No, for the story to work out the way everyone wanted it to, it had to be a classic album by the best band in America, dammit.

Which makes it sound like I don't like YHF, which would be untrue. I like it just fine. But if Reprise had put it out on schedule with no fuss and bother or dropping of the band, it would have sold 25,000 copies, Reprise would have dropped them after it had bombed, they would've gotten picked up by Merge or Matador or some other sizable indie label and Wilco would have a fanbase about the same size as Sparklehorse's.

So Tweedy should probably send Kahne a nice basket of fruit every Christmas or something.
Re: RIP
June 03, 2009 11:24AM
gotta admit best wilco show i ever saw was them backing billy bob bragg wrasslin them mermaid avenue tunes. jay was all over the place both on instruments and stage antics.
Re: RIP
June 24, 2009 10:11AM
Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.

Click here to login