Welcome! Log In Create A New Profile

Advanced

The Thrill Is Gone

The Thrill Is Gone
November 08, 2007 07:10AM
The first album by a favorite artist that you picked up more out of a sense of duty than from any feeling of excitement over its release. (This is different from, say, the first bad album - REM had two albums that I couldn't stand - MONSTER and HI-FI - before they ever reached the "Oh...there's a new REM album coming out, guess I've gotta pick that up sometime" stage. Most of these albums are really good - just the excitement for the artist has worn off.)

REM - REVEAL
Robyn Hitchcock - QUEEN ELVIS
Elvis Costello - MIGHTY LIKE A ROSE
Bob Mould - THE LAST DOG AND PONY SHOW
Tori Amos - TO VENUS AND BACK
Aimee Mann - LOST IN SPACE
Tom Petty - WILDFLOWERS
Cocteau Twins - FOUR CALENDAR CAFE
Bruce Cockburn - THE CHARITY OF NIGHT
David Bowie - NEVER LET ME DOWN
Re: The Thrill Is Gone
November 08, 2007 10:03AM
Agreement on a lot of these, although I made it through All This Useless Beauty before I dropped Costello from the list, and Monster immediately made me drop REM. I stayed with Hitchcock until A Star For Bram, but have jumped back on with Ole Tarantula (what a fantastic return to form!!!). I was discussing this with my wife the other day, how I used to "camp out" at record stores, waiting for certain bands to come out with new stuff, and how bad I felt that the amount of bands I would do that for now has dwindled to about 3-4. BTW, Prince lost me with Emancipation, and Richard Thompson with Mirror Blue.
Re: The Thrill Is Gone
November 08, 2007 12:12PM
Elvis Costello-Painted From Memory
They Might Be Giants-John Henry
Graham Parker-Acid Bubblegum
Re: The Thrill Is Gone
November 08, 2007 02:06PM
sonic youth - washing machine
rem - green
saints - all fools day
Re: The Thrill Is Gone
November 08, 2007 03:52PM
I think REM's Reveal is a classic example of this phenomenon. The entire world seemed to lose interest in REM at the same time with the release of this album. It was just such a non-event for a $70 million band. (Satch, if you place the turning point at Green, were you ever a really big fan?) Some others that come to mind:

Public Enemy - Revolverlution (best rap act ever but their recent acceleration in output amuses me since the thrill is so clearly gone)

Sleater-Kinney - one beat (would have sworn they were one of my favorite band, but could never get myself to buy this)

The Church - Priest=Aura (even though they eventually won me back with HOcool smiley

Prince - Graffiti Bridge (doing soundtracks accelerates overexposure)

Idlewild - Warnings/Promises
Wilco - A Ghost Is Born
The Fall - Cerebral Caustic

Re: The Thrill Is Gone
November 09, 2007 10:48AM

> (Satch, if you place the
> turning point at Green, were you ever a really big fan?)


they were my favorite band all through college (81-85) but by 1988 my interest in new rem was minimal. i bought green strictly out of habit. have recently gone back and picked up those post-green missing pieces, but it doesn't seem i missed much.

the more i think about it, though, document might've been the first one i bought just because it seemed the thing to do.
Re: The Thrill Is Gone
November 08, 2007 04:40PM
shit, I'm amazed
REM lost me at Fables of Reconstruction and the picked-up-for-dooty was Life's Rich Pageant. Never actually purchased another though somebody always gave me a tape.

I remember picking up Modern English Stop/Start out of duty and also Cure's Wish.

The question I have is...

Re: The Thrill Is Gone
November 08, 2007 10:31PM
SNUFF - NUMB NUTS
Re: The Thrill Is Gone
November 09, 2007 01:19PM
I've felt this way about most of Neil Young's records the past decade or so. I'm sometimes pleasantly surprised by my dutiful purchases (Living With War, Prairie Wind, even Greendale and Broken Arrow), but I haven't had a truly transcendent Neil experience since the Ragged Glory/Weld/Harvest Moon years.

Maybe the new one Chrome Dreams II will hit me where I live. I'll pick it up eventually.
Re: The Thrill Is Gone
November 09, 2007 09:28PM
Actually these are more albums where the excitement wore off AFTER I picked them up. Not that they're necessarily bad (w/some exceptions), but in keeping with the original question....

Ramones - Brain Drain. Shark jumped once and for all.

They Might Be Giants - Apollo 18 (title?)

Jesus & Mary Chain - Honey's Dead

Cure - Kiss Me Kiss Me Kiss Me

Siouxsie - Peepshow. People raved about this one and "Peek-a-Boo" is fab indeed, but the rest of it was "okay, but...". Beats the heck out of Superstition though.

Depeche Mode - the "Personal Jesus" single. "Never Let Me Down Again" from the previous album gave me hope, but afterwards it was pretty much Muzak for the Asses (okay not that bad, but I couldn't resist the pun).

Sonic Youth - Dirty
Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.

Click here to login