Welcome! Log In Create A New Profile

Advanced

R.I.P. Poll

R.I.P. Poll
February 25, 2008 05:31PM
Whose death was the most untimely?

Who would have made the greatest/most artistically important contribution to music had they lived past their expiration date?

This is NOT to be based on speculation!!!!! Do not vote unless you KNOW FOR SURE!!!!!!! There is no room for idle guesswork in this poll!!!!!!!!!!!

[www.yourfreepoll.com]



Post Edited (02-25-08 19:31)
Re: R.I.P. Poll
February 25, 2008 07:07PM
I went with Bob Marley. Even though I don't really listen to them, I think really Hendrix and Marley are the two that would have continued having an impact. Both would have made great Rubin produced comeback albumswinking smiley

Bolan is my favorite artist in the list but I am not sure he would have faired well in the Eighties. He did go out on a high note with his last album Dandy.
Re: R.I.P. Poll
February 25, 2008 07:11PM
I went with Hendrix, not because I'm a huge fan or anything, but just because he seemed the most stylistically adventurous. In his 27 years (and very brief recording career) he did things that covered an amazing amount of ground, and he surely would have continued to explore over a fuller career.
Re: R.I.P. Poll
February 26, 2008 10:27PM
great comments by all . i have to agree with everybody on hendrix.
one thing about jimi is his audience was and is predominately white and i have read that towards the end that he really wanted to reach out to a black audence. i dont think his way of going about it would have been to go commercial and sell out.
this is pure speculation but i think he could have crossed many genres and with he could have even have traded in his guitar for a keyboard on some songs. he could have went in a more fusion jazzier sort of direction. or even without his guitar playing he still was a great singer n songwriter , which is like saying babe ruth was a great baseball player without his homeruns.
Re: R.I.P. Poll
February 25, 2008 08:03PM
I went with Hendrix, too, but this took awhile. I initially went with Sam Cooke, who I think might have broken through his pop persona into a great civil rights champion, but that's based on one song, albeit one of the greatest ever. I love Otis above most, but I don't know how much further he would've pushed things. Would he have gone with the almost folk/soul of Dock of the Bay? Or would the Sly Stone revolution have left him behind? Buddy Holly might have continued to push both the pop and recording formats, or he might have had no choice but to join the early 60's teeny bop-a-thon.

Hendrix, on the other hand, was continuing to push his work and his popularity in an artistic and personal manner, more than Marley -- who I also considered very strongly. Band of Gypsies seems so close to creating a more fluid synthesis of rock and funk/soul that it makes me want to hear what he would've done next more than anyone else on the list, which is what made it for me. Cobain was also up there, which surprised me. In Utero is a great artistic statement that just doesn't quite connect all its dots, but is still mighty impressive. Would he have been able to ride commercial fame the way Radiohead has? To continue using his clout to push the art form's boundaries?

Sorry, but Morrison would have only faded out. I have no respect for The Doors, except to say that they pushed some boundaries that allowed better, fuller artists like Iggy Stooge and the Velvets to prosper. If they'd stayed around, The Doors would be a footnote. Period. Instead, the cult lives on.

Great idea, but I wish we could've voted more than once. I would have added Zappa to the list, even with his 25+years, since his later stuff impresses me so much, and The Yellow Shark shows that he was a great composer, regardless of the dooty jokes.
Tim Buckley
February 26, 2008 09:19AM
I went with Hendrix as well.

Someone I've always had high alternate-timeline hopes for is Tim Buckley. Sure, he made a retreat into plastic R&B after his most adventurous period, but I've always imagined that had he lived and accepted his commercial failure that eventually he would have set up camp in the wilds and just done what he loved.

And maybe an audience would have caught up to him in the 80's and he would have been a kind of parallel-Tom Waits.
Re: R.I.P. Poll
February 26, 2008 11:18AM
The poll contains a myriad of solid choices to choose from (Cochran, Curtis and Marley in particular). However, whether you like them or not (I rarely listen to them myself) I think it would be hard to argue against Cobain and Nirvana still having a lot left in the tank and possibly having some of their best music still ahead of them. Had they kept recording they would have more than likely reached the stratosphere of the most popular Rock bands in history. Still at a relatively early stage in their career, they nearly did that with only three proper studio albums under their belt.

