Welcome! Log In Create A New Profile

Advanced

Coldplay accused of plagiarism (what, again?)

Coldplay accused of plagiarism (what, again?)
May 06, 2009 11:38AM
First Satriani, now this guy.

Re: Coldplay accused of plagiarism (what, again?)
May 06, 2009 11:59AM
Cat Stevens, eh? I wouldn't mess with him - he'll get all jihad on yo' ass.
Re: Coldplay accused of plagiarism (what, again?)
May 06, 2009 12:25PM
That song has started to irritate the fuck out of me (I don't listen to the radio much and yet I've still heard it a million times), so I'm thinking that anything that gets it yanked off the air is a good thing.
Re: Coldplay accused of plagiarism (what, again?)
May 06, 2009 04:39PM
Michael Toland wrote:

> That song has started to irritate the fuck out of me (I don't
> listen to the radio much and yet I've still heard it a million
> times), so I'm thinking that anything that gets it yanked off
> the air is a good thing.

Maybe they should change their name to "Overplay"....
Re: Coldplay accused of plagiarism (what, again?)
May 10, 2009 06:32PM
Quote

Maybe they should change their name to "Overplay"....

"Culledploy" is my suggestion.
Re: Coldplay accused of plagiarism (what, again?)
May 13, 2009 11:29PM
HollowbodyKay wrote:

Quote

>> Maybe they should change their name to
>> "Overplay"....
>>
> "Culledploy" is my suggestion.
Or perhaps "Cold Plagiarism"....
Re: I accuse Deerhunter of plagiarism
May 14, 2009 10:30AM
One of my favorite songs of last year was "Nothing Ever Happened" by Deerhunter. However, the other day when listening to the Cure's Join the Dots box set, I noticed the main riff of the instrumental break from the Deerhunter is identical to a riff that runs through the obscure Cure b-side "The Big Hand."

Much more identical than Coldplay to Satriani, anyhow, and much more likely to imagine that Deerhunter listened to the Cure than Coldplay did to Satriani.

So Robert Smith had better keep an eye on Deerhunter in case they ever make a dime.
Re: I accuse Deerhunter of plagiarism
May 14, 2009 01:20PM
I just hope Mr. Smith knows what they (Billy Joel?) say about glass houses and throwing stones...

[www.youtube.com]

[www.youtube.com] (in which New Order reinforce their crap live rep)
Re: Coldplay accused of plagiarism (what, again?)
May 06, 2009 01:07PM
That's actually the third accusation on that song. The first was by some hipster (unknown) Brooklyn band that I refuse to give any exposure to here...since their accusation itself was aimed at getting exposure.
Re: Coldplay accused of plagiarism (what, again?)
May 06, 2009 01:18PM
Sheesh, this is turning into the trend of the year. First Joe Satriani, a musician whose commercial heyday is way behind him, decides that Coldplay's latest hit sounds enough like one of his old songs to warrant a lawsuit.

Now Cat Stevens, a guy who changed his name and turned his back on pop stardom 30 years ago, and who recently decided to resume a recording career, only to find that the world really doesn't give a shit about his worthless music anymore and he can't even get arrested — wait, never mind — decides that the Coldplay hit sounds an awful lot like one of his crappy songs too.

I especially love the part about whether he'll actually file suit: "It depends on how well Satriani does." What the hell does that mean? Does he figure the court won't swallow the notion that Coldplay could've ripped both of them off? Does he reckon that if Satriani wins, there won't be a big enough pot of royalties available to make his own lawsuit worth the trouble? Or is he waiting to see which direction the royalties flow, so he knows just who to sue? Or is he waiting for Satriani to lose, so he can say, "Damn right! Coldplay stole the song from ME, not him!"

Regardless of the results, Mr. Toland, I don't think any of this will eliminate the song's airplay. It'll just change who ASCAP collects royalties for.

Re: Coldplay accused of plagiarism (what, again?)
May 06, 2009 01:57PM
Of course. I was just hoping it would raise enough of a stink that fans might lose interest. Undoubtedly not, though.

One thing I will say defense of Coldplay (but not their music, which makes my spleen itch): when they filmed an episode of the TV show for which I work, they were extremely nice, reasonable, gracious people.
Re: Coldplay accused of plagiarism (what, again?)
May 06, 2009 07:34PM
I think Coldplay, Satriani and Yusuf Stevens should all sue everyone involved in this:

[www.youtube.com]
Re: Coldplay accused of plagiarism (what, again?)
May 06, 2009 09:41PM
great Uchube.
janisjoplin/johnlennon & the 88.
fucking sweet man.
Re: Coldplay accused of plagiarism (what, again?)
May 07, 2009 07:21AM
Mr. Toland: see a doctor about that itchy spleen. That's not something you ignore, dude.

Re: Coldplay accused of plagiarism (what, again?)
May 07, 2009 08:18AM
There is a radio station here in OKC: Magic 104. It's what everyone listens to at work, although I have NPR at my desk. It's one of those horrific, play what "30-something-secretaries-who-thought-Jon-Bon-Jovi-was-hard-rock-at-the-time" like to listen to. Every once in a while, they play a couple of Coldplay's songs.

I never thought I would look forward to hearing Coldplay.

But it's better than Michael McDonald's cover of "Ain't No Mountain High Enough", which is blasphemy of the inquisition punishing kind.
Re: Coldplay accused of plagiarism (what, again?)
May 14, 2009 01:24PM
my spleen is still bleeding too on a counta el cahon's own, that river Nile!



Post Edited (05-14-09 15:25)
Re: Coldplay accused of plagiarism (what, again?)
May 14, 2009 01:49PM
Gotta kill this thread somehow right?
fine. here goes.
I've been listening to nuggets cd's all day so i say plagIarize ARISE!
for instance, i heard a band on vol#1 first cd that might as well be THE LIBERTINES.



Post Edited (05-14-09 15:52)
Re: Coldplay accused of plagiarism (what, again?)
May 14, 2009 01:55PM
When plagiarism is done properly the only people who don't excuse it are the ones who hope to profit from it.
Re: Coldplay accused of plagiarism (what, again?)
May 15, 2009 02:36PM
When plagiarism is done properly, the only people who don't excuse it are the ones who hope to profit from it.



Post Edited (05-15-09 16:37)
Re: Coldplay accused of plagiarism (what, again?)
May 15, 2009 04:00PM
Irritation is the severest form of flattery.
Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.

Click here to login