Welcome! Log In Create A New Profile

Advanced

Over The Rhine?!

Over The Rhine?!
October 05, 2007 09:47PM
In 1998, I saw Over The Rhine open for the Cowboy Junkies. They were one of the dullest bands I'd ever seen [and mind you, this is from a Cowboy Junkies fan!] and I promptly forgot about them.

But over the last couple of years, I've come across a number of blogs/posts where people claim Over The Rhine are truly fantastic. I've read enough of these claims that I now have to ask:

Really??



Post Edited (10-05-07 23:50)
Re: Over The Rhine?!
October 05, 2007 10:00PM
I don't know about "fantastic", but they were interesting for awhile there. If you have a chance to check out the live version of "If I'm Drowning", recorded in Holland in 1994 or so (it's on the BESIDES compilation), you might get sense of what the excitement was about. Or not.

To me, they kind of started to go down a Starbucks-sound dead end around the time they got hooked up with Cowboy Junkies (1997?). Guitarist Ric Hordinski left right about that time, and for my money it's been downhill since.

Although Karin Berquist's voice remains gloriously pristine.
Re: Over The Rhine?!
October 06, 2007 05:32AM
Bought "Eve" unheard on the strength of years of hearing critical raves about OTR. I really tried to like them, but BORING! And I like ambient music.

Admittedly it's a small sample set, as I never wanted to hear any of their other music.

I know they must have their fans, but my guess is that if they struck you as dull seen live, they'll strike you as dull on recordings.
Re: Over The Rhine?!
October 06, 2007 08:00AM
Paste magazine hyperventilates at the very thought of Over the Rhine, but I've never been able to get into them. Well, I guess "been able" is mis-stating it, since I've never really even attempted to get into them. For me, they just fall into that whole "very tasteful, glad you like 'em, guess they're okay but I can't listen to everything" category, along with people like Mary Gauthier and all those Pattys and Joshes that Paste is likewise ecstatic about.

I like the phrase "Pattys and Joshes." I used to call all that stuff "NPR music", but I think I'll start calling it Patty & Josh Music, in honor of Griffin, Larkin, Rouse, Ritter and the many other very, very talented songwriters I just don't have the time to be bothered with.

I prefer the very similar Innocence Mision. Karen Peris has a quirky enough voice to keep things interesting there.
Re: Over The Rhine?!
October 06, 2007 09:43AM
I like them OK. I thought "Films For Radio" was one of their highlights, and "Eve" was good also. I haven't followed them recently.
Re: Over The Rhine?!
October 08, 2007 08:52AM
I saw Over the Rhine as an opening act during the late '90s, and thought they were okay at the time. The next morning I could barely remember seeing them ... not the sign of a good band.

And please, no wisecracks about how much I might have ingested at the show, to make me that forgetful. Trust me, memory loss is not a side effect that I experience in such situations ... which has been a real shame, sometimes.

Re: Over The Rhine?!
October 08, 2007 09:25AM
The band and their fan club pitched themselves heavily to be on the TV show for which I work. So I listened to their latest disk.

Very tasteful, very well-crafted, very, very dull. Your first instinct was correct.
Re: Over The Rhine?!
October 08, 2007 10:12AM
Are you in Austin?
Re: Over The Rhine?!
October 08, 2007 11:14AM
Yup. 2 + 2 does indeed = 4.

Any specific questions should go to my e-mail address.



Post Edited (10-08-07 17:12)
Re: Over The Rhine?!
October 08, 2007 10:54AM
I received a review copy of Films for Radio years back and was really put off by it.
Re: Over The Rhine?!
October 08, 2007 12:26PM
Now I'm starting to feel badly enough for them to feel obligated to listen to them again.
Re: Over The Rhine?!
November 01, 2007 01:49PM
I happened onto this thread and thought I'd add my two cents.

I agree with the above posts, for the most part. Most Over The Rhine albums are filled with boring, meandering songs, embarrassing attempts at experimenting with/diversifying their sound, and overwrought lyrics and vocals - especially after Ric and Brian left.

However, I still think Good Dog Bad Dog is a fantastic album, and if you haven't listened to it, you should give it a try. The lyrics are much more subtle and literary, the vocals are tasteful rather Bjork-ishly bombastic, and the music has a nice stripped down, acoustic sound, with Ric's guitars adding flourishes here and there. It's a really beautiful, subdued, melancholy record. I'm always hoping that Over the Rhine will put another one of these out, and I think this is why their fans remain so faithful to the band.
Re: Over The Rhine?!
November 01, 2007 07:12PM
boring

saw a million times
Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.

Click here to login