That being said, I think the most glaring example of an untimely demise is Robert Johnson. Had he not made that deal with the devil at such an early age, he would have left a more prolific catalog for even more countless artists to plunder and who knows what he could have or would have done with an electric guitar.

Others who more than likely had strong material still left in them:

Gram Parsons - passing shortly after his solo career gets underway
Bon Scott - AC/DC's best records are with him on vocals
Exploding Hearts - very sad as they barely got their career off the ground
Johnny Cash - the niche Rubin created for him would have only continued
Nikki Sudden - his last couple of records were among his finest solo recordings
Kirsty MacColl - was still putting out good records
Jacob Miller - although Inner Circle broke commercially after his passing, he was among Jamaica's best and most popular singers when his life ended
Hugh Mundell - after putting out one of the classic Reggae albums at the age of 13 or 14, getting struck down at 21 was a shame

Re: R.I.P. Poll
February 26, 2008 11:54AM
Yeah, there were only 25 possible slots. Can't believe I forgot Parsons, though.

Others that I had and axed for space: Patsy Cline, Janis Joplin, Malcolm Owen, Phil Lynott, Marvin Gaye, Bon Scott, Keith Moon, Peter Tosh, Darby Crash, Lester Bangs, Mia Zapata, Warren Zevon, Jimmy McCulloch and Keith Relf.

And oh - Jim Croce.



Post Edited (02-26-08 16:04)
Re: R.I.P. Poll
February 26, 2008 12:54PM
Kirsty MacColl was/is one of the most underrated artists ever. Yeah, I might have voted for her instead of Hendrix, just because I kept believing she would break through to a much larger audience and go on to become a role model, not just an artist. Kite is an extraordinary record, and Galore a "Greatest Hits" album that never fails to turn someone into a fan by the halfway point. And she had a crackin' bust, too.

I agree that Hendrix might've drugged himself out of his creative phase, but he also drugged himself into his phase.

I dearly wish Cobain had joined Poly Styrene in the Krishnas, since that might have saved him from the world.

I have no idea why I didn't think about Gram Parsons, or Janis Joplin. Possibly the same reason I didn't consider Robert Johnson -- they loom large with their legends, more symbol now than human.
Always someone with a big nose, who knows
February 26, 2008 08:10PM
It's a dreaded sunny day, blasmo! [if you get my drift...]

Did you guys know that Kirsty MacColl was murdered? [culpable homicide]

Find out about the "Justice for Kirsty" campaign.

Re: R.I.P. Poll
February 26, 2008 11:22AM
I voted for Sam Cooke because I felt that he could have made a major contribution to Soul music if he had lived. I think that the Los Angeles soul/R&B scene would have been as important as the ones in Memphis & Detroit if he was still around to mentor the talent there (one of his ideas was to have storefront "Soul shops" in the Watts area where kids could develop their talents). He was well on his way from leaving his "pop" style before his senseless death as "A Change Is Gonna Come" indicated & going back to his gospel roots, which was the basis of soul music. As it was, he was a major inspiration to people like Aretha & Otis, who both covered his songs, as well as countless other artists.
Re: R.I.P. Poll
February 26, 2008 12:10PM
> This is NOT to be based on speculation!!!!! Do not vote unless you KNOW
> FOR SURE!!!!!!! There is no room for idle guesswork in this poll!!!!!!!!!!!

I trust you meant that ironically, Reno. It's all speculation. Had Hendrix lived, his drug habits might have caught up with him to Syd Barrett levels. Had Cobain lived, he might have turned his back on stardom and music altogether, and perhaps joined the Hare Krishnas (with Poly Styrene as his guru). Had Sam Cooke and Otis Redding lived, they might be playing Vegas today. Who knows?
Re: R.I.P. Poll
February 26, 2008 12:36PM
I voted for Hendrix, but I really wonder if James Brown could have held on to his King of Soul title if Otis had lived. Otis in the funk era - can you imagine?
Re: R.I.P. Poll
February 26, 2008 01:25PM
"Otis in the funk era-can you imagine"

Or how about Otis in the disco era? Anyway, I think that Otis' death, as well as Martin Luther King's death in Memphis several months later, was the beginning of the end of the classic Soul era. I'm not sure whether if Otis lived that he was going to stick w/Stax Records. From what I remember reading in the bio Otis!, that he was planning to go to Atlantic Records (his protege Arthur Conley was on Atco).
Re: R.I.P. Poll
February 26, 2008 12:36PM
I know for a fact that Lennon and Yoko would've ended the 80s working with Skinny Puppy on industrial albums.

