Welcome! Log In Create A New Profile

Advanced

Alternative.....Pop

Alternative.....Pop
December 06, 2007 03:02AM
While playing the La's yesterday I started to think that there was this sort of period where smart pop bands seemed to be bubbling just under the mainstream, but then kinda got avalanched under grunge.

I'm thinking specifically of the La's labelmates, The Trashcan Sinatras whose "Obscurity Knocks" was one of the great singles of that period and a minor radio hit (as was "Only Tongue Will Tell") :

[www.youtube.com]

Which got me thinking about who might be an equivalent of this today, Aztec Camera-ish bands who don't quite "rock" (and aren't being ironic about it) but are so smart and strong on the melodies they don't come across as being wimpy (or if they do, you take them on their own terms because the craft is so strong).

Are there bands today who think of "High Land, Hard Rain" as their foundation, or has that moment passed? Seems odd, that this decade which has constantly recycled the past would be missing these kind of bands.

Unless I'm just drawing a blank........



Post Edited (12-06-07 10:43)
Re: Alternative.....Pop
December 06, 2007 06:44AM
Mats, these guys are worth a listen...

[cdbaby.com]

I'm a bit put off by the list of "marketing highlights", but I really like this CD. "The Fool" is almost perfect lush pop (same for "Feel My Heartbeat") with melodic choices that remind me somewhat of earlier Prefab Sprout. This band could use a lead guitarist to rough things up a bit without losing the general vibe. As it stands, the feel is a bit too samey through the full disc.

Compared to High Land, Hard Rain, maybe Silver Lakes comes off as a bit too polished and restrained. I admit to having missed completely on Seely (the singer/guitarist's former band), so maybe there should be some commentary on the flow from that band to this one. But as a debut, I thought this was filled with accomplished and strong songs as well as some clear promise for the future if they make a few improvements.



Post Edited (12-06-07 08:48)
Re: Message board help availability
December 06, 2007 06:51AM
As a small digression, it would be so, so useful for this BB to have a permanent reference to Paganizers incredibly useful "MESSAGE BOARD USER GUIDE" post (or a distillation thereof).

<[trouserpress.com];

I have to look that up every time I want to make a link active, as I'm incapable of remembering how on my own. If there were some kind of permanent link to that topic, I might go so far as to use italics now and then. I'd use them responsibly. I promise!



Post Edited (12-06-07 09:10)
Re: Alternative.....Pop
December 06, 2007 10:20PM
I'd say The Weakerthans for sure.
Anyone heard the newie?
Re: Alternative.....Pop
December 06, 2007 07:22AM
I've raved about them before, but if you're looking for the Aztec Camera/Trashcan Sinatras/Prefab Sprout type of stuff, I heartily recommend the Music Lovers, out of San Francisco. Think the Sinatras with a hearty amount of Scott Walker dolloped in. Matthew "Ted" Edwards is one of the best songwriters alive.

And, of course, the Sinatras are still around and still making great music.
Re: Alternative.....Pop
December 06, 2007 08:08AM
> As a small digression, it would be so, so useful for this BB to have a
> permanent reference to Paganizers incredibly useful "MESSAGE BOARD
> USER GUIDE" post (or a distillation thereof).

I just went to that page and saved it in Favorites. Rat is quite right; it's a very useful reference.
Re: Alternative.....Pop
December 06, 2007 12:08PM
The Pernice Brothers have saved alt-pop in the new millennium.
Re: Alternative.....Pop
December 06, 2007 08:09PM
I'd nominate Dogs Die in Hot Cars, except they broke up after one album.

The Weakerthans?
Re: Alternative.....Pop
December 07, 2007 07:10AM
DDiHC couldn't bear the pressure of such a gawdawful name.
Re: Alternative.....Pop
December 08, 2007 12:21AM
mats84forpres,

dude, i was thinkin this too today...

But then I remebered i had velvet crushes 'in the presence of greatness' album and forgot about grunge (and nirvana).

kurdt lives!



Post Edited (12-08-07 02:22)
Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.

Click here to login