Actually, a friend of mine did convince himself that would be the case. He became obsessed with the LennOno industrial phase he was sure would have come had John lived. Myself, I just listened to his albums which the punk explosion supposedly spurred him to record, and I hear "Starting Over" and "Watching the Wheels." Good songs, no doubt, but not really very reflective of the fact that it was reportedly hearing the B-52s and Lene Lovich that got him out of the kitchen and back into the studio.



Post Edited (02-26-08 16:05)
Re: R.I.P. Poll
February 26, 2008 08:23PM
MOTHERFUCKER! I can't believe I forgot Grant McLennan on that list.
Re: R.I.P. Poll
February 26, 2008 10:19PM
For a minute there I thought the ghost of Karen Carpenter had killed Stevie Ray Vaughan.
Re: R.I.P. Poll
February 26, 2008 09:18PM
Stephen Ray Vaughan had plenty of mileage left in him when he shuffled off this mortal coil. Did Karen Carpenter bump him off the list?

Re: R.I.P. Poll
February 27, 2008 07:56AM
Completely forgot Vaughan also.

And Jobriath!
Re: R.I.P. Poll
February 27, 2008 08:04AM
Stevie Ray was barely inventive or original while he was alive. What makes any one think he would have started later?
Re: R.I.P. Poll
February 27, 2008 09:25AM
Ritchie Blackmore is in the house, apparently.

I just watched some of his final Austin City Limits appearance the other day and was marveling how, despite his clear influences (Albert King, Hendrix, T-Bone Walker), he still didn't sound quite like anybody else. I think he did a great job of synthesizing his influences into his own musical persona. Considering that he was finally sober and clearheaded the year or two before he died, who knows where he might have gone had he lived?

Don't blame SRV for his legions of uninspired imitators (Jonny Lang, Kenny Wayne Sheperd, John Mayer, not to mention the two million would-be SRVs here in Austin). I admit to sometimes wishing he's never picked up a guitar every time I hear one of these crackers belch up a semi-accurate Stevie Ray lick.
Re: R.I.P. Poll
February 27, 2008 10:27AM
And for the record, I really would have been interested to hear what Karen Carpenter might have done had she lived longer.
Re: R.I.P. Poll
February 28, 2008 09:32AM
The whole Bators-Thunders-Dee Dee thing that went down in Paris is explained in the book Trash! by Kris Needs. Excellent book.
Re: R.I.P. Poll
February 27, 2008 11:08AM
Stevie Ray may not have been "inventive or original," but he was a damn fine guitarist. Having met him, I can say he was a hell of a nice guy too.
Re: R.I.P. Poll
February 27, 2008 04:12PM
As much as I wanted to pick Johnny Thunders in this poll I didn't hear enough at the tail end of his life that would have indicated that he had another great album in him (although Disappointed In You is a swell song).

But to come to think of it, after hearing a surprisingly decent new Dolls album a couple of years ago, I can only imagine how much better that album would have been with Thunders' contribution. Thunders, Johansen and Sylvain together on a new studio Dolls album would have been one of the greatest moments in rock n' roll history easily eclipsing when The Beatles came to America (though Kane and Nolan would still be missing). So, even if Thunders died some 15 years before an eventual Dolls release it was still mighty untimely.

Also, Stiv Bators. The Dead Boys got together for some live shows thoughout the 80's and released a great single, Poison Lady (All The Way Down) only a few years before Bators' life ended. So in retrospect, perhaps the Dead Boys would have eventually reformed and based on the quality of that single maybe they would have released some new quality records if not for Bators' unfortunate accident.

Now I have to dig up the tape I have with that 1987 single. Even better, it has the one Wanderers album on the flip side.

Re: R.I.P. Poll
February 27, 2008 05:59PM
>
> Also, Stiv Bators. The Dead Boys got together for some live
> shows thoughout the 80's and released a great single, Poison
> Lady (All The Way Down) only a few years before Bators' life
> ended. So in retrospect, perhaps the Dead Boys would have
> eventually reformed and based on the quality of that single
> maybe they would have released some new quality records if not
> for Bators' unfortunate accident.
>


i played the wheelman for cheetah chrome for a few days in november of 1989 and he assured me some sort of reformation was imminent. the quality of the stuff cheetah had been doing recently with sonny vincent and jeff dahl did have me excited about the prospect, but for all i know, that idea may have been kaput by the time of stiv's death the following june. heck, for all i know it might've just been the drugs talking. bob stinson was also riding along for a couple of those days...yipes



Post Edited (02-27-08 20:02)
Re: R.I.P. Poll
February 27, 2008 07:45PM
Around the same time I read that Bators was looking to form a band with Thunders and Dee Dee Ramone (which would have been true rock n' roll bliss for me) but nothing came to fruition. However, TP conflicts that account saying it was Godfathers' guitarist Kris Dollimore instead of Thunders.

Which is the true story? From everything I've read and seen, I would find it a bit peculiar for Thunders and Dee Dee to be in any band together as there seemed to be quite a bit of bitter rancor between the two.

Re: R.I.P. Poll
February 27, 2008 08:48PM
Shizzle wrote:

> Around the same time I read that Bators was looking to form a
> band with Thunders and Dee Dee Ramone (which would have been
> true rock n' roll bliss for me) but nothing came to fruition.
> However, TP conflicts that account saying it was Godfathers'
> guitarist Kris Dollimore instead of Thunders.
>
> Which is the true story? From everything I've read and seen, I
> would find it a bit peculiar for Thunders and Dee Dee to be in
> any band together as there seemed to be quite a bit of bitter
> rancor between the two.
>


dollimore did play on last race. and dee dee did write "poison heart". didn't i read somewhere that johnny and dee dee got into some sort of bitch slap fight over clothing (and drugs, duh) while visiting stiv in paris?
Re: R.I.P. Poll
February 27, 2008 08:59PM
I believe that is talked about in PLEASE KILL MEsatchmykels wrote:

> Shizzle wrote:
>
> > Around the same time I read that Bators was looking to form a
> > band with Thunders and Dee Dee Ramone (which would have been
> > true rock n' roll bliss for me) but nothing came to fruition.
> > However, TP conflicts that account saying it was Godfathers'
> > guitarist Kris Dollimore instead of Thunders.
> >
> > Which is the true story? From everything I've read and seen,
> I
> > would find it a bit peculiar for Thunders and Dee Dee to be
> in
> > any band together as there seemed to be quite a bit of bitter
> > rancor between the two.
> >
>
>
> dollimore did play on last race. and dee dee did write
> "poison heart". didn't i read somewhere that johnny and dee
> dee got into some sort of bitch slap fight over clothing (and
> drugs, duh) while visiting stiv in paris?
ira
Re: R.I.P. Poll
February 27, 2008 09:25PM
I know i'm gonna sound positively ancient here, but put me down for

Eddie Cochran
Sam Cooke
Bobby Fuller
Joe Meek
Jimi Hendrix
Kurt Cobain

I may be forgetting a few here, but most of the goners were creatively expired well before they clocked out.
Re: R.I.P. Poll
February 27, 2008 10:47PM
When I think, "who would I have liked to have heard more of?" I think Mia Zapata.
Re: R.I.P. Poll
February 29, 2008 09:47PM
Hands down, Otis Redding.

I may be biased because we're both from Georgia, but at the time of his death, Redding was just coming into his own, he was crazy innovative and he didn't have the self-destructive tendencies of so many others in this poll.

4 or 5 years in, he was just beginning to push the boundaries artistically. And the man's voice was R&B.
Re: R.I.P. Poll
March 03, 2008 08:36AM
I'd give a vote to Sam Cooke. Not only did he have the voice and the songwriting talent, but he was one of the first musicians of color to take control of the business side of his career. He started his own label, and from all indications, was turning it into a viable enterprise at the time of his death. He was ahead of Marvin Gaye and Stevie Wonder in that regard ... to say nothing of the Beatles.
Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.

Click here to login